I don't often like to lead on day 1, but if NO ONE else will then who will? No one was talking. In all other games as town and MAFIA I don't lead, I'm a very quiet person. Well cell mafia 2 was an exception, but for normal games I'm usually quiet and let someone else lead or start a fight. I'd rather lead or try to start discussion than to have no one post at all.
This seems like a genuine defense on your part, but I'd still say there were a few people that seemed way too serious about things on day one, and other than you there are four or so people who seemed that way. First impressions are everything tbh and I'm not gonna ignore them anymore.
How is Capella and I knowing she has basketball something suspicious? Lol? I knew she had basketball because she told me. Capella is close with Crystal as well. I don't remember whenI found out Crys was in basketball, think it was a thread? Or she mentioned it on the IRC, don't remember.
I have no idea how you think Crystal is MORE active as mafia. She gets by posting NOTHIGG as mafia. As town she POSTS, I'm thinking of most nub games and Portal Mafia. She hasnt been mafia often but when she has she's been quiet as a mouse.
I never mentioned a basketball game? I misread something and in skim reading thought you were saying Crystal was more active as mafia, but that was just Capella who said it. And I just read into it and even though it's still not super active, you can tell Crystal was more interested in that game than in others. Kinda subtle. But that's enough of beating a dead horse.
Who the hell was serious on day 1 lol? Is it even BAD to be serious? Sorry, maybe people actually want a PRODUCTIVE day 1.. Yes there's nothing but you can create evidence through DISCUSSION.
Read your post wrong, thought u said we know the same stuff so I thought u meant Crystals life and crap with why she was unable to come.
I would think coming back to mafia after so long would make people more excited, guess not.
Tbh I'm looking at Nikki, Yui, and Oath. Barely anyone questioned them and they're pretty much sliding past by. I know they're all busy (though some of their reasons I can't say are very valid) but I just have a bad feeling about Yui in particular. If I'm able to get on a computer perhaps I'll pull some stuff up about her, but probably not.
Bandwagoning is simply voting the same as everyone else. There was no reason for me to not bandwagon, so I did. Bandwagoning isn't some evil thing that you can't do. It only becomes a problem when people vote without having any thought of their own on the player being voted for, which wasn't the case for me. As I said earlier, it was between voting for you, and for Crystal, but seeing everyone voting for Crystal, I figured I may as well vote because she's also a good day 1 lynch candidate.
Also I'm not sure if your mess of quotes was supposed to be some sort of case on me or not, but if it was, you accomplished nothing.
Who the hell was serious on day 1 lol? Is it even BAD to be serious? Sorry, maybe people actually want a PRODUCTIVE day 1.. Yes there's nothing but you can create evidence through DISCUSSION.
I'm still looking BACK at MADOKA mafia because SOMEBODY was a little too serious about SCUMHUNTING day 1/pre-game. And she turned out to be MAFIA and my first impression was right.
I'm still looking BACK at MADOKA mafia because SOMEBODY was a little too serious about SCUMHUNTING day 1/pre-game. And she turned out to be MAFIA and my first impression was right.
okay DYLAN sorry my PHONE autocorrects words into CAPS but I'm going to keep it like that cuz it adds SUSPENSE!
Okay but YUI wasn't even SRS this game. All she said was THERES A BUNCH OF SPAM! That's it! Nothing really useful besides her post about Beardo being the BETTER out of the TWO!
Okay but YUI wasn't even SRS this game. All she said was THERES A BUNCH OF SPAM! That's it! Nothing really useful besides her post about Beardo being the BETTER out of the TWO!
She's one of the four, but I'm moreso using her as a reference/example here. I'm purely talking about how she acted as mafia in another game. Which I suppose is good to bring up anyways considering she's in this game.
- - - Post Merge - - -
And how other people who are mafia might have made the same mistake.
Well god dammit Crystal. Don't join if you aren't willing to play as a townie.
Crystal's unwillingness to even provide a defense meant two things really: bored townie or mafia that was o****ting and not posting. We took that gamble and lost, but if she wasn't going to post anyways.. maybe it was for the best. I also don't understand WHY you, Capella, didn't post that stuff about Crystal BEFORE we lynched her. It seemed like you knew that she was a townie. You voted for Beardo (past deadline might I add) to not tie yourself to the Crystal bandwagon, assumingly to not look sus. Quote in question:
honestly I don't think crys would stay quiet like she did in olympus if she was mafia. I know she's better than that tbh, even though there's been a break she couldn't have completely forgot how to be and play mafia. she's actually been active on tumblr (ty for being MY NUMBER 1 FAN!!!!) so I think she's just uninterested town. but I think she has basketball so that might be preventing her from posting something with some actual substance. probably not tho, just a thought. i'd rather not vote crystal and just give her a chance maybe she'll post soon ahaha!!
I suggested we lynch Crys due to inactivity, but if you knew the reason why she was inactive, why didn't you post it? Why didn't you say so when the bandwagon was starting?
-----
I just have a sneaking feeling that Beardo might be red. Useless, spammy, not able to piece together a shred of defense or a case. I just feel so torn about them. I'm just going to leave their posts here:
I find it interesting that you voted for Crystal when there was clearly more evidence on me (I'll get to that) Bandwagoning is usually a sign of mafia, just being lazy, or both.
Now, for my defense
I haven't contributed at all, but I've been busy. I actually have homework I need to get to after this,
anyways,
My main suspect is Ashtot. Give me a few minutes to gather evidence, I'll be back.
I would think that Beardo would have defended themselves before the day actually ended? Instead of just saying "lol I'm playing pokemon". When they were up for lynch in Mean Girls Mafia, they attempted to provide a reason to not lynch them (They ended up flipping green):
Hello! I just woke up an hour ago, then I had chores and stuff. The only reason it shows me viewing the thread is because I keep the tab open on my ipad. I have started gathering what little evidence there is though.
To me, the posting styles between those two games and this one look like different people playing, which is why I feel suspicious. I do regret that I didn't sit down and give this more thought on day one, but what's done is done.
-----
Another name I want to bring to light would be NikkiNikki.
Yeah, sorry for lurking a lot yesterday, I was pretty busy :|
On a serous note:So far Minties want to vote for Crys and Ashot on Beardo.
Here are all beardo's posts:
Not much of a help, but hey everyone was kinda trolling yesturday. However it got serious like a page or 2 back? so there should be some reads or "guts feelings" on peeps
Cry ONLY post^^. Cry's most recent activity was Today, 02:51 AM so where you at?
I'll give cry sometime if Cry doesn't post anything that's worth something then I'll vote for them
Pretty much all recap and going after Crystal. I do find it strange that NikkiNikki was championing about how inactive Crystal was, yet was the last one to vote for her after we were all on board. I mean 3 of her 4 game posts were about Crystal. It just seems off to me that she would wait until the last minute to cast a vote on the only person she felt sus of.
-----
After reviewing the posts a bit and previous games, I feel a bit more suspicious of those that voted for Beardo. It was obvious that there were too many votes on Crystal at the end, so it would have been easy for mafia to not bandwagon because we expect them to bandwagon so someone dies.
Also @Dad, why didn't you vote? If you said why, I must have missed it. Doesn't take long to vote.
Well I was working but expected to get home by the time voting was set to end, but coworkers pulled me into a dinner because it was my last day at work and it lasted pretty long. I have a pretty good record of not missing votes so it's unusual for me.
Also I was planning on making a case on Oath tonight but I tortured him once before and he turned out to be a teamie. I do want to point out, however, that he seems apologetic about how he is playing the game so far when there's really no need to be apologetic. We're all coming from a long break from mafia, brah.
I haven't played mafia in ages and I'm feeling so attacked right now. I'm out of practice. I've been in IRC/saving Hyrule all day leave me alone.
Well...maybe not apologetic, but trying to make an excuse. He also jokevoted day one but that's not a surprise or out of character. Still, something seems a little off but I don't know what.
Well I was working but expected to get home by the time voting was set to end, but coworkers pulled me into a dinner because it was my last day at work and it lasted pretty long. I have a pretty good record of not missing votes so it's unusual for me.
Also I was planning on making a case on Oath tonight but I tortured him once before and he turned out to be a teamie. I do want to point out, however, that he seems apologetic about how he is playing the game so far when there's really no need to be apologetic. We're all coming from a long break from mafia, brah.
Well...maybe not apologetic, but trying to make an excuse. He also jokevoted day one but that's not a surprise or out of character. Still, something seems a little off but I don't know what.
I agree with Minties on Nikki. Capella I know has my time zone too so I suspected she probably had school like me. PST people never lucky!
(DYLAN UR saying BRAH? Wtf? You're like an old hippie that date ugly old men go back to your retirement center and stop trying to use slang -_-)
I guess I wanted to lynch Crys more just because I know her play style better...
Okay I know Oath is busy with a gay game, I have those times too and all I would do is play it until I finish it lol. (cough dragon age) But it's very hard to get a read on him because his posts his game have been mostly jokes besides one where he's calling out Ashtot. I just find it kinda odd when some people brushed off Oaths inactivity earlier, but I know I could never lynch him on day 1 cuz I'm p sure people wouldn't have followed. Yes we all are rusty. All of us. I'm just worried with the inactivity of the game, rip TBT mafia if a 10 player game can't stay alive.
I agree with Minties on Nikki. Capella I know has my time zone too so I suspected she probably had school like me. PST people never lucky!
(DYLAN UR saying BRAH? Wtf? You're like an old hippie that date ugly old men go back to your retirement center and stop trying to use slang -_-)
I guess I wanted to lynch Crys more just because I know her play style better...
Okay I know Oath is busy with a gay game, I have those times too and all I would do is play it until I finish it lol. (cough dragon age) But it's very hard to get a read on him because his posts his game have been mostly jokes besides one where he's calling out Ashtot. I just find it kinda odd when some people brushed off Oaths inactivity earlier, but I know I could never lynch him on day 1 cuz I'm p sure people wouldn't have followed. Yes we all are rusty. All of us. I'm just worried with the inactivity of the game, rip TBT mafia if a 10 player game can't stay alive.
We don't even know if there is a vig or not and if there is I think they should save their shot for tomorrow since there's more information and it's just one shot.
