Jocks are very "meh" to me. Not very picky with many of them, and would typically take any of them that aren't in my D tier, but I have a soft spot for Pierce for being one of my first villagers ever in the AC series.
So... not my favorite character type. Though Buck is my starter villager in NH and he has grown on me. The rest can go, though I would not hate to let B tier stay for a while.