Mafia TBT Mafia XIV - Majora's Mask Redux - End Game

By tomarrow i meant the day phase, anyway, i think i can think i can get a good idea on who might be mafia by analysing the dead peoples posts

quality dolby post

i meant to say this earlier but why would nick be defending so much?? idk scum partner or idfk
i dont think he defends this much but improbably wrong
 
quality dolby post

i meant to say this earlier but why would nick be defending so much?? idk scum partner or idfk
i dont think he defends this much but improbably wrong

Nick knows full well not to do that? It's a rooky move hence why no one brought it up.. But you.
 
quality dolby post

i meant to say this earlier but why would nick be defending so much?? idk scum partner or idfk
i dont think he defends this much but improbably wrong

Oh please, now you're just getting overconfident with this Dolby Lynch.
 
To be honest, I'm not buying the whole "oh I've been making mistakes and I'm gullible" act that you've been playing at for the past few days. I've seen you play Tsundere, you're anything but a stupid player. The fact that you're making all of these obvious mistakes strikes me as really off. It would have been ridiculously overpowered to make the postman's hat unstealable. In my opinion, you and Superpenguin knew of Dad's mask and I think one of you stole it.

i really am gullible - flashback to trusting harry easily in XCOM. i've been making mistakes because well uh let's just say i'm not the best i can be atm due to some things. i can't concentrate that much due to that but i think ill be okay from now on. but yeah i had no intent on trying to play some act with my mistakes - those were truly mistakes. idk why i thought it was unstealable, because i thought well if the couples mask was unstealable then yeah. i'm usually more careful as mafia anyway, and making mistakes like this is reckless for me. sorry.

k im conflicted between dolby and alice tbh. its hard for me to ever get a read on dolby because he pops up at the last minute to post. ill wait to see how day goes before i vote.
 
I need to run and do some math stuff for college so I'm going to place my vote on the person I think is scum, and that's Alice.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also anyone jumping on voting for Dolby or Alice should feel obligated to give a reason as to why in this thread. I'm talking about you, BerryPop and Ryan88. No excuses.
 
I think everyone who hasn't given reasons to why they're voting should, bandwagoning is a joke, and it's happening too often.
 
This is just a theory to why Ashtot and Tom died, i'm assuming that their scum kills and that Sataric was killed by the clockmakers, i don't have any idea why they killed him because he mostly opperates pm. I know that my theory has a couple holes

Neither Tom or Ashtot did much this game, but both of them had positive lynch Ryan88 opinions, although the more minor opinions (relative to Lauren). I think that they could be killed as a way of undermining the support of lynching ryan of day two, but Lauren's opinion might have been a bit to noticable to safely kill her. All three (Ashtot, Tom, and Lauren) i view as strongish players and the opinions of those three could have enough influence to get ryan88 lynched

I'm really tired of "oh they almost barely kinda want to improve, they deserve a chance now.". If someone wants to improve, this isn't the way to do it, and it doesn't mean we should ignore them because they claim that they'll try.

This was directed towards Ryan88

Yeah, why would you risk wasting time in possibly helping Mafia, or in general just wasting time in general.

I just hate it when there are terrible players that don't give a crap about the game who sign up and do nothing. I never had a coach, like many others, and we didn't need them. The concept of this game isn't difficult at all. Newbie is more of a tier than something you do to learn the game, at least in my mind.

I'm just going to go ahead and vote Capella. If someone wants to take Ryan under their wing or bring them into their fold, so be it but I'm inclined to side with Ashtot and Lauren about Ryan.

If you read the few pages of the ryan88 discussion (25-29) you will find that Ashtot, Lauren, Tom, and Dad had noticeable negative opinions about ryan88

IDK really why they were killed, it just jumped out as a theory into to mind after i read their posts

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm honestly kind of tired since i woke up at 5:30 A.M. so it might not make a lot of sense
 
Dolby is sounding kind of town right now, since he at least put forth the effort to analyze what has happened and is making a sensible argument against Ryan88. I still feel a little more partial to Alice, but now I'm seeing what he means about Ryan88 and it seems like something Ryan would do as a newer player. If anything though, I think people should lay off the Dolby lynch while we still have time and actually hit scum.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also Sid you're lurking this thread a lot but not posting. What if this is another Xcom with you?

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm actually sort of on the fence between Alice and Ryan88 now. Dolby served as a reminder for me to look into Ryan and Ryan doens't seem to be acting like he's town in this game, because he often claims to be town when he's actually town, the kills seem like fearkills. No, he's not mafia by himself but it's also convenient that some stronger players were taken out (Tom and Sataric) and a townie that is risky to keep alive is taken out as well (Ashtot - probably would have been hazardous for maf with a bomb mask). Additionally, he's really inactive when he can be active (just chooses not to) and doesn't even explain his votes like he tends to do.

...I'm not feeling as confident about Alice as I am about Ryan anymore, now that I've been reminded to look into it. Going to switchvote to him.
 
Dolby is sounding kind of town right now, since he at least put forth the effort to analyze what has happened and is making a sensible argument against Ryan88. I still feel a little more partial to Alice, but now I'm seeing what he means about Ryan88 and it seems like something Ryan would do as a newer player. If anything though, I think people should lay off the Dolby lynch while we still have time and actually hit scum.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also Sid you're lurking this thread a lot but not posting. What if this is another Xcom with you?

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm actually sort of on the fence between Alice and Ryan88 now. Dolby served as a reminder for me to look into Ryan and Ryan doens't seem to be acting like he's town in this game, because he often claims to be town when he's actually town, the kills seem like fearkills. No, he's not mafia by himself but it's also convenient that some stronger players were taken out (Tom and Sataric) and a townie that is risky to keep alive is taken out as well (Ashtot - probably would have been hazardous for maf with a bomb mask). Additionally, he's really inactive when he can be active (just chooses not to) and doesn't even explain his votes like he tends to do.

...I'm not feeling as confident about Alice as I am about Ryan anymore, now that I've been reminded to look into it. Going to switchvote to him.
Oh no it's not. I was just reading through and decided on who to vote for. Give me a minute on that
 
To be honest, I'm not buying the whole "oh I've been making mistakes and I'm gullible" act that you've been playing at for the past few days. I've seen you play Tsundere, you're anything but a stupid player. The fact that you're making all of these obvious mistakes strikes me as really off. It would have been ridiculously overpowered to make the postman's hat unstealable. In my opinion, you and Superpenguin knew of Dad's mask and I think one of you stole it.

i really am gullible - flashback to trusting harry easily in XCOM. i've been making mistakes because well uh let's just say i'm not the best i can be atm due to some things. i can't concentrate that much due to that but i think ill be okay from now on. but yeah i had no intent on trying to play some act with my mistakes - those were truly mistakes. idk why i thought it was unstealable, because i thought well if the couples mask i'm usually more careful as mafia anyway, and making mistakes like this is reckless for me. sorry.

This is just a theory to why Ashtot and Tom died, i'm assuming that their scum kills and that Sataric was killed by the clockmakers, i don't have any idea why they killed him because he mostly opperates pm. I know that my theory has a couple holes

Neither Tom or Ashtot did much this game, but both of them had positive lynch Ryan88 opinions, although the more minor opinions (relative to Lauren). I think that they could be killed as a way of undermining the support of lynching ryan of day two, but Lauren's opinion might have been a bit to noticable to safely kill her. All three (Ashtot, Tom, and Lauren) i view as strongish players and the opinions of those three could have enough influence to get ryan88 lynched



This was directed towards Ryan88





If you read the few pages of the ryan88 discussion (25-29) you will find that Ashtot, Lauren, Tom, and Dad had noticeable negative opinions about ryan88

IDK really why they were killed, it just jumped out as a theory into to mind after i read their posts

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm honestly kind of tired since i woke up at 5:30 A.M. so it might not make a lot of sense

Assuming mafia has 2 KP since this is a rather small setup (if they have 3kp then wtf oath) this kind of fall aparts if Tom and Sataric were mafia kills instead. It's a possible theory, but we don't know who was killed by mafia. Mewmewmewm claims she thinks Ashtot was shot by a vig, so idk.

(Don't worry I woke up at like 4:00 AM lol)

Anyway, although Dolby's post is not much I believe he's town over Alice. Her playstyle at the moment reminds me very much of her playstyle in XCOM. I'm putting a vote down for her, though if something comes up in the next ~3.5 hours then I'll change. Won't vote right away though. I'm worried we might not reach majority however.. I'd rather we lynch someone so we get information, so hopefully Alice gets enough votes. But if I have to switch over to reach majority, then so be it. Bit annoyed that Kiss is using illogical evidence against me, but whatever you say dude.

Also, can the clockmaker(s) please PM me? I'm interested in working with you. If you choose to work with town we would be happy to lynch you after all the mafia are gone. However if there's two of you then I'm not sure how it will work.

What time is it for the clockmaker(s)?
 
Well considering there's 3 hours remaining, it looks like today is going to end up a no lynch?
 
Well considering there's 3 hours remaining, it looks like today is going to end up a no lynch?

I don't know. I was thinking of going for ryan, but I'll vote Dolby just to prevent another no lynch if I have to. I'm not too sure about either though.
 
I am between Alice and Dolby. But from Dolbys last post I get more of a townie vibe. It seems he was trying. But if he doesn't want to get lynched in future days he might want to work on his defense. Because I don't think he even defended himself at all. I get a feeling like Alice might be more likely to be scum then Dolby so I think I will vote for her.
 
Also, Clockmakers should work with town. It will be harder to win if you team up with mafia
 
Back
Top