Mafia TBT Newbie Game VII: The Daily Tragedy - Town win

[Arstotzkan]

This was my idea of how we could go about this:

We lynch Menchie today. If Menchie is town, tonight, right before night ends, Sparro outs who he jails between Nightmares and El. If he dies, get the one he didn't jail. If he lives, get the one he jailed.

 

[CinnamonBuunn]

but like why? can you explain a little more clearly why you thought she was sus and now you are so strongly town reading them? just because you "re-read the thread" doesn't show me anything or your train of thought for such an extreme and quick change of mind.

I'm not town reading Nightmares, I was saying the 99% was how positive I was that Entropy isn't cop.
I believe Nightmares is innocent now, and I'm almost positive (like 99%) Entropy was not cop because Sparro and you both probably wouldn't lie.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh, btw that is copied and pasted (The end part, my quote)

- - - Post Merge - - -

This was my idea of how we could go about this:

We lynch Menchie today. If Menchie is town, tonight, right before night ends, Sparro outs who he jails between Nightmares and El. If he dies, get the one he didn't jail. If he lives, get the one he jailed.

Just one question:
Will you actually eat a hat if I'm town?

I'd pay to watch that

 

[Arstotzkan]

I'm not town reading Nightmares, I was saying the 99% was how positive I was that Entropy isn't cop.
I believe Nightmares is innocent now, and I'm almost positive (like 99%) Entropy was not cop because Sparro and you both probably wouldn't lie.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh, btw that is copied and pasted (The end part, my quote)

- - - Post Merge - - -



Just one question:
Will you actually eat a hat if I'm town?

I'd pay to watch that

Yup.

Answer my questions though: http://www.belltreeforums.com/showt...ragedy-DAY-2&p=6903542&viewfull=1#post6903542

- - - Post Merge - - -

If it isnt you, I'd say it would be El. And if not either of you, then I'd question my life choices.

 

[glow]

ahahahha I will eat a hat if menchies isn't town

- - - Post Merge - - -

menchies I got u homie, vote eleanor, I TR you so much

 

[Arstotzkan]

ahahahha I will eat a hat if menchies isn't town

- - - Post Merge - - -

menchies I got u homie, vote eleanor, I TR you so much

A hat will be eaten this day

Why would Eleanor target me tho.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Nightmares there's a chance that Entropy is a corrupt cop if you are town.

And if El is scum, why would she make a post like this?

 

[glow]

oh yes i love when mafia involves eating hats

 

[Arstotzkan]

Actually, now that I think about it, that's a townslip El made. Yeah ok Im pretty dead certain its Menchie at this point. If not her, Toads? Then Nightmares? Theres no way lmao. Its gotta be Menchies, even by POE.

 

[glow]

imo it's actually really weird to say, why not assume that nightmares is just lying rather than a cop being insane?

that's cause she knew night was town

 

[Arstotzkan]

I thought it was because she just came from cultists, which had people getting converted. Thats what I assumed she meant by corrupted.

 

[glow]

I thought it was because she just came from cultists, which had people getting converted. Thats what I assumed she meant by corrupted.

oh hmmmmm eleanor pls respond

what did u mean by corrupted?

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm not town reading Nightmares, I was saying the 99% was how positive I was that Entropy isn't cop.
I believe Nightmares is innocent now, and I'm almost positive (like 99%) Entropy was not cop because Sparro and you both probably wouldn't lie.

oh, i did say i'm not cop btw. it was a reaction test, i wanted to see what she would say

 

[amanda1983]

what about nightmares rxn (reaction) didn't you like?

and yeah, about eleanor, the inactivity + her last question is super weird

- - - Post Merge - - -

also can i request that everyone adds a dumb tag pls.

At the time I made my second reads post (# 295) there had been several posts that implied/mentioned Nightmares as possible Mafia. I can't pinpoint any particular reaction of hers that seems "off" - the couple of posts that stuck out to me have already been raised. She seemed willing to offer reasons - even defences - for why other people appeared "scummy" (despite being Town), but she didn't have much to say to defend herself or seem to be actively looking for Mafia.

Oh, and I should have been clearer with what I wrote in post # 371 - I hadn't read post # 294 by Toads when I sent my post, but I had noticed that El had been quite passive about Fleshy and I was wondering about that. Had Menchie and Nightmares not been so prominent in my mind, and I not been so pressed for time to get the reads done before EoN 1 then I would probably have moved El back down to null if not amber, but I thought I was likely over-reacting at that point.

 

[Arstotzkan]

At the time I made my second reads post (# 295) there had been several posts that implied/mentioned Nightmares as possible Mafia. I can't pinpoint any particular reaction of hers that seems "off" - the couple of posts that stuck out to me have already been raised. She seemed willing to offer reasons - even defences - for why other people appeared "scummy" (despite being Town), but she didn't have much to say to defend herself or seem to be actively looking for Mafia.

Oh, and I should have been clearer with what I wrote in post # 371 - I hadn't read post # 294 by Toads when I sent my post, but I had noticed that El had been quite passive about Fleshy and I was wondering about that. Had Menchie and Nightmares not been so prominent in my mind, and I not been so pressed for time to get the reads done before EoN 1 then I would probably have moved El back down to null if not amber, but I thought I was likely over-reacting at that point.

I think she was talking about Nightmares' reaction to cop getting a sus read on her.

 

[amanda1983]

I think she was talking about Nightmares' reaction to cop getting a sus read on her.

Ah I see now, sorry for the misunderstanding. The section in bold in the following quote (from my post # 371) -

I'm happy to look at El again, I agreed with the points Toads made about her post-lynch. Not enough to trump Nightmares or Menchie when doing my reads, but now that we're back to the drawing board again...

- was talking about my thinking for my second reads post (# 295), not my current thinking. Sorry again for the confusion.

Whilst I can definitely see Nightmares being Town, I'm not keen on the lack of outright denial of being Mafia. If she's Town then her reaction makes sense and seems to fit her previous play style, but the ~detached tone also raises questions for me. I don't know, I think I just need more to work with from her.

 

[brownboy102]

@Toads I do understand.

Also, I'll need to ask you all to understand that I'm only going to have wifi at school and maybe my cousins house, and won't be able to post as often and as lengthily as before. I'm as unhappy as you may be. It may seem like an excuse but it isn't; I haven't been able to get on often. I'll hop on at lunch and ten minutes after school to read up but other than that I won't be able to, unless we can get our internet services back up. I'm extremely sorry for the inconvience, and thank you for understanding.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm going to point out menchie's change of tone. It seems like she's giving up. I know it's hard to get around but if you really are town you need to at least try to defend yourself.

 

[Iwaseleanor]

what about nightmares rxn (reaction) didn't you like?

and yeah, about eleanor, the inactivity + her last question is super weird

Refer to above regarding inactivity. My last question was weird? I asked the question wondering about whether maf could've killed and maybe hit BPV, if that was the setup, and noone else had brought up the possibility.
Alright just to ask quickly though, what, other than my question changed your opinion of me from 100% town to you now putting a vote on me?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh oops I accidentally deleted this bit:
Please take into account timezones and that people need to sleep and go to work/school. I was only just able to get on

 

[Arstotzkan]

Refer to above regarding inactivity. My last question was weird? I asked the question wondering about whether maf could've killed and maybe hit BPV, if that was the setup, and noone else had brought up the possibility.
Alright just to ask quickly though, what, other than my question changed your opinion of me from 100% town to you now putting a vote on me?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh oops I accidentally deleted this bit:
Please take into account timezones and that people need to sleep and go to work/school. I was only just able to get on

Question: When you were talking about corrupted cop at the beginning of today, did you mean insane cop? As in the cop would get the opposite result of the true allignment of the person they suspected?

 

[Iwaseleanor]

Question: When you were talking about corrupted cop at the beginning of today, did you mean insane cop? As in the cop would get the opposite result of the true allignment of the person they suspected?

Yes I got confused with the terminology somehow sorry

 

[Nightmares]

So what's everyone's thoughts on a Menchie lynch?

I'm honestly not sure at this point.... I won't be totally surprised if she turns out to be Mafia, but I can't see any tell tale signs she is.
The thing I thought was weird how she "re-read" the thread and now she thinks I'm Town (99% anyway lmao), but when asked why she thought this:

Originally Posted by*toadsworthy*
but like why? can you explain a little more clearly why you thought she was sus and now you are so strongly town reading them?

She only replied by repeating herself:

I believe Nightmares is innocent now

and not actually giving us any reasoning

She is defending me (a Townie ofc *coughcough*) though, so maybe I'm just being pedantic...?? I'm bad at this lmao sorry

 

[glow]

its pretty weird to assume that cop would be insane imo. eleanor, why wouldn't you just assume that nightmares is just lying and trying to seem towny?

it sounds like something you would say if u were maf and u knew someone else was town

so yea kat that's not a townslip

i think fleshy was trying to bus

- - - Post Merge - - -

bussing in that situation is really smart

because then if his teammate gets lynched, he looks better for voting mafia

if he gets lynched, his teammate looks town because he pushed her

- - - Post Merge - - -

Refer to above regarding inactivity. My last question was weird? I asked the question wondering about whether maf could've killed and maybe hit BPV, if that was the setup, and noone else had brought up the possibility.
Alright just to ask quickly though, what, other than my question changed your opinion of me from 100% town to you now putting a vote on me?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh oops I accidentally deleted this bit:
Please take into account timezones and that people need to sleep and go to work/school. I was only just able to get on

well, its not just your inactivity but also lack of input right now on menchie/nightmares/etc

 

[toadsworthy]

6 hours (roughly) until end of day guys....