Mafia TBT Mafia: Renaissance - Game Thread [ENDGAME - Town Wins]

Status
Not open for further replies.
@Harbour can you elaborate on why you don't nullread trundle if you aren't sure how to read them? also if you HAD to make a statement on tae/locket, what is it?
i find tae and locket both town-like. locket seems to be contributing and as for tae i've said this before, but their frustration seems genuine.
i've been unsure of trundle as ever since the start of the game, their posts have been very strange. i'm just paranoid because of the punchy playstyle thing.
i'd want to vote trundle today.
 
If i'm going to be completely honest with you harbour. That's not an option. Anyone who splits votes here absolutely gets considered mafia so it's just about who me/antonio decide to vote today.

So the question is, if you had to lynch one of Tae and Locket, who's mafia. If you don't believe that Tae/Locket are mafia, who are the three mafia to you?
 
If i'm going to be completely honest with you harbour. That's not an option. Anyone who splits votes here absolutely gets considered mafia so it's just about who me/antonio decide to vote today.

So the question is, if you had to lynch one of Tae and Locket, who's mafia. If you don't believe that Tae/Locket are mafia, who are the three mafia to you?
If it's about who we both decide, why are you voting Locket/Tae?
Post automatically merged:

I'm not down for locket but I am done for Tae.

I really think Locket is lying and they're another 3rd party.
 
I guess I was under the impression that you didn't want to make the choice for today because when I asked for your opinion you told me not to.

But yeah, I guess it didn't post what I wrote before.

I'm just gonna vote Tae man. I've been trying all game to get them lynched and there's not a world where they flip town.
If you're town and you don't scumread tae, splitting votes is the easiest way to let mafia force the lynch they want.
The only reason I didn't vote Tae earlier was because I wanted to look it through, but honestly? I can't really imagine them being town.
 
No, I am not attempting to derail the discussion on who is scum.I will be quiet for now on.

I would assume scum would be a little quiet this round since it's close to EOD, btw. That's my final thought.
 
Antonio, if you wanna decide to pick a different lynch over me, that's ~fine~, but we do have to discuss and vote together, the worst thing we could do as town is split our votes just because we disagree, the same goes for anyone here, splitting votes here is the worst thing we could do. And ya'll have a tendency to blitz every day.
 
Antonio, if you wanna decide to pick a different lynch over me, that's ~fine~, but we do have to discuss and vote together, the worst thing we could do as town is split our votes just because we disagree, the same goes for anyone here, splitting votes here is the worst thing we could do. And ya'll have a tendency to blitz every day.
Understandable, just wait.
 
The severe lack of talk and discussion and votes yet makes me worried, especially since my deadline is sooner than it is for all of you.

I really can't shake the feeling that there's something up with Shawo playing a really good game and getting so hyped for killing a townie since it's lylo zone rn. But that might just be me going 'you know what would be funny'. I sure know I was thinking the same thing at the start of the game when people were going "Dino is asking lots of questions, I think she's town because if she was mad she would ask her fellow mad" and I was thinking 'wow, if being a newbie makes me seem town, how funny would it be if I actually was evil and not town'.

I'm genuinely more concerned about Locket than I am about tae, yet I feel relatively alone in that thought, especially given the only vote cast so far has been tae. Which came from Shawo, which almost fuels the niggling feeling of 'what if' in the back of my mind.

So I don't know what to think. And my chance to make a choice is running out quicker than it is for everyone else.
 
locket has gotta go

if it makes you feel better, Dino, i did a full ISO on you and i think you're town

can't say the same about locket
Post automatically merged:

Dino in how many hours do you go to sleep? forgot ur timezone but ik phases end at weird times for u
 
locket has gotta go

if it makes you feel better, Dino, i did a full ISO on you and i think you're town

can't say the same about locket
Post automatically merged:

Dino in how many hours do you go to sleep? forgot ur timezone but ik phases end at weird times for u
I tend to go to bed between 9pm-11pm my time, which is GMT. So at the lastest 5 hours before EoD.
It's currently half 6 for me.
 
i still don't even know who to vote cause i am SO unsure in my reads, they've all been wrong
 
So at this point in the game I think we are kind of at a point of no return when it comes to players we have "confirmed" as town. If shawo is truly as deadly a player as I originally guessed he might be in my RQS, I think there is a chance he could be running this game behind the scenes the whole time. I think oath could have been a bus. Regardless, if shawo is mafia, then he has played a better town game as mafia then tae has as town. If tae is mafia, then shawo is just playing a great town game as town. glow made some really good points on tae and oath's compatibility. I hope I'm not just being super pocketed by a stellar mafia team of glow + shawo, but I'm going to vote tae and pray.
 
I am seriously completely and utterly confused on which way to vote.
I personally think it should be Locket, but everyone else says tae. The one person who has also said Locket has yet to vote to show they actually really support a Locket lynch. aaaaaa
Post automatically merged:

And honestly on top of that, the more I think about it, the more I think it's actually Shawo rather than Locket vs tae
 
Last edited:
I have thought, and thought.

I cannot in good conscience vote between Locket and tae when I don't have enough reasonable suspicion on either of them, not on a lylo day.

Something about the way Shawo has limited it to two (since I seem to have been removed from the group) without considering the others rubs me completely the wrong way. Like they know exactly who to try and push for because they know who is mafia and who isn't, so they know who could die to cause a lylo. I'm really sorry if I've got it backwards, but this idea is in my head and I can't get it out, I have to vote with my conscience.

I'm sure Shawo's two mafia members will be backing them up and voting tae. I get the feeling tae will agree with me and possibly vote Shawo. I don't know where that puts the rest of the town, however many there may be, but I get a feeling that my vote isn't going to be the beginning of any kind of significant wagon. If I'm being perfectly well and truly honest, I don't have much hope of the town winning today, but that's another matter entirely.
Post automatically merged:

Vote is placed. And with that, good luck to you all, and goodnight. I look forward to catching up on the fallout in the morning.
 
Vote Count - 4:1
tae [2]: shawo, Trundle
Shawo [1]: DinoTown
Not Voting [6]: Locket, PunchyDaHufflepuff, Antonio, tae, glow, Harbour

Currently at [2] votes, tae is currently set to be lynched. You have roughly 6.5 hours left to lynch someone. Day ends tonight at 10:00 PM CDT. Majority to immediately lynch is 5.
 
dino. you're wasting your vote and potentially risking mafia having the ability to win this phase. there's three mafia here, only ONE person is technically clear.

i will disregard my reads and pretend i have no read on shawo.

of those alive: there HAS to be three mafia within harbour/shawo/tae/locket/trundle/you/me.

Antonio, punchy, locket, tae, harbour, me.

shawo is voting tae. tae will vote shawo.

Antonio WILL NEVER vote shawo. likely trundle will never vote shawo as well.

punchy has failed to actually interact with the game this phase so who ****ing knows where he is

you're potentially leaving the lynch to harbour, locket, punchy. of which, one you've definitively said you think is mafia.

potentially Evan has a vote too but let's not rely on ghost votes.
Post automatically merged:

i forgot punchy in the first list but whatever.
Post automatically merged:

i want to lynch locket but i'm not splitting votes.
 
locket seems too easy honestly

but idk who else would be mafia

tae has honestly seemed kinda towny on brief skim of iso

after that tbh idk who
Post automatically merged:

sorry i really should be interacting more

my fault

inb4 antonio susses me for this

i’m 90% going to go on locket unless something drastic happens
Post automatically merged:

antonio mafia left you alive over mog because you have ****ty reads

you contributed way more then mog

i’m going to need you to vote locket
 
Last edited:
glancing through it, i think there is a chance that tae might've bussed oath? if my internet would work faster for a few minutes i'd appreciate it
Post automatically merged:

tae's reads on dead town have been all scum. tae slightly sussed oath in the past. i don't know if its just horrible scum/town reading abilities (bc tbfh all my reads r bad) or a red-flag
Post automatically merged:

placing my vote on tae for now
i'm really unsure though
 
If i'm going to be completely honest with you harbour. That's not an option. Anyone who splits votes here absolutely gets considered mafia so it's just about who me/antonio decide to vote today.

So the question is, if you had to lynch one of Tae and Locket, who's mafia. If you don't believe that Tae/Locket are mafia, who are the three mafia to you?
so this is going to happen again. last time i voted oath d2 and nobody followed me so i changed my vote and he ended up being scum. so far i'm really confused on who to read in this game but i want a trundle lynch, and maybe punchy could be paired with him too but he's null for me.
out of tae and locket i'm more confident in locket being town.
 
you just townread tae a page ago.

what indicates tae busses specifically.
Post automatically merged:

bussed****
Post automatically merged:

so this is going to happen again. last time i voted oath d2 and nobody followed me so i changed my vote and he ended up being scum. so far i'm really confused on who to read in this game but i want a trundle lynch, and maybe punchy could be paired with him too but he's null for me.
out of tae and locket i'm more confident in locket being town.

HOW is locket town.
Post automatically merged:

harbor, unfortunately it's not just about voting mafia it's about compelling those around you to vote in unison.

you call trundles reads strange. how so are they strange?

you say locket has been contributing. how are those contributions towny? we've all contributed at some point. if we hadnt then we'd be modkilled
Post automatically merged:

i'm sorry i keep spelling ur name harbor it's harboUr i'm a dumb american
Post automatically merged:

ASK YOURSELF WHAT IS MORE LIKELY

locket flipping their read on tae based on "glancing through their ISO"

OR

locket flipping their read on tae because that's who's up for lynch apart from themself.

like it's PERFECTLY fine to vote out of self preservation. but the fact that locket tried to make a ~read~ on tae? lol.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top