Mafia TBT Mini Mafia V: Cell Experiment [Game Over/Mafia Win]

[KermitTea]

It doesn't matter who's leader...as a group, we need to decide the order and the leader will submit those in.
I think we need active people to remain longer so we can tell who is mafia from their posting style.
My order is: E, C, B, D, A.
Or E, C, D, A, B.
I ranged it in order from inactive ness -> active ness (as a group) because in my opinion the more you post the easier it is for you to mess up. The inactives will be a threat. I would like to stay longer, but I am worried about pallycake and ITookYourWaffles, which is why I nominated my group for first lynch. The other teams aren't a huge worry since everyone is mostly active.
I would like to hear your opinions and it would be nice if some of you could order the groups in your preference.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

I really don't care who leads us, so I'll probably just bandwagon Trundle on in. The real excitement comes from finding the traitors within our cells.

 

[unravel]

It doesn't matter who's leader...as a group, we need to decide the order and the leader will submit those in.
I think we need active people to remain longer so we can tell who is mafia from their posting style.
My order is: E, C, B, D, A.
Or E, C, D, A, B.
I ranged it in order from inactive ness -> active ness (as a group) because in my opinion the more you post the easier it is for you to mess up. The inactives will be a threat. I would like to stay longer, but I am worried about pallycake and ITookYourWaffles, which is why I nominated my group for first lynch. The other teams aren't a huge worry since everyone is mostly active.
I would like to hear your opinions and it would be nice if some of you could order the groups in your preference.

Meh, You don't have to worry about me I'm active since I'm on summer vacation, I am worried about pally because she is an inactive player. The only problem with me is the timezone have to stay up around 4 AM because of that ) I also agree about your suggestion. (TBH, I don't know when to start or say anything)

 

[toastia]

Like Karen said, it doesn't matter who the leader is. The leader should do what everyone wants. If you ask me, I think the best order would be D, C, A, E, B. Putting my group first because honestly I don't know what to think; both have PM'ed me. I'm not sure which one of them are lying about being Town. They are both currently on my radar.

 

[Jeremy]

Like Karen said, it doesn't matter who the leader is. The leader should do what everyone wants. If you ask me, I think the best order would be D, C, A, E, B. Putting my group first because honestly I don't know what to think; both have PM'ed me. I'm not sure which one of them are lying about being Town. They are both currently on my radar.

And you are on ours!

 

[EpicGamer12]

Like Karen said, it doesn't matter who the leader is. The leader should do what everyone wants. If you ask me, I think the best order would be D, C, A, E, B. Putting my group first because honestly I don't know what to think; both have PM'ed me. I'm not sure which one of them are lying about being Town. They are both currently on my radar.

And you are on ours!

Oh snap it's getting intense in Group D over here, guys

 

[toastia]

Oh snap it's getting intense in Group D over here, guys

Mafia = salt = intense. Simple.

 

[unravel]

Mafia = salt = intense. Simple.

Indeed really intense. It would be the best if you guys keep discussing maybe I can help. I will try my best to contribute as well. Plus its too early to pinpoint guys.

 

[toastia]

Indeed really intense. It would be the best if you guys keep discussing maybe I can help. I will try my best to contribute as well. Plus its too early to pinpoint guys.

It has to start with something. After we pick a leader we could really start on some discussions. Once we find out what group goes first.

 

[unravel]

It has to start with something. After we pick a leader we could really start on some discussions. Once we find out what group goes first.

Well that is what I'm telling ya dear well what I mean by pinpointing early is accusing or point someone without proof. Let's start discussing the leader thing then your group (I guess)

 

[Superpenguin]

Kind of unnerving that if Karen becomes the leader, she would put her group up first, so we can lynch someone there and if Karen is scum she can escape by early. Whereas, if her group was last and she was the leader, she would be much more susceptible to suspicions for poor group orders.

To me, a scum leader would be putting their group up first so they can get out of the game first and avoid being accused of scum for how they chose the groups later on.

 

[KarlaKGB]

A reminder that the voting deadline is in a few hours.

 

[Beary]

Oh poop. We need to chose.

 

[KermitTea]

Kind of unnerving that if Karen becomes the leader, she would put her group up first, so we can lynch someone there and if Karen is scum she can escape by early. Whereas, if her group was last and she was the leader, she would be much more susceptible to suspicions for poor group orders.

To me, a scum leader would be putting their group up first so they can get out of the game first and avoid being accused of scum for how they chose the groups later on.

It doesn't matter who's leader...as a group, we need to decide the order and the leader will submit those in.
I think we need active people to remain longer so we can tell who is mafia from their posting style.
My order is: E, C, B, D, A.
Or E, C, D, A, B.
I ranged it in order from inactive ness -> active ness (as a group) because in my opinion the more you post the easier it is for you to mess up. The inactives will be a threat. I would like to stay longer, but I am worried about pallycake and ITookYourWaffles, which is why I nominated my group for first lynch. The other teams aren't a huge worry since everyone is mostly active.
I would like to hear your opinions and it would be nice if some of you could order the groups in your preference.

I just want to make it clear that I'm not asking to be leader o-o I simply voiced my opinion since I really support the lynch-inactives-early route. If I were leader, I would submit whatever you guys want. Which could be dangerous since 1/3 of the group is mafia, and I don't want to be swayed by them. A strong player such as you would be better since you have more experience and better reasoning.
I think Trundle would be a good leader. The only reason I haven't voted for him yet is because I don't support his plan to put his group up first. Like Kaiaa said earlier, as a group we need to decide -- and so far no one has listed their preferred groups in order. We have to start somewhere.

 

[Superpenguin]

E -> C -> D -> B -> A

 

[Minties]

It doesn't matter who's leader...as a group, we need to decide the order and the leader will submit those in.
I think we need active people to remain longer so we can tell who is mafia from their posting style.
My order is: E, C, B, D, A.
Or E, C, D, A, B.
I ranged it in order from inactive ness -> active ness (as a group) because in my opinion the more you post the easier it is for you to mess up. The inactives will be a threat. I would like to stay longer, but I am worried about pallycake and ITookYourWaffles, which is why I nominated my group for first lynch. The other teams aren't a huge worry since everyone is mostly active.
I would like to hear your opinions and it would be nice if some of you could order the groups in your preference.

I agree with your E, C, D, A, B list. I think it's a good idea to have E first solely because Pallycake is ferociously inactive in mafia games. I don't want her to slip by as mafia because she won't post. C, D, and A all have their fair share of inactives and people that will make us run in circles with fakeclaims or spam posts. Their order can be switched around however you guys think. I also agree on B being last because SP and Justin are both strong players while Cory is also stepping up his game. We would need slightly more time to figure this group out based on their posting.

I am wary about trusting Trundle, given his nature of making rash decisions and working against town initially. Who do you all think should be mayor?

 

[KermitTea]

Well, there's like five hours left until we need to decide on a leader. We need to make this decision fast -- so far Trundle and Minties have been nominated. I think we can decide between these two.

 

[Superpenguin]

A strong player such as you would be better since you have more experience and better reasoning.

I believe I was nominated as well.

 

[unravel]

My Opinion

E > C > A > D > B

I choice E first (like what Karen said)
I'm going to post about Pallycake

Spoiler: Her roles and modkills too obvious

Mafia I -Townie (Modkilled Day 6)
Mafia II -Townie (Modkilled Day 5)
Mafia III -Detective (Modkilled Day 2)
Mafia IV -Party Elite (Modkilled night 3)
***I think this is not important, I know she is busy and trying her best. And also I have a feeling she is a scum.

Who do you think should be a mayor?
SP, Minties or Tina.

 

[Cory]

I'm going to hold off on voting until Trundle posts the group order he is going to do.