Yoshi155
Just smile
The Simpsons Seasons 9-12 is like SpongeBob Seasons 4-5. They're not considered nearly as good as the golden age (every season before them), but they were still good enough for the OG fans to watch, who would leave after these seasons. These seasons of The Simpsons have three “jump the shark” moments, though. (The first two are more major plot points, so they'll be in spoilers if you want to watch them)
- Season 9 has The Principal and the Pauper, and it is one of the most hated and controversial episodes of the entire show, and definitely the most at that point. Principal Skinner, who'd been a pretty well developed character, is revealed to be an impostor the entire time, and the real Skinner was thought to be dead. In the end, the real Skinner is sent out of town and everyone promises to never speak of this again. Matt Groening (the show creator) and Harry Shearer (Principal Skinner's voice actor) hate this episode as much as the fans do, because they basically just completely ruin a character. For the most part, it isn't talked about again except for a few occasions, so I guess even the writers want to forget about it.
- Season 11 has Saddlesore Galactica. The A plot has the Simpsons rescue an abused horse from its owner, and have it participate races. After it keeps winning, Homer is threatened by the horse jockeys, who are actually elf like creatures, and threaten to kill Homer if Bart and the horse win any more races. Bart wins anyway, so the elf jockeys chase them but they trap them in a trash bag and leave them on the curb. If you think that sounds too outlandish to be the plot for a normal episode, a lot of people would agree with you. It would probably make more sense for a Treehouse of Horror, or hell, even a South Park episode. The writers were well aware of this, having meta references in the episode about this being the worst episode ever.
- Season 12 has Homer vs. Dignity. There's really only one scene that people think makes it qualify for this, which is Homer getting, uh, assaulted by a panda after having to dress up as a panda for Mr. Burns' amusement, who does nothing to help when this is happening. It's off-screen, but still. A lot of people thought this was another example of something that just isn't fitting for The Simpsons and would make more sense in South Park or Family Guy (in either case it probably would be on screen). There's more instances of vulgar humor in this episode than most Simpsons episodes, like Homer also having to dress up as a baby and pretending he shat himself, or a comment Comic Book Guy makes when eating Peeps.
- Season 9 has The Principal and the Pauper, and it is one of the most hated and controversial episodes of the entire show, and definitely the most at that point. Principal Skinner, who'd been a pretty well developed character, is revealed to be an impostor the entire time, and the real Skinner was thought to be dead. In the end, the real Skinner is sent out of town and everyone promises to never speak of this again. Matt Groening (the show creator) and Harry Shearer (Principal Skinner's voice actor) hate this episode as much as the fans do, because they basically just completely ruin a character. For the most part, it isn't talked about again except for a few occasions, so I guess even the writers want to forget about it.
- Season 11 has Saddlesore Galactica. The A plot has the Simpsons rescue an abused horse from its owner, and have it participate races. After it keeps winning, Homer is threatened by the horse jockeys, who are actually elf like creatures, and threaten to kill Homer if Bart and the horse win any more races. Bart wins anyway, so the elf jockeys chase them but they trap them in a trash bag and leave them on the curb. If you think that sounds too outlandish to be the plot for a normal episode, a lot of people would agree with you. It would probably make more sense for a Treehouse of Horror, or hell, even a South Park episode. The writers were well aware of this, having meta references in the episode about this being the worst episode ever.
- Season 12 has Homer vs. Dignity. There's really only one scene that people think makes it qualify for this, which is Homer getting, uh, assaulted by a panda after having to dress up as a panda for Mr. Burns' amusement, who does nothing to help when this is happening. It's off-screen, but still. A lot of people thought this was another example of something that just isn't fitting for The Simpsons and would make more sense in South Park or Family Guy (in either case it probably would be on screen). There's more instances of vulgar humor in this episode than most Simpsons episodes, like Homer also having to dress up as a baby and pretending he shat himself, or a comment Comic Book Guy makes when eating Peeps.