Random sig

[Darkwind]

yes I take requests. but not ones like "I need this 2day kthx"

 

[Black Jack]

I like it, the only thing though is that the colors don't really go. It would look better if the dude was more blue.

 

[Sab]

your render needs to blend in more. work on lighting and depth. also i think it could use more effects. just overall doesn't seem finnished, but its a nice start. kiu

 

[muffun]

It sticks out too much from the background, and blue and tan/red don't mix well.

 

[Lisathegreat!]

It doesn't really .... What Sab said, blend in.

 

[Darkwind]

1. its supposed to stick out
2. I know the colors don't match well, but I couldn't find a good render of luffy in his blue outfit.
3. START!? PFFFT.

 

[m12]

1. its supposed to stick out
2. I know the colors don't match well, but I couldn't find a good render of luffy in his blue outfit.

3. START!? PFFFT.

If you've been doing this for a while, as you seem to insinuate, I would've expected you to take criticism well. There is a difference between sticking out and "sticking out", by the way. If you mean that you want the attention focused on Luffy, then make the lighting and focal blurring point to him. Give it depth, and give Luffy the appearance of being the farthest out of the signature, sort of like a 3D effect, in a way.

 

[Darkwind]

I fail to see how I took criticism badly.
I try to take everyones advice whom offers it, I even remade the sig based on their suggestions.

 

[SamXX]

I love this one! It looks really good. The Blue one's OK but I see what everyone's saying.

 

[100]

Ok, now those two blend.
I personally don't like the text, though. But hey, whatever floats your boat.

 

[EpicGamer12]

I fail to see how I took criticism badly.
I try to take everyones advice whom offers it, I even remade the sig based on their suggestions.

I like these ones a lot!

 

[Josh]

Nice, I like the other versions. I needs to just be behind the borders and blend a little bit and it'll be much much better.

But I like your signature though.

 

[bittermeat]

I like the blue one more. The quality lowered once you did color transitions.

 

[SilentHopes]

Not very good. Render just stands out.

 

[Lisathegreat!]

I like the orange one!

 

[Say Whaaaaa]

I like the red one.

 

[Sab]

the 3rd is looking good now. still the tag lacks depth. i would suggest putting some effects or vectors in front of your render to help with the depth