Rosie or Lolly?!

[kerryelizabeth]

ACK I cannot believe I'm having this problem again. I now have both Rosie and Lolly in my town and cannot decide which I want to keep. I can either have two peppy villagers or two normal villagers. Rosie or Lolly, guys?

Here's my current town in case it makes a difference:
Lopez
Fuchsia
Whitney
Wolfgang
Maple
Stitches
Bam
Cookie
Freya

So I need that last slot to fill... I had my heart set on Rosie, but after meeting Lolly, she's just SO sweet!

 

[MadisonCrossing]

Lolly all the way! She is for sure a favorite of mine. Rosie used to be better until I actually learned about Lolly...
So yush. Lolly is my winner!
And I am the first voter! XD

 

[kerryelizabeth]

At the moment it's 50/50 on the poll. I voted for Lolly just so I could see the results, because I'm torn... So it's 50/50. I just think Lolly is the sweetest little thing but Rosie is adorable too. But I do prefer normal personalities to peppy ones...

 

[Chris]

I like Rosie best. Although I auctioned mine off before I reset the town she was in. I have Lolly in my main town and I find her boring.

 

[kerryelizabeth]

It's still 50/50 xD

- - - Post Merge - - -

Of course, I could just get Cookie to move out and have them both
Then I'll have two bear cubs, three deer, three wolves and two cats. That works.

 

[Isabella]

Rosie. to be honest the normals are SO cute but once you have 3 of them (like me) you get bored of them..

 

[Lin]

Lolly, Rosie is meh... and she was obnoxious and cowardly in the movie. xD Just makes me think less of her I guess. She's cute but Lolly is cuter. And Lolly has cool patterns on her fur.

 

[rivulet]

I prefer Lolly, although I like Rosie. I have Lolly in my town and she's one of my favorites, I used to have Rosie but I traded her for Marina.

 

[beffa]

Lolly's so boring ;_; her facial expressions are just kind of dull

 

[Farobi]

i made it 50/50 again. I chose Rosie cuz Lolly's eyes aren't really appealing for me.

 

[Annemalcrossing]

Rosie. She's sweet, cute and I had her in my original AC gamecube town

 

[jvgsjeff]

Lolly is one of the cutest animals in the game (and one of my favorites), so I would keep her.

 

[han]

I say Lolly. I find her cuter :3

 

[ForgottenT]

I have them both, and I could not let any of them go, and I would not be able to choose 1, so I?m not gonna vote xD

 

[Lin]

Rosie kind of reminds me of Hare (not a bad thing, to me it's good):

Spoiler: large image

 

[Dozer]

Definitely Lolly. I've never been very crazy about Rosie. She looks like a purple tomato to me with her hair.

 

[Touko]

...Uhh....I had them both so I can't choose :L

 

[Sherry]

Both are very adorable. I had Rosie in my Wild World town and I really liked her.
Though I like Lolly in appearance more because of her unusual cute face. Rosie's eyes are too big for my liking.
If I had to choose between these two I would take Lolly.