Mafia TBT Mafia VIII: Dark Lord Ascending [Game Over/Town Win]

[Beary]

I'd like to counter that. I'll post something soon~

Him, okay. I've been mainly skimming the thread, so I'm sorry if I missed anything. I better get back to homework now....I'll be gone for a bit if anybody posts to me.

 

[Ashtot]

I don't really see why anybody would be suspecting you at the moment, you are contributing very well, and making great points. I think you are acting very pro-town.

No.

 

[iLoveYou]

To answer your question though, I don't have someone that is scummy, but has been lurking: Kayla / iLoveYou. I figure she's doing some analyzing or traveling into PM land, since you can never tell with her.

I put out my list of targets for Day One lynch, but ultimately it just falls into Truffles' hands since he's the one getting roleclaims. It wouldn't help to keep bringing up the same names & that's all I have to post right now. I basically just want to target people who won't get targeted by the Mafia themselves, because it'll be hard to watch them play for us at the end.

 

[DarkNightMoon]

No.

Can I ask how I am not?

 

[Syd]

Me and Karen are working together with the case, expect a post soon.

- - - Post Merge - - -

On DarkNightMoon that is.

 

[BlueLeaf]

Can I ask how I am not?

Look at my previous post.

I actually think contrary, she has been saying "agreed" and "anybody else-" quite often. I'm willing to move past it, but it's definitely something that should be fixed.

One common Mafia trait is to manipulate someone and let them do all the work. You should definitely try to contribute yourself.

 

[Kit]

Me and Karen are working together with the case, expect a post soon.

- - - Post Merge - - -

On DarkNightMoon that is.

I would LOVE to see this.
A case on a NEW player who is actually trying to help town and is posting HELPFUL information.
I will be waiting.

- - - Post Merge - - -

(I do agree on the whole agreeing on everything part, but dark is new and I really don't see that as case worthy)

 

[BlueLeaf]

I would LOVE to see this.
A case on a NEW player who is actually trying to help town and is posting HELPFUL information.
I will be waiting.

Helpful? Do you mind quoting one post with helpful information from her? If I recall correctly, I haven't really found any.

 

[BellGreen]

(I do agree on the whole agreeing on everything part, but dark is new and I really don't see that as case worthy)

I mean no offense to all new players but I don't think new players deserve to be excused more often. Everyone should be as equally up for lynch as everyone else.

 

[oath2order]

Lynch Cory 2k14

If you need me I'll be in IRC or Skype.

Especially coming right off of Cell Mafia, I don't know why you thought just randomly saying this was a good idea. Granted, it's Cory, so I can understand it.

Not gonna do some analysis or "player list" until later on in the day. So have at it.

Again, please don't post your player hit-list. -_- I don't like being a target.

I have not been town since mafia VI, which was 2 games ago for me. I am a totally different player now, what made me look like town back then does not make me look like town now.

You seem to think that, don't you? But everybody has extremely subtle tells when they're scum.

B) A scum may not even claim anything, so they're hiding something.

Both could end up finding a liar or scum so I'm all up for trusting Truffle.

Makes me a little suspicious about people massively against roleclaiming.

Many people are going to claim the self-aware miller. I predict 4 claims for it.

Four is an odd number. There are five goons you know.

You guys are pretty much ruining any chance of trapping Mafia though, by the way you are all exposing all these plans & what you think they will do. We could have probably trapped at least 1 Mafia player with the self-aware miller role, but now there's too much attention on that + the drunk Townie role.

How about we just discuss a Day One lynch & Truffles tells us if we're going on the right track or not? That way he won't have to release any names with roles, on who he wants us to lynch, which would help Mafia blue snipe in the end as Justin mentioned.

Has Syd played any Mafia games before that I can look at? Do any of you know?

See also: Mafia Game VII. "LET'S BUY ALL THE ITEMS AND SAY WHO HAS WHO SO MAFIA KNOWS TO ROLEBLOCK"

Oh my literal god are you already doing this.
WAS I THE ONLY PERSON WHO DID THAT? NO.
WAS I THE ONLY PERSON POINTING THINGS OUT? NO.
Would you just let me play the game?

Throwing a little fit. Like in AC Mafia when you were accused.

Well, I want oath2order to be lynched cause...personal reasons. :3
But I don't think we really should.

You shut your mouth.

Especially him, anyone remember Mini Mafia IV?

Why do you keep bringing up Dolby's playstyle? You did this in Cell I think.

I'd rather lynch Lynn because of her slide-by inactiveness which presents itself in every game she has played.

I honestly would agree with this.

I don't know who to lynch. Kit is just being spammy as hell and I just wanna wait until Truffle talks.

 

[Kit]

Helpful? Do you mind quoting one post with helpful information from her? If I recall correctly, I haven't really found any.

Ok, she is TRYING to be helpful.
She is trying to figure out and understand mafia, she isn't automatically going to know whats helpful and what isn't.

 

[BungoTheElf]

Sorry Maddy you can't fool me I always check chat logs when I go on and since they were talking about you I decided to check.

I always check the chatzy history. You made a big mistake. ):

We can't screenshot right?

Maddy: JAOSN
Maddy: JASONNN
Elise: jason thats not a reason
Elise: he has a **** tho
Maddy whispers
Jason: yes it is
Maddy "I'm scum"
Elise: oh lol
Maddy cleared the room 2 hours ago
Elise: idc
Maddy: Nothing
Maddy: :3

--skip bc convo between makki and Jason--

Maddy: Byeeeeeee
Maddy cleared the room 2 hours ago
Maddy: Lynn
Maddy: must not see
Maddy: because she is playing
Maddy: shhhh

I honestly doubt she'd lie to these two about her role.

 

[FireNinja1]

I don't really see why anybody would be suspecting you at the moment, you are contributing very well, and making great points. I think you are acting very pro-town.

All she's doing is the exact opposite of what you have said.

So now we have new people and experienced. Does anyone have a want for lynch?

The first part is just completely obvious. Furthermore, asking about "a want for lynch" is quite suspicious, since someone could could just voice their opinion, and you just hop on that train.

Exactly. Personally, I have no clue what I am doing. Sorry if it sounds scummy.

Honestly "Sorry if it sounds scummy" sounds like just an attempt for compensation of the suspicious behavior, so Town just might dismiss this post. Doesn't help town, it only helps mafia.

Agreed with the Truffle thing, we hardly have any evidence right now.

We get it! That's how Day 1 is! Anyone who has looked through any, and I mean ANY of the past mafia games will know that day 1 has no evidence.

 

[Kit]

Especially coming right off of Cell Mafia, I don't know why you thought just randomly saying this was a good idea. Granted, it's Cory, so I can understand it.



Again, please don't post your player hit-list. -_- I don't like being a target.



You seem to think that, don't you? But everybody has extremely subtle tells when they're scum.



Makes me a little suspicious about people massively against roleclaiming.



Four is an odd number. There are five goons you know.



See also: Mafia Game VII. "LET'S BUY ALL THE ITEMS AND SAY WHO HAS WHO SO MAFIA KNOWS TO ROLEBLOCK"



Throwing a little fit. Like in AC Mafia when you were accused.



You shut your mouth.



Why do you keep bringing up Dolby's playstyle? You did this in Cell I think.



I honestly would agree with this.

I don't know who to lynch. Kit is just being spammy as hell and I just wanna wait until Truffle talks.

It would be easier to stop posting if you guys wouldn't make me the center of attention.

 

[Beary]

Sorry Maddy you can't fool me I always check chat logs when I go on and since they were talking about you I decided to check.

I always check the chatzy history. You made a big mistake. ):

We can't screenshot right?

Maddy: JAOSN
Maddy: JASONNN
Elise: jason thats not a reason
Elise: he has a **** tho
Maddy whispers
Jason: yes it is
Maddy "I'm scum"
Elise: oh lol
Maddy cleared the room 2 hours ago
Elise: idc
Maddy: Nothing
Maddy: :3

--skip bc convo between makki and Jason--

Maddy: Byeeeeeee
Maddy cleared the room 2 hours ago
Maddy: Lynn
Maddy: must not see
Maddy: because she is playing
Maddy: shhhh

I honestly doubt she'd lie to these two about her role.

I hate you.

 

[Kit]

All she's doing is the exact opposite of what you have said.
The first part is just completely obvious. Furthermore, asking about "a want for lynch" is quite suspicious, since someone could could just voice their opinion, and you just hop on that train.
Honestly "Sorry if it sounds scummy" sounds like just an attempt for compensation of the suspicious behavior, so Town just might dismiss this post. Doesn't help town, it only helps mafia.

We get it! That's how Day 1 is! Anyone who has looked through any, and I mean ANY of the past mafia games will know that day 1 has no evidence.

SHE.IS.NEW. She probably hasn't read the past games! How was she supposed to know any of this?

 

[KermitTea]

Well then, Beary it is I suppose. I can save the case for DarkNightMoon for later.

 

[oath2order]

It would be easier to stop posting if you guys wouldn't make me the center of attention.

You said you'd stop responding

 

[Syd]

SHE.IS.NEW. She probably hasn't read the past games! How was she supposed to know any of this?

Just because someone is NEW doesn't mean they can't be a prime suspect.

 

[iLoveYou]

Sorry Maddy you can't fool me I always check chat logs when I go on and since they were talking about you I decided to check.

I always check the chatzy history. You made a big mistake. ):

We can't screenshot right?

Maddy: JAOSN
Maddy: JASONNN
Elise: jason thats not a reason
Elise: he has a **** tho
Maddy whispers
Jason: yes it is
Maddy "I'm scum"
Elise: oh lol
Maddy cleared the room 2 hours ago
Elise: idc
Maddy: Nothing
Maddy: :3

--skip bc convo between makki and Jason--

Maddy: Byeeeeeee
Maddy cleared the room 2 hours ago
Maddy: Lynn
Maddy: must not see
Maddy: because she is playing
Maddy: shhhh

I honestly doubt she'd lie to these two about her role.

Yeah the fact that she cleared the chat pretty much makes it look like she was telling the truth about herself being scum.