Mafia Jailbreak Mafia Game Thread - Game Over, Town Wins!

[Arstotzkan]

No C was correct. She was acting wishy-washy as ****, and meta arguments honestly kind of suck? But if you're going to go by meta, she was ****ing pissed and was like "tell me what I have to do" to Ness. That isn't giving up. She only gave up when she got told to cut that crap.

Can we talk about how scummy Toads is tho

- - - Post Merge - - -

Can I post...?

Yup we can post
Btw Tea voting Maddie there isn't a scum-tell. Self-pres is ideal regardless of alignment

 

[Dinosaurz]

Oh cool. Yeah I think looking back, towards the end maddie definitely did seem scummy. I was just too drunk to comprehend anything tbh lol.

 

[Arstotzkan]

Oh cool. Yeah I think looking back, towards the end maddie definitely did seem scummy. I was just too drunk to comprehend anything tbh lol.

Don't play mafia and be drunk kids!

 

[radical6]

No C was correct. She was acting wishy-washy as ****, and meta arguments honestly kind of suck? But if you're going to go by meta, she was ****ing pissed and was like "tell me what I have to do" to Ness. That isn't giving up. She only gave up when she got told to cut that crap.

Can we talk about how scummy Toads is tho

- - - Post Merge - - -

Yup we can post
Btw Tea voting Maddie there isn't a scum-tell. Self-pres is ideal regardless of alignment

i guess

also arent you maddie. im confused

 

[Arstotzkan]

i guess

also arent you maddie. im confused

No, I'm Kat. Maddie is Ilumnie, the person who got lynched in Cell A.

 

[Dinosaurz]

Dino losing it at the end was annoying but it honestly reads unraveling town which he is prone to.

Toad ngl I was rlly tipsy also

I?ll probably read the thread soon to catch up on stuff. I?m probably gonna struggle more with my reads since more people=more confusion 4 me.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Well I’m gonna guess since game still on there was mislynch somewhere which eh given. Guess try and find out where? And start from there? I hope we at least got 1/3 but eh idk

 

[PunchyTheCat]

i believe i'm allowed to post now?

sorry my power was out for almost all of my cell time and i couldnt get on

i barely read the thread

if we killed the new player in my cell i think he was town and genuinely confused as to why people were questioning him, his vote placement talk felt like a genuine thought a new player would have as town, as its probably their only power to be used during the day

i'll have to look at the other two people in my cell (i think one was toads and the other was another old player i cant remember)

also time on mu has changed my playstyle slightly, if this was two years ago i'd have posted this in at least 6 different posts

lets get this started

 

[Arstotzkan]

tbh that's honestly a question I think we could all do with answering for each cell: do you believe they got their lynch right, and if not, who is scum amongst them?

A: I think we got it right. If not, it'd have to be Tea (Liam is literally bleeding town), but I feel like Tea was just noob town. I think Maddie had some townie tells, so I'm not 100% confident it's right, but I'm decently confident.

B: No way in hell. That chat was a wasteland. Funny bc that chat was predicted to be the noisy one lol. I think town!Toads would have pushed for way more conversation and probed people with questions way more than he did. He seemed so excited for things and then he just... didn't. This goes for Panda to some extent too, but I remember her doing some things that I was like "there is no way scum does this it'd be way too careless". Like jumping onto Punchy as a hunch read. The reason in the end for lynching Rosie was weak as ****, but it looks like it passes since "nothing else happened". Please. Y'all could have made something more out of that day.

C: See above; that's right. If it is wrong, it's radical I think, but I feel pretty damn confident you guys got that one right.

 

[toadsworthy]

I didn't read any of Cell C because I've just felt bum-crap awful today, needed to be productive and wasn't... I don't think I'll have much time to devote until monday night after work. My phrasing and everything was not the best I'll admit because I was on mobile most the time

 

[Arstotzkan]

oh hey punchy your cell reeks

- - - Post Merge - - -

I didn't read any of Cell C because I've just felt bum-crap awful today, needed to be productive and wasn't... I don't think I'll have much time to devote until monday night after work. My phrasing and everything was not the best I'll admit because I was on mobile most the time

Oof, hope you feel better

 

[PunchyTheCat]

alright i actually read toads's posts

1. he pushed rosetti WAY too hard, he's expressed not appreciating placeholder votes in the past but he was pretty excessive in this one (in his defence it was a little weird of a vote)

2. I think he was trying to push the easiest lynch that he could, i believe he was 'planting seeds of doubt' in me(someone circa 2018) in stating the hunch in his first post, and then immediately pushing the new player after he voted me

3. his posts feel tonally off

4. he's acting like a victim (specifically #270)

 

[Aquari]

Holy heck is there alot of stuff to catch up on, gimme a sec to gather my 2 braincells and read back on the last 2 cells

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Toad ngl I was rlly tipsy also

I?ll probably read the thread soon to catch up on stuff. I?m probably gonna struggle more with my reads since more people=more confusion 4 me.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Well I?m gonna guess since game still on there was mislynch somewhere which eh given. Guess try and find out where? And start from there? I hope we at least got 1/3 but eh idk

this is town

 

[toadsworthy]

B: No way in hell. That chat was a wasteland. Funny bc that chat was predicted to be the noisy one lol. I think town!Toads would have pushed for way more conversation and probed people with questions way more than he did. He seemed so excited for things and then he just... didn't. This goes for Panda to some extent too, but I remember her doing some things that I was like "there is no way scum does this it'd be way too careless". Like jumping onto Punchy as a hunch read. The reason in the end for lynching Rosie was weak as ****, but it looks like it passes since "nothing else happened". Please. Y'all could have made something more out of that day.

so I'm scum because I basically did what i could following what you expect but it wasn't..... enough? when I didn't even have a person there. I probed as much as I was given... but like what else could I have done. Punchy was non existent and Panda was being town from what I could tell. Panda is very avoidant t okay anything as scum, and she seemed more confident in telling people. Rosie seemed like panicked mafia. Punchy could very well be the scum in ours too, but I wasn't about to just let Rosie snap vote an inactive (off a convo me and panda started I may add), then let it run to that sorry that is scummy to me.

I was originally slated to be in Cell A which worked much better for my schedule, so yeah it was not as good of a time because I had a friend here staying with me. They literally were like what are you typing while we waited for our table at dinner.

For cell A I was between Kat and Ilunie for scum. Liam was obvious town i agree, and Tea just seemed like apathetic to anything which I don't see her do as scum.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

2. I think he was trying to push the easiest lynch that he could, i believe he was 'planting seeds of doubt' in me(someone circa 2018) in stating the hunch in his first post, and then immediately pushing the new player after he voted me

i should expand on this

i believe that toads was intending to have me lynched because he thought i would be an easy target

but then the new player decided to push me after toads's hunch. toads would have thought it would be easier to kill him, as i wasnt present and panda would be more likely to latch onto my wagon

 

[toadsworthy]

alright i actually read toads's posts

1. he pushed rosetti WAY too hard, he's expressed not appreciating placeholder votes in the past but he was pretty excessive in this one (in his defence it was a little weird of a vote)

2. I think he was trying to push the easiest lynch that he could, i believe he was 'planting seeds of doubt' in me(someone circa 2018) in stating the hunch in his first post, and then immediately pushing the new player after he voted me

3. his posts feel tonally off

4. he's acting like a victim (specifically #270)

1. Well when I pushed her on her placeholder vote it just seemed like word vomit

2. the easiest lynch would've been on you.... so like, I don't agree with this. If anything I was the easiest lynch because I was the most vocal about anything. All we had to start was an offing placeholder vote and it seemed more out of place than anything.

3. ok, hopefully you explain why later

4. 270 explains my whole thought process on rosie and why I thought she was the scummiest between her and panda.

 

[Arstotzkan]

I was originally slated to be in Cell A which worked much better for my schedule, so yeah it was not as good of a time because I had a friend here staying with me. They literally were like what are you typing while we waited for our table at dinner.

Why didn't you ask to switch cell times with Dad? He said that was an option. Don't think it's AI either way but c'mon man use some of that networking social strength you used with me and dad in signups to do the day that fits you best.

It felt like there were people there, but they just didn't know what to say (excluding punchy who was ****ing dead). You showed a lot of excitement and you were going to go into Cell A which I think was good, but then the way you let it drop when people were like "eh" bothered me. Like it's fine to drop it, but you better have a conversation to start in its place.

 

[toadsworthy]

i should expand on this

i believe that toads was intending to have me lynched because he thought i would be an easy target

but then the new player decided to push me after toads's hunch. toads would have thought it would be easier to kill him, as i wasnt present and panda would be more likely to latch onto my wagon

If I intended to have you lynched, I would've shut my mouth and let placeholder votes spill overtime and lynch someone who gave us nothing. Why would I sneakily do all that bs and give myself such a big spotlight

 

[Arstotzkan]

"People weren't there" I get it wasn't the most active cell, but still, I don't remember you even trying to start conversation really after that initial attempt to look into A and giving your thoughts on it. There wasn't much more you could have said, sure, but why not press the others on their thoughts?

 

[toadsworthy]

Why didn't you ask to switch cell times with Dad? He said that was an option. Don't think it's AI either way but c'mon man use some of that networking social strength you used with me and dad in signups to do the day that fits you best.

It felt like there were people there, but they just didn't know what to say (excluding punchy who was ****ing dead). You showed a lot of excitement and you were going to go into Cell A which I think was good, but then the way you let it drop when people were like "eh" bothered me. Like it's fine to drop it, but you better have a conversation to start in its place.

I believe I went into my cell with a conversation.... tell me what you thought of Cell A and panda gave me one line about it. So I was like wow that didn't work. I don't know if Rosie answered the question or not, but she sure as hell put a placeholder vote down quick enough

- - - Post Merge - - -

"People weren't there" I get it wasn't the most active cell, but still, I don't remember you even trying to start conversation really after that initial attempt to look into A and giving your thoughts on it. There wasn't much more you could have said, sure, but why not press the others on their thoughts?

So I did have an initial conversation.... but it just wasn't enough for you. So I did exactly what you said I should.... but I should've done more? with one person absent and my initial efforts being avoided or one-liner