Mafia Janitorial 2.0! Day ends June 22nd 2020, 5 PM PST.

[Feferily]

ok so let me lay out all the scenarios here.

aerious is never getting lynched. she is mechanically confirmed town

1. you lynch me today
> i flip town
> someone dies during the night
> remy 'investigates' someone tonight, but you can't trust the result either way
> d4 is 2v1
> good luck

2. we lynch tom today
2a.
> tom flips mafia: gg. town win
2b.
> tom flips town
> someone dies during the night
> remy 'investigates' someone tonight, but you can't trust the result either way
> d4 is 2v1
> good luck
2c.
> tom flips town
> we follow teddy's plan: all power roles target me
> remy dies before they can confirm result on me. everyone lynches me
> teddy wins as maf

3. we lynch teddy today
3a.
> teddy flips mafia: gg. town win
3b.
> teddy flips doctor
> someone dies during the night
> remy 'investigates' someone tonight, but you can't trust the result either way
> d4 is 2v1
> good luck
> remy has to be scum in this scenario bc if remy and teddy are both PRs there's no way they're still alive

4. we lynch remy today
4a.
> remy flips mafia: gg. town win
4b.
> remy flips cop. this sucks but it's fine bc if they live we can't trust their result anyway
> someone dies during the night
> d4 is 2v1
> good luck



if teddy is town, he dies tonight in all scenarios as far as i'm concerned. the player pool is too small so the chance of NK is too big. teddy can't self-heal


my vote stays on remy

Even if you can't trust my report it isn't the only thing you'll have to go on. You'll also have the information from the eliminate (which hopefully is mafia and we win) and whoever the last mafia chooses to eliminate during the night. My report will only be adding onto that.

Killing me will only get you 4B.

Not killing me will get you a cop report if I don't get killed during the night. Eitherway, I think town has a big chance of winning. As long as doctor protects Aerious (which we're hoping that one of you three is doctor now.)

Right?

Post automatically merged: Jun 25, 2020

Also, Epona, I'll try and form a better defense as to why you're wrong but I genuinely am cop. A dumbass cop but I did still get town two mafia kills. Even if I wasn't sure about one of them, lol. And I will try and secure town victory with every bit of my ability, even if it means being killed now.

I won't vote for myself, because that won't help though, but I will be voting in towns interest.

 

[Aerious]

Even if you can't trust my report it isn't the only thing you'll have to go on. You'll also have the information from the eliminate (which hopefully is mafia and we win) and whoever the last mafia chooses to eliminate during the night. My report will only be adding onto that.

Killing me will only get you 4B.

Not killing me will get you a cop report if I don't get killed during the night. Eitherway, I think town has a big chance of winning. As long as doctor protects Aerious (which we're hoping that one of you three is doctor now.)

Right?

doctor absolutely should not protect me. that’s beyond foolish. me dying provides a 100% correct report
remy not voting has instilled doubt in the legitimacy of report. i’m going to reread everything later and ask more questions

 

[epona]

What I’m gonna say is probably the most anti-town thing there is right now, but I wanna lynch either Ace or Remy. We’re at the stage where neither role is entirely needed to win, but both still being alive is a bit mind-boggling to me. I just don’t know and I don’t like PRs that don’t die as expected. WIFOM maybe, but whoever it is might be banking on it.

i agree
lynching me or tom solves nothing bc it's vanilla/vanilla

the 2 PRs should not still be alive. one of them is faking

 

[Aerious]

i agree
lynching me or tom solves nothing bc it's vanilla/vanilla

the 2 PRs should not still be alive. one of them is faking

we don’t know who died n0. it could’ve been vanilla and one of the vanillas trying to leave pr. it’s a huge liability, which doesn’t make much sense

 

[Feferily]

doctor absolutely should not protect me. that’s beyond foolish. me dying provides a 100% correct report
remy not voting has instilled doubt in the legitimacy of report. i’m going to reread everything later and ask more questions

Not voting?

 

[Aerious]

Not voting?

i never once said i’m not voting. i’m waiting to make a vote based on the entirety of this thread, not just today

 

[Feferily]

i agree
lynching me or tom solves nothing bc it's vanilla/vanilla

the 2 PRs should not still be alive. one of them is faking

I at least have proof of being cop other than just saying that I've been protected when the 'doctor' could just be pretending.

Post automatically merged: Jun 25, 2020

i never once said i’m not voting. i’m waiting to make a vote based on the entirety of this thread, not just today

No, I asked why you said I wasn't voting. Sorry I wasn't clear xD I'm voting. I said so.

 

[Aerious]

I at least have proof of being cop other than just saying that I've been protected when the 'doctor' could just be pretending.

Post automatically merged: Jun 25, 2020

No, I asked why you said I wasn't voting. Sorry I wasn't clear xD I'm voting. I said so.

i meant voting as in sending in an action, soz for lack of clarity

 

[Feferily]

i meant voting as in sending in an action, soz for lack of clarity

Ooh okay, yeah that makes more sense

 

[epona]

we don’t know who died n0. it could’ve been vanilla and one of the vanillas trying to leave pr. it’s a huge liability, which doesn’t make much sense

tom and i both had a big chance of being inspected last night. neither of us could predict remy not sending an action in.
you lynch me/tom today, and if one of us flips town, it tells you nothing

the two claimed PRs of doctor and cop cannot co-exist for this long. one of them is faking

i actually not even care anymore this is just annoying me now do what u want im not taking my vote off remy

 

[Feferily]

tom and i both had a big chance of being inspected last night. neither of us could predict remy not sending an action in.
you lynch me/tom today, and if one of us flips town, it tells you nothing

the two claimed PRs of doctor and cop cannot co-exist for this long. one of them is faking

i actually not even care anymore this is just annoying me now do what u want im not taking my vote off remy

The last mindset is a bit unfair to me, ngl.

I'm voting for Ace. He's the only one that, besides Aerious, I had little chance of inspecting again. If I'm the one who gets eliminated during the vote, fine, but please focus Ace after.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

we don’t know who died n0. it could’ve been vanilla and one of the vanillas trying to leave pr. it’s a huge liability, which doesn’t make much sense

A huge liability sure, but this is a game of risks. Even if we end up wrong, we have the voting records and we have the entire thread. Eliminating Remy or Ace nets us the most information and frankly, even if it it’s the vanillas I trust you enough to be able to make the right call when it comes down to it.

 

[epona]

The last mindset is a bit unfair to me, ngl.

I'm voting for Ace. He's the only one that, besides Aerious, I had little chance of inspecting again. If I'm the one who gets eliminated during the vote, fine, but please focus Ace after.

how is it unfair i have broken my back pushing a case on u all day i think it is extremely fair of me to vote for you

 

[Feferily]

how is it unfair i have broken my back pushing a case on u all day i think it is extremely fair of me to vote for you

No, no. The wagon is fine since you seem to genuinely believe it. But the mindset of "doesn't matter what happens my vote stays".

Post automatically merged: Jun 25, 2020

I have more genuine evidence that I am cop. Doctor has only his own claim that he's protected me when he could have been the one choosing to not eliminate me this whole time. I've gotten two mafia members down already. Trust me with the third.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

No, no. The wagon is fine since you seem to genuinely believe it. But the mindset of "doesn't matter what happens my vote stays".

Post automatically merged: Jun 25, 2020

I have more genuine evidence that I am cop. Doctor has only his own claim that he's protected me when he could have been the one choosing to not eliminate me this whole time. I've gotten two mafia members down already. Trust me with the third.

But have you though? You “inspected” Ace and he returned town, so the only other choice was going to be Guava. Not that hard a choice there, whereas we can’t prove you’ve been inspecting just like we can’t prove Ace has been protecting.

 

[Ace Marvel]

I'm voting for Ace. He's the only one that, besides Aerious, I had little chance of inspecting again. If I'm the one who gets eliminated during the vote, fine, but please focus Ace after.

Scum detected, I know I can prove it, but me knowing that I'm the doctor, means anyone trying to kill me should be considered scum.

 

[epona]

No, no. The wagon is fine since you seem to genuinely believe it. But the mindset of "doesn't matter what happens my vote stays".

Post automatically merged: Jun 25, 2020

I have more genuine evidence that I am cop. Doctor has only his own claim that he's protected me when he could have been the one choosing to not eliminate me this whole time. I've gotten two mafia members down already. Trust me with the third.

the only 'evidence' you have is your read on volt, which 100% could have been bussing and setting heyden up for a miselimination

you didn't kill guava, you got a townread on ace which means basically nothing considering the lawyer was still in play. i didn't believe it, and people ended up voting for guava mostly bc of her weird gameplay and doc claim, not because of your inspection

the 'evidence' you have is entirely self-manufactured. none of the rest of us has access to it. you and ace, on a base level, are as believable as each other
what ace DOES have is that he didn't 'forget' to send in an action that would have solved the game. you did. and the only person that benefits from a no-inspection last night is scum fakeclaiming cop

i am tired and frustrated and my mind will not change on this soz

 

[Ace Marvel]

I hate power roles, too much responsibility. I like vanilla chaotic me.

 

[Aerious]

i actually believe ace is town. i don’t think i’m going to change my mind on that

 

[Feferily]

But have you though? You “inspected” Ace and he returned town, so the only other choice was going to be Guava. Not that hard a choice there, whereas we can’t prove you’ve been inspecting just like we can’t prove Ace has been protecting.

Incorrect. The rest told me my read didn't mean much because Lawyer was still alive.

Post automatically merged: Jun 25, 2020

i actually believe ace is town. i don’t think i’m going to change my mind on that

That's unfortunate. You're killing cop.