Smug, maybe? Then again, I haven't had much interaction with smug villagers. I talk to mine (Lionel) once a day, but I really want him to move out and replace him with someone else.
I would say jock since they really do seem to have a one track mind, but from my experience, they're so friendly. Jitters may give me two or three gifts a day.
I find pretty much all of them likable in their own way. I'm not a very big fan of jocks, though. Never been a big fan of sports and it's all they ever talk about.
Normal villagers are too vanilla for me. They're too boring. Every time I get pinged by Alice now, I get annoyed as she always goes on about that identical personality magazine quiz.
I kind of wish I could change my answer now because I've changed my mind. As I stated in my original post, I don't hate any of the personalities, but I chose jocks because I thought I would get tired of having too many in my town.
However, I ended up with two jocks in Nocturne (Antonio and Sterling) and I love them both. Having two of them doesn't get on my nerves at all because they're kind of funny.
So I think if I could change my answer in the poll, I would say normal is now at the bottom of my list. They have some very cute villagers but their dialog is some of the most bland and repetitive that I've encountered in the newer games. So one normal villager in my town is plenty.
I could never stand Uchis, especially in NL. I've still got war flashbacks with Shari and how unpleasant she was. She was so rude. They're so abrasive and snarky but not in the same charming way as Snooties with their "high-society" flavor. They're a bit better in NH but I still would rather go completely without them on my island. It also doesn't help that I find most of them to be either boring in design at best or absolutely ugly at worst.
It's jocks. I don't really like any of their designs beside a couple of them. The only reason as of now I have Sly in my town is because I do like camo and I need to get the fire pit pwp. Once I get it I can't really say if I will keep him or not.