Too many lazy villagers

[melletan]

Hi

I'm having a problem.
I have 3 lazy type villagers WHO I ADORE AND LOVE SO MUCH.
1.) Beau was one of the first five villagers that I had and he gave me a nickname! were best buds and a bit emotional just thinking if he moves out but I really hate the interior of his home (its the general interior bc hes one of the first five villagers to move in)
2.) Zucker I got him from a friend and I srsly love his character design and he is like uwu baby omg huhuhuhu just typing this is making me uwu
3.) Sherb got him from a campsite, at first I was intending on trading him for a dreamie but FOR SOME REASON HE BECAME MY FAVORITE AND I LOVE HIM LOTS UWU BABY BOI


I really want to have all personality types in my island but having 3 of the same is not really helping me HAAHAH.

pls help me decide which one should I let go of(not now but soon)

 

[BalloonFight]

I'm also a Lazy villager lover. I have Bones right now, and ideally I'll also get Lucky and Stitches for my island. Out of your list I'd probably boot Zucker before Sherb or Beau. Zucker is pretty cool and unique, but I definitely would prefer to keep Beau and Sherb over Zuck.

 

[lyradelphie04]

They're all so cute!! But, in your position, I'd probably say goodbye to Sherb. Beau was a first villager!! That's in your milestones. Zucker is adorable and there are so few octopi. Sherb's a cutie, but considering you originally intended to trade him in the first place, it's probably good to stick with that.

 

[raqball]

Well I just got Beau today off a mystery Island and I am already thinking about amiibo him out... Not diggin his house and for some reason I just don't really like him...

I love Zucker.. He is not going anywhere, ever!

 

[Xara]

hoo boy this is a tough decision. i love all 3 of them but honestly i’d probably get rid of sherb. while i think he’s adorable, i’ve got zucker on my island and i’ve grown so fond of him (even if he’s constantly talking about bugs lmao) and beau has been very special to me since new leaf came out so i could never boot him ;u;

 

[Jared:3]

I would personally boot Beau because he will never have his original house and is stuck with that DIY furniture which is unfortunate but it will never change

 

[0ni]

I WAS IN THIS EXACT POSITION! same villagers and everything lol

I ended up letting Sherb go to make room for a Dotty and as much as I do love Sherb, I don't regret the decision - 3 of any personality type is too many for me

best of luck with your decision, it's a tough one ~

 

[Mink777]

I have 4 lazies, and I have no problems with it.

 

[raqball]

I would personally boot Beau because he will never have his original house and is stuck with that DIY furniture which is unfortunate but it will never change

His upgraded house is terrible... He has a brick oven, a sleeping bag, a blanket and a picnic basket on the floor. After he moved in I went to his house and was like dang, this is terrible! LOL

Not my photo but this is his 'upgraded' non starter house.. YUCK!

 

[CowKing]

Honestly, I love Sherb to death and I would say you should keep Sherb, but you seem to have a connection with Beau so maybe keep him!

 

[raqball]

I have 4 lazies, and I have no problems with it.

I have 4 right now as well. Zucker, Ozzie, Beau and Lucky. I honestly think Beau is going to go...

 

[Alicia]

I've got two lazy villagers right now, Moe and Zucker. I was going to let Zucker move out at some point, but now I'm not sure I want too. Looks like I might have two lazy villagers for good.

 

[Hoosker]

I have 3 now as well!
Stitches, Zucker, and Sherb.

But I have the other 2 Octopus as well so I think I may let Zucker go... Also I don't love his house.
So I guess I suggest the same?

 

[Moon Cake]

I'm biased because I love Zucker but I would definitely choose to keep Zucker! I adore his design (and I like takoyaki) and he's just a sweetheart.

 

[BubbleBlowinDoubleBaby]

I have both Zucker and Sherb in my town and it's real hard for me to imagine letting either go! Personally, out of the 3, I would suggest booting Beau. I like Sherb way too much because as much as I like the models of goats, most of their faces/color schemes are off-putting to me, but Sherb is a total sweetie, and it's nice to have some more species variety! And Zucker is one of only 3 octopi in the game, and has such a cute design it's hard to not love him!

 

[Spooky.]

I feel you, I have two lazies and I love them both and I'm not sure I could let either of them go.

 

[starlightsong]

If your only reason for wanting to kick Beau is that you hate his interior, since it's just the basic starter interior you can fix it by trading him to a friend and having them trade him back to you! He'll end up with his "real" interior and he'll even still remember who you are and have any clothes you've gifted him. You can still have all 8 personality types with 3 lazies, though--you'd just need to have one each of the 7 other types, and your 3 lazies would add up to 10.

 

[Aleigh]

My vote is to kick Beau tbh

 

[raqball]

If your only reason for wanting to kick Beau is that you hate his interior, since it's just the basic starter interior you can fix it by trading him to a friend and having them trade him back to you! He'll end up with his "real" interior

I assume this was for the OP but even his upgraded house is UGLY. I posted a photo of it a few above. The photo I posted is what his house looks like. I believe that is his "real" interior..

 

[starlightsong]

I assume this was for the OP but even his upgraded house is UGLY. I posted a photo of it a few above. The photo I posted is what his house looks like. I believe that is his "real" interior..

That is his real house, my girlfriend has him. I don't mind it too much myself so that'd be up to the OP if they like it and wanna try trading him to fix it or not! It's also possible to try gifting him things to replace the sleeping bag and such--you're only completely out of luck if you hate the wall and/or flooring. Personally, I had Zucker for a while and like him a lot, even kinda like his house, but didn't like his wallpaper in this game at all and it was part of why I let him leave