Re-do post. Cute on the outside, creepy on the inside

[. Rarity .]

I'm looking for villagers who are say like Dotty, and Ruby. Ones who look innocent, but actually kinda creepy

Since that would be my main idea for my island. Which villagers do you think, would fit that idea?

 

[_Rainy_]

The ones I can think of maybe are Julian because of his white eyes when he decides to open them. Hopkins for the air plug on the back of his head or stitches because he’s cute, but if you think about it he’s a possessed doll.

 

[. Rarity .]

The ones I can think of maybe are Julian because of his white eyes when he decides to open them. Hopkins for the air plug on the back of his head or stitches because he’s cute, but if you think about it he’s a possessed doll.

Oh I never noticed that about Julian, interesting!

 

[Venn]

All I could think of is Coco the Rabbit. At least for the Creepy part. Some people think Coco is cute as well.

 

[daringred_]

lucky, if you subscribe to the idea that he's a decomposing dog underneath the bandages.

peaches, maybe, since you could interpret her eyes as being sewn shut.

penelope because nobody's sure whether that's a bow or her ears... to quote her pocket camp description: "we want to believe that penelope simply has unusually bow-shaped ears. the alternative is just too disturbing to contemplate."

depending on whether or not you consider them "cute" to begin with: rodeo, namely for his red eyes; pietro, due to the common fear of clowns; raddle, since he is based on a poison dart frog (super poisonous to humans) and because his mask lends itself to the idea that he's either a) suffering from an incurable/deadly sickness or b) the survivor of a place that was devastated by one, prompting him to wear said mask out of fear/paranoia.

 

[. Rarity .]

Oh man, I already found Penelope creepy, but that is slightly creepy I agree

 

[Dunquixote]

Pietro is cute and can be considered creepy by those who aren’t fans of clowns.

Cole! I love him and I think he is so cute but some may find his stare and eyes unsettling. I am a Dragon Age fan so after I discovered Cole and how he shared the name with a character in the novel Asunder and Dragon Age Inquisition, I always pictured the villager as that character (more so after I made a design in HHD with him in it based on some scenes in the book). The character can be creepy since he was a spirit.

Aside from Cole, I can’t think of any cute villagers that creep me out. The villagers that come close to maybe creeping me out are ones I find unappealing or not cute (or had a past experience in NL that caused me to be creeped out by them).

If I think of any more, I’ll post again, but that’s all I can think of right now.

 

[WaileaNoRei]

I think clay kind of fits (though I find him adorable, I think some only think of him as creepy)

He is based on dogu, an ancient japanese clay statuary (different from the haniwa that coco is based on)

here is a quote from Wikipedia, though I cannot say how accurate it is:

Some scholars theorize the dogū acted as effigies of people, that manifested some kind of sympathetic magic.[4] For example, it may have been believed that illnesses could be transferred into the dogū, which were then destroyed, clearing the illness, or any other misfortune

he also has little solid black alien eyes.

I also think Cleo the snooty horse is cute, but has kind of crazy alien eyes.

 

[. Rarity .]

I think clay kind of fits (though I find him adorable, I think some only think of him as creepy)

He is based on dogu, an ancient japanese clay statuary (different from the haniwa that coco is based on)

here is a quote from Wikipedia, though I cannot say how accurate it is:



he also has little solid black alien eyes.

I also think Cleo the snooty horse is cute, but has kind of crazy alien eyes.

Oh Clay is so adorable, hes my favorite hamster

Post automatically merged: May 29, 2021

Pietro is cute and can be considered creepy by those who aren’t fans of clowns.

Cole! I love him and I think he is so cute but some may find his stare and eyes unsettling. I am a Dragon Age fan so after I discovered Cole and how he shared the name with a character in the novel Asunder and Dragon Age Inquisition, I always pictured the villager as that character (more so after I made a design in HHD with him in it based on some scenes in the book). The character can be creepy since he was a spirit.

Aside from Cole, I can’t think of any cute villagers that creep me out. The villagers that come close to maybe creeping me out are ones I find unappealing or not cute (or had a past experience in NL that caused me to be creeped out by them).

If I think of any more, I’ll post again, but that’s all I can think of right now.

Ah, Cole is very cute, also slightly creepy lol

Post automatically merged: May 29, 2021

lucky, if you subscribe to the idea that he's a decomposing dog underneath the bandages.

peaches, maybe, since you could interpret her eyes as being sewn shut.

penelope because nobody's sure whether that's a bow or her ears... to quote her pocket camp description: "we want to believe that penelope simply has unusually bow-shaped ears. the alternative is just too disturbing to contemplate."

depending on whether or not you consider them "cute" to begin with: rodeo, namely for his red eyes; pietro, due to the common fear of clowns; raddle, since he is based on a poison dart frog (super poisonous to humans) and because his mask lends itself to the idea that he's either a) suffering from an incurable/deadly sickness or b) the survivor of a place that was devastated by one, prompting him to wear said mask out of fear/paranoia.

I definitely need Penelope if I did then lol. That is creepy

 

[. Rarity .]

Just wanted to thank everyone for helping me, I now have a list of cute villagers with a creepy feel to them! I'm looking forward to this island, and this cast is perfect for it ♡

I decided on pretty much everyone susgested here, a few others for my own reasons, the fact I find them creepy