Mafia TBT Nub Mafia V: Daycare Mafia - Endgame - Town wins!

[tae]

all accusations aside... I agree we should look at to why Lynn would be killed first, lets figure out something that actually happened, rather than just trying to decide the actions behind what people are saying

lynn was suspected mafia int eh beginning, which i find odd as to why she was randomly killed off first.
i think it was a cover for an easy kill. obviously if i was killed night 1, red flags would have shot up at everyone i grilled into on day 1.

*looks directly at the camera*
right, toad?

 

[toadsworthy]

keep in mind there's about 2-3 scum and we lost 2 vanilla townies already :/

- - - Post Merge - - -

toadsworthy might know something we all don't know since he's being so bold

so like are you gonna make one big assumption on someone and then disappear again for 3/4 of the conversation after? you did this day one calling out Lynn and then vanished? you are quick to point a finger then runaway, especially drawing attention to the currently biggest target... Lynn when spoke first, and now me after all went down before night 1

- - - Post Merge - - -

lynn was suspected mafia int eh beginning, which i find odd as to why she was randomly killed off first.
i think it was a cover for an easy kill. obviously if i was killed night 1, red flags would have shot up at everyone i grilled into on day 1.

*looks directly at the camera*
right, toad?

its very true, if you had died, I think I would already be lynched at this point....

- - - Post Merge - - -

or that might have been too obvious a choice for the mafia to try to go with....

- - - Post Merge - - -

I AM SO SORRY THAT I USE ZILLIONS OF ELLIPSES

 

[tae]

regardless, i'm curious to see other's ideas towards who to lynch at the end of day 2.

 

[toadsworthy]

I think Lynn was probably a safe kill... someone who kinda was suspected by everyone, then wasn't as suspicious, I will have to go back and read their posts to see why they mightve been killed....

 

[tae]

they didn't really post much, but we can look back into who that accused and their reasoning behind it and see why it could have been them killed.

i still wonder about blue roles in this game?
have we found anything evidence wise as to what the roles in play might be?

 

[Chrystina]

as i'm going through all these previous posts now... i have one quick question.
tae, who are you reading as TOWN?
i think you've been sus of everyone at this point...

 

[tae]

as i'm going through all these previous posts now... i have one quick question.
tae, who are you reading as TOWN?
i think you've been sus of everyone at this point...

right now i have no solid evidence that anyone but myself is town.
i'd like to believe that you're also town, but i don't have a compelling argument towards which side you pay be playing for, other than the fact that you were so damn sure of qwerty and she flipped town.

there's too many people here who haven't contributed enough to believe them to be town or not.
so far the only people who really contributed at all have been killed off. lol.

the only continuous active people here are you me and toad. and i'm sus of you both.

 

[toadsworthy]

OK, I literally just reread all of day 1 posts...

1. I also did some research online about NL vs Day 1 Lynching and I completely understand now hurray! I learned that with our set-up of 9 its best to Lynch day 1 and was very happy someone else did the percentages for me!
2. Alexi played an extremely strong foil to Lynn at the start of day one convo, but then once dust had cleared over NL they were all over Qwerty. I had called you out for being all for lynching people day 1 (granted this was when I was opposed to it) and you instantly said "what a scummy thing to say and support NL" which started the votes toward me because I didn't understand NL... but then you said you thought I was just confused and supported me, and we all continued on to Qwerty. If it was a tactic, you perfectly shifted suspicion on to me, and then cleared your own name (well played)
3. Runeraider posted the thing about NL being bad day one, but I think he is a smart enough and brash enough player to post that knowing "yeah its the smartest thing, but I'm gonna make sure they lynch a townie afterward" and I think he was annoyed I was so inexperienced and a strong proponent of NL that he wanted to just make me a target and kill me, while simultaneously looking like he knows everything and being a valuable player
4. I'm fine with keeping my vote on Helloxcutiee until they actually say something... because so passive, so innocent
5. Mother of all Llamas has never been suspected of anything, they just kinda throw little quips in here and now, but its nothing ever really substantial, so like what?
6. I totally trust Taesaek... despite wanting to lynch me

 

[Chrystina]

I literally can't even. what.

Let's start with

Alexi played an extremely strong foil to Lynn at the start of day one convo

Really?

I think Inkling's claim is warranted, I mean posting that quick in clear support one way over the other does look suspicious (whether faking or nah).... wouldn't anyone think?



what weirds me out, is that there was a pretty quick claim to make Lynn look innocent... not to mention the added "then again what would I know" just rubs me the wrong way

- - - Post Merge - - -

its obviously way to early to make a rash claim, but it looks like two mafia players trying to help each other, clear their names, and start a bandwagon on someone whose claim wasn't really that far-fetched

THIS WHOLE POST was before I made any reads on lynn. inkling called lynn's post sus and YOU agreed and even went as far to say qwerty and lynn were the scumteam. Not I.

but then once dust had cleared over NL they were all over Qwerty.

This has absolutely nothing to do with me since I was the ONLY one to vote when the majority wanted NL. Since that discussion brought up qwerty's flip flopping posts, to me that was scummy. You voted for qwerty too, must I remind you?

I had called you out for being all for lynching people day 1 (granted this was when I was opposed to it) and you instantly said "what a scummy thing to say and support NL" which started the votes toward me because I didn't understand NL...

Let's see.

you have to think if the flow of this conversation was going towards lynching someone who wasn't mafia, don't you think the mafia would WANT us to then go ahead and lynch someone? and thus expedite the killing off of our own people? so I'm quickly becoming suspicious of Alexi and Runeraider.... if they think they are in the clear they would of course want us to go ahead and lynch somebody, because its not anyone of their mafia goons.... they are trying to create chaos so that they can keep their own heads clean

wait what?
if anything scum would be trying to convince town to NL.

I cant even believe the discussion is still on about NL or no.

You actually singled me out and said it was scummy of me to push for a lynch. I didn't call you scum, it was the other way around.

but then you said you thought I was just confused and supported me, and we all continued on to Qwerty. If it was a tactic, you perfectly shifted suspicion on to me, and then cleared your own name (well played)

Oh, maybe thats because I actually never called you scum. Like I just said.

- - - Post Merge - - -

3. Runeraider posted the thing about NL being bad day one, but I think he is a smart enough and brash enough player to post that knowing "yeah its the smartest thing, but I'm gonna make sure they lynch a townie afterward" and I think he was annoyed I was so inexperienced and a strong proponent of NL that he wanted to just make me a target and kill me, while simultaneously looking like he knows everything and being a valuable player
6. I totally trust Taesaek... despite wanting to lynch me

I also find this GREAT.
You townread the two people who voted for you.
Hoping to get on their good site? Maybe seem less sus & not get voted this time?
Nice try.

 

[illunie]

I also find this GREAT.
You townread the two people who voted for you.
Hoping to get on their good site? Maybe seem less sus & not get voted this time?
Nice try.

For the record, that was a scumead on me. He just didn't actually out it.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Anyway, I can't think of any reason why mafia would kill Lynn, but hopefully I'll think of something. Bluesniping maybe?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh, and I'll do the case at some point, but I've got an assignment that I left till the last minute to do...

 

[tae]

bluesnipping is when you're taking out blue townies right?
i just wonder how it is anyone knows what blues we actually have in play?

wait does mafia know townie's roles too?

 

[illunie]

bluesnipping is when you're taking out blue townies right?
i just wonder how it is anyone knows what blues we actually have in play?

wait does mafia know townie's roles too?

Blue sniping is when the mafia kill someone because they think that they're a blue role. Judging by the table, we have either 1 or 2 blues in play.

Mafia only know that they're mafia, not the roles of the other players.

 

[tae]

bless you for helping my noob ass.
and ahh, so i was close enough.


but it's just strange to me that they chose lynn.
unless mafia is trying to set you up.


alexi pointed out that you posted about lynn flipping town, and guess what, she flipped town.
either you're mafia, or alexi is trying to make you out to be scum.

- - - Post Merge - - -

who tf called me a peacock.

- - - Post Merge - - -

ahh, i see that alexi voted toadsworthy already.

- - - Post Merge - - -

6. I totally trust Taesaek... despite wanting to lynch me

can't get me off your back this easily, shroom boy. >:3

- - - Post Merge - - -

Even though there's still plenty of time left for d1.. but if activity doesn't pick up i'd rather not vote, since it'll most likely be town that gets lynched.

yet you've been the first one to vote, both days?

is your toad vote now because you're a bit mad over his accusations/sus towards you?
why the sudden change of heart when i tried so hard day 1 to convince at least one person to switch votes to lynch toad?

I AM SO SORRY THAT I USE ZILLIONS OF ELLIPSES

you should be sorry toad. i was gonna slap you on day 1. <3

- - - Post Merge - - -

@helloxcutiee where the **** you at.

 

[Chrystina]

bless you for helping my noob ass.
and ahh, so i was close enough.


but it's just strange to me that they chose lynn.
unless mafia is trying to set you up.


alexi pointed out that you posted about lynn flipping town, and guess what, she flipped town.
either you're mafia, or alexi is trying to make you out to be scum.

- - - Post Merge - - -

who tf called me a peacock.

- - - Post Merge - - -

ahh, i see that alexi voted toadsworthy already.

- - - Post Merge - - -



can't get me off your back this easily, shroom boy. >:3

- - - Post Merge - - -



yet you've been the first one to vote, both days?

is your toad vote now because you're a bit mad over his accusations/sus towards you?
why the sudden change of heart when i tried so hard day 1 to convince at least one person to switch votes to lynch toad?



you should be sorry toad. i was gonna slap you on day 1. <3

- - - Post Merge - - -

@helloxcutiee where the **** you at.

first one to vote both days because activity actually picked up.
and I didn't change my vote day 1 b/c of reasons I already said.. there was very little time once you scumread him & and at that same exact moment I had something going on irl that I couldnt just be like "oh sorry i have to check a game on this forum and delay what is actually happening atm".

 

[tae]

first one to vote both days because activity actually picked up.
and I didn't change my vote day 1 b/c of reasons I already said.. there was very little time once you scumread him & and at that same exact moment I had something going on irl that I couldnt just be like "oh sorry i have to check a game on this forum and delay what is actually happening atm".

you were still around though? for the most part, you still came on and made a few posts those last 30 minutes or whatever?
i don't think activity picked up a whole lot, but your first vote was lynn right? and then changed to qwerty pretty easily, so it just makes me kinda curious as to why you flipped so fast, but then didn't flip to toad later on.

just a hunch tho.

- - - Post Merge - - -

whats your read on toad? since you spent all of the last bits of day1 avoiding reading him.

 

[Chrystina]

you were still around though? for the most part, you still came on and made a few posts those last 30 minutes or whatever?
i don't think activity picked up a whole lot, but your first vote was lynn right? and then changed to qwerty pretty easily, so it just makes me kinda curious as to why you flipped so fast, but then didn't flip to toad later on.

just a hunch tho.

- - - Post Merge - - -

whats your read on toad? since you spent all of the last bits of day1 avoiding reading him.

i was reading the back and forth between you and him, then noticed his new reply.. and thats what pretty much convinced me to vote for him. i was already leaning towards it but yeah.
honestly it was just horrible timing. like if that back and forth had happened just an hour earlier, when I was actively posting I would've scumread him too. like I am now.

- - - Post Merge - - -

and yes, I will point out I said earlier it seemed like town vs town.. but going back and actually reading it carefully there's a lot of things i had missed.

 

[tae]

i was reading the back and forth between you and him, then noticed his new reply.. and thats what pretty much convinced me to vote for him. i was already leaning towards it but yeah.
honestly it was just horrible timing. like if that back and forth had happened just an hour earlier, when I was actively posting I would've scumread him too. like I am now.

and yes, I will point out I said earlier it seemed like town vs town.. but going back and actually reading it carefully there's a lot of things i had missed.

toad was incredibly sus to me on day one after i looked into rune's accusation.
and then when he threatened us for the possibility of his lynching, that's when i REALLY got sus.
i mean who doesn't turn their head at the comment of "you'll regret lynching me" like is that a challenge or??

but then again there that fine line between being finicky with their ideas and playing too boldly.
that's the one thing that i can't figure out yet and it's driving me crazy and i wish more of the inactive players would pop their damned heads in soon. i'm getting itchy.

if i was mafia, i'd try to stay neutral enough that i wouldn't go under fire, but i definitely wouldn't be sticking my neck out that far on someone else's behalf.. and that's why i'm struggling with toad so much right now. and their new-found calm and collective buddy buddy approach towards me makes me unsettled because i don't know why they'd trust me so much even after i lit them on figurative fire day 1.

i'm sus of everyone,
but i want to hear other's opinions.

 

[toadsworthy]

Literally give me a stream of consciousness of why you think I'm the best candidate to be in the next lynching.... I've given you my reasonings for voting at the moment on Helloxcutiee! But all you guys keep saying is "I view him as scum" "I'm scum reading him now" but that is so general!

I flipped on NL because I didn't understand the difference, but now I realize what we did was the right decision
I flipped last second on Qwerty because I had a feeling that turned out to be right
I'm giving out valid reasons for things I saw after rereading after a day of chilling on this, and you're literally ****ting back on me just because I'm the only one talking about it

And now you are voting on me, because its the easy thing to do, but I'm sorry for trying to bring new ideas to the table and if your just gonna shoot the one opening his mouth, then just wait for the quiet ones to move in from the shadows to kill the rest

But literally guys, if I was mafia do you honestly think I would still be talking, I would've recoiled as fast as possible after Qwerty got majority last time! but I keep talking because I want us to start thinking outside the box, and stop pigeonholing each other just because were the only ones talking!

 

[inkling]

you were also pretty sure that qwerty was scum, she flipped town.

- - - Post Merge - - -



maybe you should be a little more active instead of posting once with an accusation and then never returning?
you're so quick to call someone else sus but then you disappear into lala land and it's like, well ok then.

- - - Post Merge - - -

you are an interesting character.

i was inactive for maybe a day and a half? where were you at the beginning? You're right that'd a made an accusation and seemed to have disappeared, but what i really did was get the ball rolling. it may have been a bit too much. we are down 2 townies and that's a huge loss. at the same time we have you and toad who are going back and forth.. about what exactly? not sure. we have a few others who are super quiet. Like I said we have about 2-3 mafia still out there and I'm not sure who is mafia at all. toad is prob innocent. you're prob innocent. what about llama guy? what about anybody who hasn't accused anybody and has contributed to the conversation only superficially? maybe thats who we should be looking at.

 

[toadsworthy]

Don't you think Rune is pretty sus right now too? He keeps acting like the big boss of all that is mafia? "Oh I'll post my views on it later", but never really doing it? "let me explain again for those who can't do maths" like damn, you made three posts just now, but couldn't take the slightest bit of time to help everyone out on why I am the biggest suspect, when you can clearly understand how important it is for them?
when he saw we were bickering about NL vs d1 Lynch, he posted that LONG guide to make himself look good and made himself to look like he was supporting Town. no one really talked about this at all.... I mean he sounds like he knows a lot about this game, moreso than all us arguing right now! So of course he knows why NL is stupid and knowingly can tell us about that guide to pose like a townie. But literally thats the biggest thing he's done, and I totally believe he could've given us that to stop our arguing yet still do it from a safe distance and sway convo away from him

he took the time to write out that long guide, but he can't take time to post anything else? he probably did it to pose like a townie, since he knew it was the answer we needed and it was advantageous to clear his head. Leaving us guessing about everything else makes us not even question him. And homie can't write a full post since then even though were begging for his input! Like I said he just made three posts, but couldn't compose a single paragraph about what he said ages ago....

I'm sorry I don't quote actual posts like everyone else does but I don't know how to do it without taking up a whole ton of time