ok, well I can't get to ISO more of Ninja, so here... I don't feel like this is my best work, but I'm getting tired of working on these tbh. I've flip flopped a lot of stuff and alignments while going through the thread. I did just re-read most of it. If something sounds weird, I can clarify. I want to vote for Trundle today though. I feel like I couldn't find the right words for certain things, but at least you can see my general thoughts about everyone so far, and I hope I have made up for my lack of existence since this started.
Kallie ? Lord help us if Kallie is scum, because I don?t think anyone of us will catch her. Going back to RQS her answers feel really genuine and not scripted or trying to hide anything (unlike most others this game) and her effort so far to me doesn?t feel like it is fabricated for like mafia use. Just like my trust in Dolby last game, I?m going to trust her for this game.
Dolby ? Copy Paste from earlier. the one thing that is sticking out to me is Dolby's scum leans list. There is no way all the scum are in that list without a more experienced player to balance it out (fire ninja I know has played a lot of games, but is still "new" if you get what I'm saying). Also Dolby takes a sentence out of every reads list to remind people why he thinks I'm town-leaning, despite me not really having any credibility for it tbh. I think its because he sees me saying I'm going to post reads and come back, knows I'm town, knows I will make myself look townier (when I actually follow through with my promises) and is trying to beat everyone to the punch. If this all makes sense. Dolby is a very smart player, and I don't get the same vibes as last game in this game, something feels way more calculated. His defense of ?well I don?t think zendel would follow that model? feels weak to me. I think he would know that a very experienced player would have to be on the mafia team, and I bet he is that person.
Ness ?you have been acting really suspicious so far tbh. The jump on Jacob for his mistake was weird, but I don?t think you would?ve been so committed to lynching him if you were scum. Were missing your trademark aggressive scumhunt day 1, but the exchange between you and Trundle doesn?t seem staged. While Trundle has bussed scummates before, I don?t see it as being characteristic of you. I also think your change in effort is because you have real-life stuff happening too.
Jacob → Daniel ? is an idiot for thinking Bowie was in the game, no point in hashing this out more. But I tend to make my slip-ups like that when I?m town, then regretting the heck out of them (see Mystic Messenger where I said some stupid things) and that early in his first few posts, he wouldn?t have been so careless. Daniel seems fine so far.
Fireninja1 ? lol, you did the same thing as Jacob and then agreed to lynch him for it. As well as, sussed Jacob for talking about Bowie who hadn?t posted when Kermittea did the exact same thing about Trundle, but you didn?t mention that. Your push on Trundle after Day 1 feels more genuine though and I can agree more with this train of thought than the start of day 1.
SensaiGallade ? of all the coasters, you are the biggest one. In the Jacob mistake thing, you joined in on the convo and raised suspicions about it, but didn?t seem very convinced to do anything regarding it. Nothing else is very town progressive, just whining and defending yourself.
Trundler ? A brash apple is a scary apple. His current posts remind me of when we were on mafia together in Steven Universe and he really didn?t give a crap about what anybody thought. However, I can understand his frustration he has voiced , hence why I had him as null first and completely understand if that?s the root of his current behavior. Claimed Townie: Kukui. When we got safe claims in SU2, he was very quick to use it. The fact that you are so eagerly trying to get people to see that claim as town-aligning for you is scummy after I remembered this. Looking at Cleb/Trundle as far as standpoint goes they had opposing views on a lot of stuff, so I could see him targeting him, so could be why he could?ve targeted him. All of this just isn?t sitting well with me when looking at Trundle in this game. Exchange between him and Ness stuck out as scum v town. I would probably want to lynch him today, because I think it can be telling of a lot of other people in this game too.
Kirbystarship ? Kirby feels like he is trying to contribute in his own little way. I think with him, he overly tries to scumhunt as town, but he gets sussed a lot because idk, its not very good? He usually just subtlely goes along with whatever when he is scum. Theres more of him generating new topics than last game.
Farobi ? I feel like you are just lazy a lot of the times. However, some of the posts and topics you talk about don?t seem very mafia aligned. If there is a 3rd party, my guess would be its you but I don?t think we have any, so I bet its just I haven?t played with you much.
ItookYourWaffles ? I?m guessing its my unfamiliarity with you, but I see your effort, but certain things also don?t sit well with me. Your posts sometimes feel like like hollow content/ posting to be seen, but its not really town progressive.
Chick ? the minimal effort is disconcerting, and by far the easiest ploy to coast as mafia especially given all the other things that went on in this game so far. I don?t want to just say, minimal effort/coasting noob scum, but that?s what it is looking like.
Two biggest scum-leads are Trundle and Dolby, looking for a Trundle lynch as I said earlier.
- - - Post Merge - - -
I would vote him now, if I could get to the thread
