Seeing as everyone wants a guide for this I thought maybe everyone on this forum can contribute a bit.
Every time you get your shoes shined, post exactly what you were wearing and what option(s) you clicked when visiting Kicks, then tell us, in as much detail as possible, what kind of shoes you got.
I doubt i'll add everything into this main post straight away because it would just get too tedious, i'll do it all at once every few weeks (assuming the thread stays alive that long and doesn't get buried among all the other threads)
YES, A GUIDE!! I was wearing a red No. 1 shirt and got them shined by color, and they became red. Then the next day (wearing the same thing), I had them shined by style, and they went back to the blue shoes I had in the beginning.
I was wearing the orange pattern you have in the beginning, and I got brown shoes w/ pink socks. My brother was wearing his purple 4-ball shirt, and he got pink shoes w/ white polka dots and had bright green socks...