Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

[Antonio]

Damniel is giving me weird vibes, like he is just relaxed and no questioning every single sentence in this game... red flag

Isn't it a bit too early to be coming to such a conclusion?

 

[Damniel]

Damniel is giving me weird vibes, like he is just relaxed and no questioning every single sentence in this game... red flag

am i not supposed to be relaxed? like why should be feeling differently

we need to get the game started somehow

 

[Ace Marvel]

I said what I said.

 

[Antonio]

am i not supposed to be relaxed? like why should be feeling differently

we need to get the game started somehow

I don't see how the last sentence is relevant. How does being relaxed correlate with you starting the game?

Post automatically merged: Sep 20, 2020

I said what I said.

There hasn't been much to be questioning for, though.

 

[Damniel]

I don't see how the last sentence is relevant. How does being relaxed correlate with you starting the game?

ace also said that i was questioning everything so far. im starting off the game by questioning (im assuming the no was a typo since i have in fact been questioning alot)

 

[Antonio]

ace also said that i was questioning everything so far. im starting off the game by questioning (im assuming the no was a typo since i have in fact been questioning alot)

I don't think you started off the game with questioning. You started it off with a geoni voted.

 

[voltairenism]

Damniel is giving me weird vibes, like he is just relaxed and no questioning every single sentence in this game... red flag

haha chaotic ace go brrrr

 

[Hikari]

idk it feels kinda weird for damniel to be targeting a guy who hasn't even posted anything yet?? like geoni hasn't even posted yet lol.

all i said in regards to geoni is that was that i found it weird how dino randomly mentioned us, but like i said he probably didn't mean anything by it. damniel kinda just took that comment and ran with it imo, which is kinda weird imo

 

[Damniel]

I don't think you started off the game with questioning. You started it off with a geoni voted.

yes, then questioning after that. do you think this means something?

Post automatically merged: Sep 20, 2020

idk it feels kinda weird for damniel to be targeting a guy who hasn't even posted anything yet?? like geoni hasn't even posted yet lol.

all i said in regards to geoni is that was that i found it weird how dino randomly mentioned us, but like i said he probably didn't mean anything by it. damniel kinda just took that comment and ran with it imo, which is kinda weird imo

how did i target geoni? i voted him at the very start and have said nothing on him aside from it not being impossible he can be wolf three times in a row

 

[Antonio]

yes, then questioning after that. do you think this means something?

No, it doesn't mean nothing. I'm just asking questions.

 

[Hikari]

yes, then questioning after that. do you think this means something?

Post automatically merged: Sep 20, 2020

how did i target geoni? i voted him at the very start and have said nothing on him aside from it not being impossible he can be wolf three times in a row

idk i guess it just feels a bit odd to throw a vote at someone when they haven't even said anything yet, followed by trying to convince people that they could be wolf again. but i guess none of us have much to go off at the moment

Post automatically merged: Sep 20, 2020

*much to go off of at the moment

 

[Damniel]

idk i guess it just feels a bit odd to throw a vote at someone when they haven't even said anything yet, followed by trying to convince people that they could be wolf again. but i guess none of us have much to go off at the moment

Post automatically merged: Sep 20, 2020

*much to go off of at the moment

that's fair to think my vote is weird, but i was responding to ace's claim that he did not believe geoni could be wolf again, when it is possible. any thoughts on ace's belief that geoni can't be mafia 3 times in a row? he also has claimed to had been town 20 times in a row, so im unsure why he thinks geoni can't possibly be wolf again

 

[epona]

@epona given you were teamed with ace recently, what do you think of his odd town lean on geoni?

i don't think... anything?
this is a weird question, i don't see how me recently being mafia with ace gives me any special insight into his thought process this game although i do think saying he's townleaning geoni is a stretch

re: daniel's vote on geoni i don't really think much of it. dan's just come back from MU champs where random voting for no reason is pretty standard so it's prob just a culture clash thing

 

[Antonio]

that's fair to think my vote is weird, but i was responding to ace's claim that he did not believe geoni could be wolf again, when it is possible. any thoughts on ace's belief that geoni can't be mafia 3 times in a row? he also has claimed to had been town 20 times in a row, so im unsure why he thinks geoni can't possibly be wolf again

Yes but why are we having all this discussion about Geoni if he hasn't even arrived to the game yet. Talking about possibilities are basically irrelevant.

 

[Damniel]

i don't think... anything?
this is a weird question, i don't see how me recently being mafia with ace gives me any special insight into his thought process this game although i do think saying he's townleaning geoni is a stretch

re: daniel's vote on geoni i don't really think much of it. dan's just come back from MU champs where random voting for no reason is pretty standard so it's prob just a culture clash thing

well partners tend to get to talk alot and get a deeper look in their partner's thought process when asking for advice what to do. like playing a game already knowing he was mafia should give you that perspective

 

[Hikari]

that's fair to think my vote is weird, but i was responding to ace's claim that he did not believe geoni could be wolf again, when it is possible. any thoughts on ace's belief that geoni can't be mafia 3 times in a row? he also has claimed to had been town 20 times in a row, so im unsure why he thinks geoni can't possibly be wolf again

no thoughts really on ace's response, he's just thinking from a statistical standpoint about it, i suppose. but as you said, it's not impossible, especially since each game is independent from the other, so I agree we shouldn't be determining people's potential of being wolf simply due to past trends.

 

[Damniel]

Yes but why are we having all this discussion about Geoni if he hasn't even arrived to the game yet. Talking about possibilities are basically irrelevant.

it think its interesting that ace already said it was unlikely to be geoni when he also has claimed to had played mafia for months without landing wolf until recently. he was using probability to assume geoni was unlikely to be wolf even though its still possible and he's been on an even more unlikely streak

 

[epona]

well partners tend to get to talk alot and get a deeper look in their partner's thought process when asking for advice what to do. like playing a game already knowing he was mafia should give you that perspective

and if you read the mafia quicktopic for that game you'll see we made a point of not talking at all for that exact reason
so idk

 

[Damniel]

what im saying is that using probability to try to clear someone is very odd and especially odd coming from ace

Post automatically merged: Sep 20, 2020

and if you read the mafia quicktopic for that game you'll see we made a point of not talking at all for that exact reason
so idk

i didn't read that qt tbh, but was a good question to ask

 

[epona]

i think this probability conversation is not the hill to die on

i got crucified once for making a similar comment about the odds of someone randing mafia twice in a row. it's a pretty human conclusion to come to even if it doesn't make statistical sense

i rlly just don't think it's that deep