Thank you for all your input everyone! I'm now deciding between Lumeria and Carmela, but almost 100% certain I'm going for Lumeria!
I like the way it looks and sounds, the way I sorta just made it up, and the meaning I gave it.
I like Lilycove too (it's my NL town), but it's just not unique enough for me this time around. I also like Storybrook, but I think I'd only use it for a fairytale themed town. Who knows, maybe I'll use it for my second island one day. And have villagers like Merengue, Tia, Julian, etc.
i was going to comment Lumeria or Carmela until seeing that you'd already chosen it! i think there's something really pretty about the sound of 'Winnie of Lumeria' and i like the meaning behind it!