Rate your villagers

[xhyloh]

i love all my villagers but here goes

1. julian - he's definitely my favorite on my island (until i get pietro at least), and my favorite villager of all time
2. stitches - perfect in every way. i'm obsessed with lazy villagers
3. cookie, tipper, and ketchup are all tied. they're perfect
4. judy - she looks like an anime snow cone i love her
5. tad - i love all the frogs but he might be my favorite out of all of them
6. marshal - he doesn't fit with my theme anymore but he's still cute !!
7. kabuki - was gonna choose someone like static or butch as my cranky but he was free and i've never had him before so
8. muffy - i love her but she has no place on my island anymore. sorry girl

 

[ayeeprill]

1. Kiki - My all time favorite villager, had her in every game since ACGC! I don't think I could ever have a town without Kiki in it, it just would not feel right.
2. Ribbot- my second favorite villager. Love him almost as much as Kiki, I've also had him in every game since ACGC. Again, it doesn't feel right if I don't have him.
3. Pippy - one of my six original villagers from my GameCube town. I didn't really have much of an opinion on her back then, but I grabbed her from a mystery island in NH and I ADORE her now. An underrated queen.
4. Sylvana - I fell in love with her when I saw her on someone's island in New Horizons and ended up grabbing her from someone on Twitter when she was in boxes on their island. She's just so stinking CUTE.
5. Diana - A villager I had in New Leaf! I found her in my campsite in New Leaf and actually moved her in with the intent to sell her. But I ended up absolutely adoring her, so much so that I had to get her in New Horizons too. We stan a classy deer.
6. Agnes - Pigs are my favorite animals, but I don't like very many of the pigs in Animal Crossing. I adore Agnes though, and she also happens to be my favorite sisterly!
7. Julian - My forced campsite villager, thus my longest tenured villager on my island. I've thought about letting him go, but every time I do, he says something hilarious that makes me decide to keep him.
8. Julia - My islander from ACGC! I had wanted to get her when New Leaf dropped the Welcome Amiibo update, but couldn't stand to part with anyone from my town, so I got her in New Horizons when it launched instead! Will probably let her go next time she asks to move, but may bring her back via Amiibo in the future.
9. Dobie - Cranky Grandpa Wolf is a gem. Impatiently awaiting his photo, then I will probably let him move so I can get a different cranky for awhile. Have his Amiibo though!
10. Erik- newest villager, he was an autofill, but I'm fine with that! Won't be keeping him forever, but I'm enjoying having him around for now.

 

[maria110]

I love all my villagers. Otherwise I wouldn't have them. They're all lovely and score 10/10. On my main island, I currently have Marina, Colton, Raymond, Reneigh, Sherb, Sterling, Boomer, Astrid, and Audie.

 

[nordskjev]

1. Olivia
2. Shep
3. Raymond
4. Maddie
5. Vivian
6. Reneigh
7. Melba
8. Sylvana
9. Erik
10. Tybalt

 

[Pyoopi]

1. Peewee - beefcake 10/10
2. Tiffany - sultry 10/10
3. Reneigh - runaway train 10/10
4. Rory - terrifying goofball 10/10
5. Cole - piercing stare 9/10
6. Rowan - lunatic energy 8/10
7. Ruby - neutral 7/10
8. Pudge - cupcake thief 6/10
9. Norma - time for her to leave 3/10
10. Derwin - about to be buried 3/10

 

[Mr.Fox]

1- Rocco. Handsome. 10/10
2- Cesar. Perfect. 10/10
3- Deli. Baby. 10/10
4- Plucky. Adorable. 10/10
5- Bubbles. Precious. 10/10
6- Tex. Amazing. 10/10
7- Mac. Fantastic. 10/10
8- Jambette. Gorgeous. 10/10
9- Violet. Beautiful. 10/10
10- Kyle. Meh, please leave. 3/10

I love seeing atypical villagers get some attention. I applaud your villager choices. Very refreshing to see

 

[Bui]

1. Mitzi (11/10). She was the first villager I ever met in the series, so there is a bit of a sentimental connection there that I don't have with any other villagers. By chance she was also the first "repeat villager" I had in the series as well, when she moved in very early to my Wild World town when I got it shortly after. She is an awesome villager and, in my opinion, the cutest one too!

2. Rizzo (11/10). A seriously underrated villager here, and he is my second favorite in the series. I first had him in the GC version, but didn't have him for very long. When he moved into my CF town though, he instantly became a favorite and is one of only two villagers I have specifically ordered an Amiibo card for (the other being Mitzi).

3. Blaire (10/10). Another more or less instant favorite from City Folk. If I recall correctly, she was one of my starting villagers in that town. An all-around great villager.

4. Rosie (10/10). She's Rosie. What else do I have to say?

5. Whitney (10/10). Another quick favorite from City Folk. I got attached to a lot of villagers in the City Folk days it seems!

6. Katt (10/10). She moved into my villager cycling town in New Leaf around the time I took a break from cycling and she quickly grew on me. I was able to get her into my main town, but one day she just up and left without saying a word until she was all packed up to leave. I randomly found her on a Miles island in NH and immediately invited her to my island.

7. Cherry (10/10). One of my NH starters, and a great starter at that!

8. Ken (9/10). My first camper. I didn't expect to like him as much as I do now when I invited him, but he's a pretty cool villager. I don't plan on sending him off any time soon unless I manage to get one of 2 other smug villagers on my island.

9. Punchy (8/10). My most recent lazy on my island, and one of the longest-staying ones (only Prince was here longer). He is a great lazy villager though, so he might be sticking around a bit longer.

10. Rory (8/10). My other starter. I've never particularly liked the Jock villagers in the more recent games, but I do like him. The fact that he was a starter might help here as well.

 

[B7hf]

1.Cranston
2.Big Top
3.Huck
4.Zucker
5.Bud
6.Butch
7.Stinky
8.Flora
9.Canberra
10.Celia
Dream Address : DA-6882-5570-4253

 

[Dunquixote]

1. Punchy 10/10 BFF from NL and now . I love his design so much and while I hate the new bug talk, Punchy will always be my best bud.
2. Rudy 10/10 - got the cutest expressions ever. I love when he stomps around when he gets in a fight especially when it is raining. The way he twirls and thrashes out holding his umbrella is so funny and cute .
3. Kiki 9.5/10 or 10 - i grew to love her in Nl and just love her squished little nose .
4. Raymond - 10/10 - his toothy grin melts my heart and I just love how he looks so cranky even though he is a smug. Bonus points for being a cat as well as my other cats .
5. Merry - 10/10 - I love her teeth, bangs, design so much. I don’t like the dialogue for peppy as much as in Nl, but I still love her and rosie both
6. Rosie - 10/10 - she is so derpy but in an adorable way. I love her color too I used to favor her over Merry but now I like Merry more or them equally.
7. Sherb - 9/10 - i don’t like the goats very much, but I love sherb so much. He is so sweet (just cut the bug talk please )
8. Spike - 8-9/10 - reminds me of my friend @Hobowire so he has a special place in my heart even though like Reneigh, I haven’t had much time to bond.
9. Reneigh - 6/10 - overall - design 8/10. I am not sure how I like her. Haven’t played much since I got her to move to my village.
10. Judy - 8/10 - i used to not like her because of her eyes, but meeting her at my campsite changed that and soon after the idea of giving her or selling her since I like her now. She has really good expressions. And although I don’t like pink or pastel, I do like how the colors blend on her and her galaxy looking eyes.

 

[Xara]

honestly, all of my villagers are a 10/10 - i love them a lot.

this still applies but since my lineup has changed a bit since i last posted, i figured i’d update and actually provide ratings this time.

1) beau - he was my #1 favourite for years and while that infatuation has faded a bit, he’ll always be a 10/10 in my eyes.
2) margie - i’m so mad at myself for sleeping on her for so many years. she’s a treasure and deserves way more love! 10/10.
3) sprinkle - i‘ll start this off by saying that her interior is a whole ass mess . my girl was wronged but she’s genuinely the most precious lil baby and i’d die for her. 10/10.
4) audie - one of my all-time favourite villagers! i’m not as crazy about her as i was last year but i still love her with all my heart. 10/10 forever and always!
5) fuchsia - i love how vibrant she is and her house is neat, too! 10/10.
6) whitney - such an angelic gal. 10/10.
7) étoile - bro she’s genuinely adorable?? might be a bit biased since i’m honestly still so happy that i managed to get my hands on a pack of sanrio amiibo cards but she’s an absolute angel and i love her house! 8/10.
8) chai - she was the first sanrio villager that i invited as i didn’t think that i’d like her very much but uh,, i was wrong lol. she’s honestly so precious and i love seeing her roam around the island. <3 8/10!
9) chèvre - when i ran into chèvre while island hopping, i wasn’t planning on inviting her but i’m glad that i did as she’s lovely! i give her a 7/10.
10) toby - i feel bad for having him at the bottom but i suppose he’s my least favourite villager that i have atm. don’t get me wrong, i love him a lot and am enjoying having him around but i kind of like my other villagers more :’). rating-wise, i think i’d give him a 7/10.

 

[Moritz]

1) Tybalt. Hes my best friend in the whole of animal crossing. Even ordered a very expensive plush of him off etsy.

2) quillson. Hes just adorable. It's my headcanon that he's dating Tybalt.

3) sherb. Hes sherb. We all love sherb.

4) hes yet to move to my island, but egbert is so cute. He's agreed to move in and I am pretty excited to have him.

5) tiffany. Her playboy bunny looks are just too funny. In my head she always talks like she is trying to seduce you.

6) Peggy. Nothing special about her to make me love her. She was one of my starting villagers from last year. I got rid of her like 9 months ago because she was stuck in her starting house. I missed her so I brought her back.

7) Harry. Hes just a loveable old man hippo who loves fishing

8) cherry. She's a cool goth girl. Not an all time favourite but sisterly designs are nearly all ugly

9) maple. She's just kind of there.

10) cyd. I only have him for his pic. Will give him away for free once I have his pic. He's ungifted so I'm sure someone will be happy

Updated with my current line up

1) still Tybalt. I now own a plush of him.
All time favourite villager

2) Megan. She's the only normal I've ever liked and she's become my second favorite villager of all time

3) sherb still. I will be sad to see him leave my island soon. But I don't want 2 lazies because...

4) egbert. Hes just too cute. I think I prefer sherb but the fact I'm letting sherb go so that lazy dialogue belongs solely to him might say otherwise. Hard one.

5) Sheldon. Flat out cutest squirrel in the game. In my islands story he is the adopted son of tybalt.

6) raymond. Had him 4 times now. He just has a way of coming back into my life. Never getting rid of him again because what's the point. I clearly have a weakness for him.

7) pashmina. She's fairly new to my island but I like her. Might be keeping her forever because sisterly villagers have horrible designs and she's the first one I'm somewhat clicking with

8) Henry. He's too new to really comment on but he's very cute and his house is lovely.

9) Roscoe. I think I like him but I partly regret not taking limberg over him. It was between the 2 and Roscoe has a birthday coming up so i chose him.
But I want limberg

10) soleil. I liked her, until my husband saw her and pointed out that she looks like my nasty, evil, sexist, bully of a boss. I can't unsee it...

 

[B7hf]

1. Punchy 10/10 BFF from NL and now . I love his design so much and while I hate the new bug talk, Punchy will always be my best bud.
2. Rudy 10/10 - got the cutest expressions ever. I love when he stomps around when he gets in a fight especially when it is raining. The way he twirls and thrashes out holding his umbrella is so funny and cute .
3. Kiki 9.5/10 or 10 - i grew to love her in Nl and just love her squished little nose ❤.
4. Raymond - 10/10 - his toothy grin melts my heart and I just love how he looks so cranky even though he is a smug. Bonus points for being a cat as well as my other cats ❤.
5. Merry - 10/10 - I love her teeth, bangs, design so much. I don’t like the dialogue for peppy as much as in Nl, but I still love her and rosie both
6. Rosie - 10/10 - she is so derpy but in an adorable way. I love her color too I used to favor her over Merry but now I like Merry more or them equally.
7. Sherb - 9/10 - i don’t like the goats very much, but I love sherb so much. He is so sweet (just cut the bug talk please )
8. Spike - 8-9/10 - reminds me of my friend @Hobowire so he has a special place in my heart even though like Reneigh, I haven’t had much time to bond.
9. Reneigh - 6/10 - overall - design 8/10. I am not sure how I like her. Haven’t played much since I got her to move to my village.
10. Judy - 8/10 - i used to not like her because of her eyes, but meeting her at my campsite changed that and soon after the idea of giving her or selling her since I like her now. She has really good expressions. And although I don’t like pink or pastel, I do like how the colors blend on her and her galaxy looking eyes.

You should put merry in ten boy she is ugly

 

[Moritz]

You should put merry in ten boy she is ugly

As far as cats go (I'm not too huge on them overall) merry is pretty cute

 

[tiffanistarr]

10) soleil. I liked her, until my husband saw her and pointed out that she looks like my nasty, evil, sexist, bully of a boss. I can't unsee it...

She isn’t called Karen for no reason

My current lineup:

1. Bones - He is my best boy. Favorite villager since GC. He is the ultimate cutie.
2. Ozzie - He is probably my second favorite on my island. I just love him so much.
3. Portia - My queen. She’s iconic and i love her.
4. Shari - She’s so cute and her personality is so wacky and fun. She’s superior. Also in a committed relationship with Lobo.
5. Lobo - My favorite cranky old man and Shari’s partner in crime. They’re so adorable and just out there.
6. Coach - My favorite man cow. Always pushing me to be healthy and I appreciate it.
7. Stitches - Another sweet lazy boy, that i love so much.
8. Melba - She’s a koala so she’s automatically top tier, also she’s so kind and sweet.
9. Skye - I love her appearance she’s very unique looking and so cute. Very kind to me.
10. Ruby - The only peppy i’ve let stay on my island for a lengthy time. She is my girl.

 

[Wosie]

Lily ~ I wanted her on my island for so long and finally found her on a mystery island a few months back! She's now a next-door neighbour. <3 Her design is perfect. She's incredible cute when studying flowers, artwork and the like, too. \(^o^)/
Étoile ~ Absolutely adorable fluffy pastel sheep with a face that reminds me of Dom somewhat. Adore her!
Marty ~ Super cute baby bear who always makes me smile. =*o) Too bad he doesn't respond to reactions however! (Only Étoile does from the Sanrio villagers I've had)
Lyman ~ My starter jock who will always have a special place in my heart! Such a welcoming smile and I love the citrus theme (my island fruit is oranges, too!)
Pietro ~ I think Pietro might be my favourite Animal Crossing character of all time (design-wise), but I've had him for so long now in ACNH that he'll be leaving tomorrow. Buuut, he won't travel far, just to my second island. ;o)
Judy ~ Love her design so much! She will never leave, I'm so proud to have her on my island. Magical cosmic cub who reminds me of 70's-80's shoujo manga
Rudy ~ Simply super cute with his huge constant smile and goofy demeanor. Probably the cutest jock in the game imho. *^.^*
Puddles ~ Got her before Lily and really wanted them to live together. She's a very good friend and tends to give me much better gifts than my other villagers ;D
Chelsea ~ I have her picture so she will leave as soon as she asks. Pretty character though and it was fun to dress her up :3 Really dig her colour scheme.
Olive ~ Arrived today! Wanted to take whoever was in my campsite the other day, just to shake things up and Olive was there. Very simple design and I'm not into her colour scheme but she is sweet and I'm looking forward to getting to know her. Don't think I've ever had a grey villager by choice before ^-^ (I love colourful things, especially pastels!)

 

[Megan.]

I like all of my villagers, some I want to replace but overall they’re fine.
1) Coco
2) Katt
3) Judy
4) Bam
5) Raymond
6) Colton
7) Claudia
8) Anchovy
9) Celia
10) Iggly

 

[Dunquixote]

You should put merry in ten boy she is ugly

I don’t understand what you mean by putting merry in ten. I have her at 10/10. And she is my villager so I can rate her how I want. That’s fine if you dislike her, but this thread is about how we feel about our own villagers.

Sorry if this came out a rude. I didn’t understand the first part of the post and I was a bit taken back by that since I wasn’t posting for feedback.