Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

[Antonio]

on guava, i felt she was very open about not wanting to do much until D2. i dont think she would be that open as mafia and would instead try to at least force some minor reads. i think she'll be easier to figure out later, but tonally i think she's been honest

I don't see how it's townie to not contribute to the game. I understand waiting but I feel like everyone who is townie should be able to contribute during day 1.

There's also like her opinions are based on others people's current opinions.

 

[Damniel]

ok 1. Daniel I think you're asking the wrong question.

Looking back at ace's iso, I also thought that only having 2 scumreads meant anything, but I doubt that anyone here had teamreads in mind (especially since you asked them to toss out their early thoughts.) you don't see me asking volt if he thinks ~6 people~ are teamread.

2. I think dinosaurz is mafia.

So this actually has nothing to do with the reads. Just when I went back to ISO dino's game, none of it felt really direct to the game. It just felt like a lot of their posts were a direct response to the things that happen. Like. considering the amount of posts they have... all of it feels like filler.

I mean even their last post felt bad.

I mean they SAY they're coasting along with gut reads, but I just feel like they're posting... for the sake of posting, not necessarily because they always have something to say.

Which is generally a mafia thing.

from my experience as mafia when i did this game (and what my teammate did), is that we both marked each other as wolf and I marked both my teammates as wolves since i vocalized being null on them earlier and needed to stay consistent on "guilty until proven innocent". as someone who had their teammates in mind when I tried out that game, i think there could be something there

yes I agree that dino hasn't been contributing much or making any firm stances, but i dont get a sense that they're being guided on what to do. they just seem to be solo in not knowing what to do. if they're mafia they're playing the "IDK" card too hard

 

[Dinosaurz]

I’m here for a fun time not a long time folks XD

 

[epona]

the fact that Dinosaurz has continued posting the same way even after it's been mentioned earlier that his posts are pretty fluffy actually makes me town lean him a little bit now

like, if he was mafia, I feel like his posting style might've shifted subtly after that as an attempt to try to avoid suspicion if people were noticing it and he was posting filler on purpose to coast along, if that makes sense

yeah but some people (i.e. daniel) were townreading him for that same tone so i kind of disagree with this

 

[Dinosaurz]

I’ll try and improve my game and make a nice substantial post in the morning when I wake up

 

[Damniel]

I don't see how it's townie to not contribute to the game. I understand waiting but I feel like everyone who is townie should be able to contribute during day 1.

There's also like her opinions are based on others people's current opinions.

i can point you to several town players who found D1 useless and didn't want to do anything. Sometimes its hard to see the town motivation, but whats more important is the wolf motivation

 

[Dinosaurz]

Because it’s correct I really don’t know what to do lol and im scared to commit to reads in case they r wrong but I’ll try and do it properly

 

[Antonio]

yeah but some people (i.e. daniel) were townreading him for that same tone so i kind of disagree with this

You're disagreeing with somebody because someone else town read him for the same reason.

 

[epona]

You're disagreeing with somebody because someone else town read him for the same reason.

what

 

[Antonio]

i can point you to several town players who found D1 useless and didn't want to do anything. Sometimes its hard to see the town motivation, but whats more important is the wolf motivation

What about her opinions? Her opinions feel like copy points towards other people's current opinions.

 

[voltairenism]

You're disagreeing with somebody because someone else town read him for the same reason.

epona means that dino didnt have reason to change his behaviour based on sus because people were also townreading him for it

 

[Antonio]

what

That was supposed to have a question mark at the end

 

[epona]

what volt said

 

[Damniel]

What about her opinions? Her opinions feel like copy points towards other people's current opinions.

i didn't really get the sense of that so if you can point to exactly which points were just copied off, i can try to understand this better

 

[Antonio]

epona means that dino didnt have reason to change his behaviour based on sus because people were also townreading him for it

that wasn't implied in the message.

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

Unless I'm missing something

 

[voltairenism]

that wasn't implied in the message.

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

Unless I'm missing something

it kinda was

 

[Ace Marvel]

It's happening!​

 

[Antonio]

View attachment 321416

It's happening!​

Can you contribute something useful before I flip that **** on you...

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

epona means that dino didnt have reason to change his behaviour based on sus because people were also townreading him for it

So, she's stated that Dino didn't have a reason to flip behavior so she disagree with the read?

 

[Damniel]

i do see the points people are trying to make on dinosaurz so they should not be consensus town that quick. but if town, it just feels like a very easy target to hop on

 

[voltairenism]

Can you contribute something useful before I flip that **** on you...

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

So, she's stated that Dino didn't have a reason to flip behavior so she disagree with the read?

idk why im discussing this for annie tho

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

View attachment 321416

It's happening!​

omg ill omgsus vote dan brb