Here's my reads/summary of whats happened so far
Hayden- The little contradictions about his activity/play style this game are sticking out to me. Stating in his RQS that he couldn't be bothered this game, then turning around and saying he wants to take it seriously.
4. What's your playstyle like? I try to mix it up but tbh I cbf this game
no jk i sorta wanna take this game srsly so pls let me be ^.~
but other than that i think he is playing normally for his town meta him coming out of left field with rando reads and votes early in the game isn't weird behavior for him.
Endless- It's always hard for me to completely trust Abe he is very sly with his words and intelligent about the game enough to pass himself off as a "town leader" when he really isn't a town member at all, he's helpfulness towards the newer players is nice but don't let him pull a cloth over your eyes, hold him to his
Mogyay- I feel like she is playing as town rn, as scum she usually hides a little more in the shadows, but her willingness to contribute and question players, makes me trust her as town.
Tom- I also have a hard time trusting Tom, he usually plays in a very detached way, where it seems like he doesn't wanna help town so i usually end up scum reading him, i would like for him to explain the No Lynch idea, so i can better understand where he's coming from. UPDATE* says the No Lynch was a joke... hmm... was it though ?
Athena- She hasn't contribute much, mostly filler about roles and being "bussed" or "driven" she did do this tho that stuck out of me im not completely sure she said it just for the lolz or not.
Oh, my bussed was Night 0 I think. Sorry!
And as for Wise/Godot... I think he is fairly new to this (and not frequent her as I recall) so I don't think lynching him at this moment will be... Wise!
Jokes aside, is it possible if you fill me in on anything important? It is kinda hard to cross-examine around twenty people at once!
Not only the defending or Wise but also it would be WISE to read back and form your own opinions so we can get a read on you rather than just taking anyones word for whats happened so far.
Duck- The refusal to participate in the RQS was strange to me, I mean it's only 6-7 harmless questions, the hesitation to answer them and the fear of being lynched for it makes me feel like they have something to hide.
I don't want to follow
The system
if this gets myself lynched D:
also they seem to have this unwillingness to be cooperative.
Why not? The answer is quite simple.
I was lazy and didn't feel like checking.
Done.
I was busy and didn't feel like making a post
To me these just seem like half a$$ excuse as to why you are being vague.
Daniel- I would like some kind of read post from him before EoD if thats at all possible, his activity is high which is good but most of the post are either tearing other peoples post down or filler, so i need more substance.
Toad- His little grammar feud with Duck, is usual Toad, he gets emotional while scum hunting and im town reading him for it.
Chrystina- I think she is following her usually town meta and i can also see an improvement, less tunneling and more logic, i like it. Town reading her as of now.
Entropy- Not sure what she's up to, she's usually a lot more helpful from what i can remember, but sometimes she doesn't make decent post til later in the game, so for now im keeping an eye on her, if she doesn't show a greater interest in scum hunting soon, ill have to move her to my scum reads.
Cpu- Hasn't posted anything thus far, unlike her normal behavior, I'm starting to get annoyed/suspicious.
Curry- I like his long post addressing most of the active players, makes me feel like he isn't trying to hide.
Taesaek- He hasn't posted much content yet, but i believe he has be busy (yes with OverWatch) and he's gonna make time to contribute in the near future, looking forward to that, so i can get a better read on him. UPDATE* Tae's come back, mostly just calling everything stupid. ha.
Fleshy- Has only had a few post and i can't get a read on him yet, he seems to want to go after the inactive players how aren't here and I understand the inactive players suck, but honestly people like Cpu might just end up getting modkilled for not voting or breaking the inactive rule.
I don't know, it's hard with so many players, especially considering quite a few people have been silent/very quiet. In a big game like this a few players seem to take the lead, which is good, but it can lead to some people keeping on the low and getting forgotten. Anyway, at the moment I'm probably leaning toward Daniel, I mentioned him earlier and I agree with what Chrys has said regarding him, he just seems to be acting out of character in general and it's sending red flags. It's only a slight scumread on him though, but I don't have any better ideas as of yet, I can see Toad's reasoning for voting cpu though.
I personally don't think we should go easy on inactives, especially if it's out of character for them to be so inactive. I don't really see the point in lynching someone just for being inactive so early on (when there might be better options), but like Mog said, I'm also not writing off inactives, I did that in previous games and they turned out to be scum.
I do think NL could be worse in this game though, then cult get a free kill and recruit(?), and we haven't even tried. Also Tom, why not recruit inactives? I mean, you're writing them off right now, and that's what cult would want, to be written off, so surely recruiting lurkers/inactives would be a way for cult to keep on the low?
Seroja- I'm town reading her, her activity is strong and she seems to be scum hunting and willing to help the new players have a better understanding of the game.
Iwaseleanor- At first their almost overly confident comment towards Heyden about the game set up was alarming.
I must be mistaken, but I thought there's a scum team and a cult team?? Or am I just understanding wrong..
It clearly says not in the first post, if you're serious.
To me the Set Up in the OP isn't typed out that "clearly" but after their explanation.
I acted a little aggressively towards Hayden and would like to clarify. There are things that pop out to me reading the original post making me fairly certain of their being no mafia. For starters, the lack of a mention of a Mafia team. Also wouldn't cult AND Mafia be overpowered? Also, the host goes on about how she compensated various factors of a cultist game by making there far more town than cultists. From this I don't think she would add mafia, since town would be double-screwed.
Outside of the first post, there was no deaths on N0 too.
i'm willing to let it rest, but i will be watching their future behavior closely.
Menchie- I need a little more effort for them, they have popped in a couple times just confused af it seems.
Amanda- I'm very impressed with her so far she has shown great understanding of the game and also is putting the time and effort in to help us scum hunt by making well organized reads/post. Town reading as of right not.
Wisemimir- Never answered the RQS. Has two in game posts one of which pertaining to the game that show hesitance to trust
Endless and throws a vote on Toad cause well... "why not"
And how are we supposed to be able to trust your word, Endless? Not to antagonize, but we have no way of knowing who can and can't be trusted.
Threw a vote in because why not.
a few of us have expressed interest in hearing an explanation but nothing in reply thus far.
Tasuot- Hasn't posted much of anything so far, says they were gonna read back, hopefully they contribute soon.
with the little to no info this is the best i can do atm, i don't want to lynch Cpu for the inactivity i rather her let herself get modkilled, but im still uncertain who's the best lynch candidate rn, we have less then an hour and a half to decided im gonna look over the votes thread, double check some post, and try to make a decision.
they posted RQS answers and started to act like they care more.
