Mafia TBT Mafia X: The Honnō-ji Incident [Game Over/Town Win]

[KarlaKGB]

Most Mafia games are actually supposed to be played without PMs, hence why there are mason roles. When I started hosting here, I figured it was too difficult to enforce such a rule. By keeping everything in the thread, it's much easier to hold people accountable for what they say. It also emphasises logic and analysis, instead of the usual overreliance on blue roles which plagues TBT mafia. It's not at all a quirky setup like you imply it is.

Karen quit because I interrogated her too hard and broke her. She was withholding the Andelsky information, and giving bad reasoning for doing it.

 

[Byngo]

Most Mafia games are actually supposed to be played without PMs, hence why there are mason roles. When I started hosting here, I figured it was too difficult to enforce such a rule. By keeping everything in the thread, it's much easier to hold people accountable for what they say. It also emphasises logic and analysis, instead of the usual overreliance on blue roles which plagues TBT mafia. It's not at all a quirky setup like you imply it is.

Karen quit because I interrogated her too hard and broke her. She was withholding the Andelsky information, and giving bad reasoning for doing it.

I presume what you're saying also applies to PM's on the IRC?

 

[KarlaKGB]

I presume what you're saying also applies to PM's on the IRC?

Yes, I'm pretty sure you're not supposed to whisper/private message people on IRC mafia either.

 

[Yui Z]

Okay, I've looked through the thread several times and can't find anything new that hasn't already been brought up. So here's my opinion on Trundle's case against Andel.

First of all, I'm pushing aside the fact that they took 17 minutes to reply since, although it's possible that she was contacting other scum, it's also likely that something came up in real life. With the first quote, I think the 'damaging friendships' thing could've been a cover for them trying to keep Andel alive long enough for them to kill Trundle tonight, before he shares too much. (If this was the case, then it didn't work obviously) This is also why I agree that we should keep an eye on Gallows since they replaced Karen. This is why I wouldn't be against them being lynched.

Sorry there isn't anything new here really. Now I really should start my coursework.

 

[Lauren]

Yes, I'm pretty sure you're not supposed to whisper/private message people on IRC mafia either.

There would be no way of us stopping this though. There are pros and cons to this, like jeremy said, mafia would know out every move if we didn't move but also important things like the current situation are being hidden, pieces of information that could help town win. So it's really two of one half a dozen of the other.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Move? No pm**

 

[PrayingMantis10]

I will ask all detectives to inspect me night one, and I will start forming a quick alliance from there. We will have to be quick in finding the cult leader. I think that is our biggest threat. We will basically have no concept of "confirmed town" anymore.

Jeremy, are you still asking all the detectives to inspect you? If not ..then why have you changed your mind?

 

[oath2order]

Jeremy, are you still asking all the detectives to inspect you? If not ..then why have you changed your mind?

He never said anything to the contrary.

 

[Sataric]

I personally feel that we have now chosen to trust in Jeremy and that having every single Detective waste a night on confirming his role is a waste of our time - He will automatically be in the spotlight due to being the Mayor and we'll hopefully be able to detect if he has hidden agendas or causes trouble for Town further down the line. I understand that if the Detectives check him tonight, they could then PM him his role, proving that they are the DT, and thus start working together based on mutual trust - But even so, there would be a small chance that Jeremy is the Godfather and then those inspections would be coming back looking legit either way. And please, let us not forget that the Mafia has a framer. At the end of the day, though, it's up to each Detective to make their own choices.

TL;DR: I feel that the risk of trusting Jeremy is the preferable gamble over wasting a whole night's worth of inspections.

 

[Prof Gallows]

This is also why I agree that we should keep an eye on Gallows since they replaced Karen. This is why I wouldn't be against them being lynched. [/SIZE]

You're kidding, right?

Why would I need to be lynched at all? If you're basing anything off of what Karen did it's no evidence at all.

You can't chalk up someone playing badly to me being lynch worthy. That's ridiculous.

 

[Yui Z]

You're kidding, right?

Why would I need to be lynched at all? If you're basing anything off of what Karen did it's no evidence at all.

You can't chalk up someone playing badly to me being lynch worthy. That's ridiculous.

Actually, I wasn't even suggesting that you should be lynched. All I was saying that someone should keep an eye on you. Nothing that hasn't already been said really.

 

[Prof Gallows]

Actually, I wasn't even suggesting that you should be lynched. All I was saying that someone should keep an eye on you. Nothing that hasn't already been said really.

Just a normal townie. Not really worth watching me but if you want to have someone inspect me or something by all means go ahead. Other than myself and Andel is anyone else being suspected?

 

[Jeremy]

Jeremy, are you still asking all the detectives to inspect you? If not ..then why have you changed your mind?

We may use that plan to an extent, but I'm not sure because it might not work if mafia interferes. That being said, if any detective has role claimed to Trundle, please do what he asks you to do for night 1. If you have not claimed to him, you can talk to me if you want. If a detective doesn't want to role claim to either of us, but wants to trust me, feel free to inspect me and use your best judgement in terms of the godfather and framer. I suggest you do one of the three though. We don't have much time to form an alliance because the cult will be harder to beat the longer the games draws out. And because of the cult, I think the detectives should not know who each other are. Instead, they can interchange inspections through me.

 

[Justin]

I say go for the Andelsky lynch. I don't expect a scum lynch on Day One, so it's not the end of the world if we're wrong, but this seems like a good oppertunity. Andelsky's defence to the 'evidence" is very lackluster, they don't seem to be trying very hard to defend themselves.

I would lay off Karen/Gallows for now since it appears the whole suspicion on Karen was a mix up with the Andelsky information.

 

[Lauren]

With the whole protecting Jeremy thing, it would give detectives piece of mind but also it could go the wrong way and mafia could get a big hit on us. Is it worth forming an alliance and allowing mafia to possibly hit blues or it could work in our favour and they takeout cult leader...

 

[Alice]

I say go for the Andelsky lynch. I don't expect a scum lynch on Day One, so it's not the end of the world if we're wrong, but this seems like a good oppertunity. Andelsky's defence to the 'evidence" is very lackluster, they don't seem to be trying very hard to defend themselves.

I would lay off Karen/Gallows for now since it appears the whole suspicion on Karen was a mix up with the Andelsky information.

We really don't have any better information here, so that may be our only real option. I guess for now, we should just take Gallows word for it.

 

[Jeremy]

With the whole protecting Jeremy thing, it would give detectives piece of mind but also it could go the wrong way and mafia could get a big hit on us. Is it worth forming an alliance and allowing mafia to possibly hit blues or it could work in our favour and they takeout cult leader...

Also understand that I'm trying to keep part of it a secret for now, which is why I'm asking Trundle's blues to keep talking to him for night 1. Hopefully at least one of them is a detective.

 

[Lauren]

I understand I was weighing up possibilities that could work in our favour. I want to make this clear to everyone, MissNoodles just pm'd me asking how I would implement my plan to work with mafia. That was not my intention but I don't see how my post said that, but just in case anyone else gets confused, of which I highly doubt.

 

[Lauren]

With the forming an alliance that was intended about blue roles checking Jeremy for trust reasons not to form an alliance with mafia.

 

[Cory]

Here you go Jeremy

- - - Post Merge - - -

oops

 

[Jeremy]

So I will put in the lynch for Andelsky in an hour, sound good? Does anyone have anything else to say before I do?