What do you think of other person's villagers?

[IslaYuka]

Hi there. Probably a thread like this has been made before at some point but I would like to make it anyways lol.

I thought it may be fun to see what people think about each other's villagers and to see which villagers are your favorites and which are permanent!

My own villagers are: Rosie, Paolo, Soleil, Lyman, Goldie, Agnes, Pietro, Tom, Rilla and Étoile (as seen in my signature).

It's difficult to pick a favorite but my newest are Soleil and Goldie and I really really like them!

I don't really know who's permanent and who's not but if someone were to leave it would be Goldie, Rosie, Rilla, Étoile or Agnes because I have them as amiibo and can invite them back in case I change my mind.

 

[Dunquixote]

Hi there. Probably a thread like this has been made before at some point but I would like to make it anyways lol.

I thought it may be fun to "rate" each others villagers. With that I mean all 10 villagers as a whole. Maybe also mention who are permanent and who aren't or who your favorite is!

Some examples are:
Do you think it's a fun/unique combination? Do you love/dislike any specific villagers on the list? Are there villagers you've not seen before on other's islands? Does the person have any dreamies of yours?

My own villagers are: Rosie, Paolo, Soleil, Lyman, Goldie, Agnes, Pietro, Tom, Rilla and Étoile (as seen in my signature). It's difficult to pick a favorite but my newest are Soleil and Goldie and I really really like them! I don't really know who's permanent and who's not but if someone were to leave it would be Goldie, Rosie, Rilla, Étoile
or Agnes because I have them as amiibo and can invite them back in case I change my mind.

Rosie: 10/10 - she has been one of my favorite villagers since NL. I always thought she looked derpy but in a cute way and her color is really pretty . She is a dreamie who I have (but may let go and maybe reinvite via amiibo so I can try out villagers out).

Tom: 7/10 - I think he is cute! I did use his amiibo card to kick someone out and then reinvite them; would love to have him longer even if just temporary. I can’t say his design is one of my top favorites but I do like it a lot . He’s not a dreamie but is one I’m interested in.

Etoile: 7/10 - I’m not much into pastel colors - even purple my favorite color, but I strangley still like her colors and overall design. This rating is without having her on my island or talking to her much on other people’s islands. I hope to eventually get around to inviting her for her picture and to get to know her.

Goldie: I’m not much of a dog person but I do think Goldie is adorable. I’d rate her as maybe as 7/10.

Agnes: 7/10 - she as well as the ones I mentioned prior have the potential be rated higher. I’ve been interested in Agnes for at least a couple of months thanks to the screenshots and positive things I have heard about her from other users here. I don’t like pig villagers but I really do like her design and color.

Rilla: 1/10 - sorry. My opinion of some gorillas have significantly improved but I still won’t budge on two of them. I do plan on inviting her eventually to try to get her picture so maybe my opinion will change, but for now, I can’t say I like her design or colors.

Pietro: 3/10 - he has grown on me a little but I still am not a fan of clowns or clownlike designs or villagers with makeup aside from maybe blush. I will try to keep having an open mind on him though; I do like seeing others screenshots of him and hearing how much they love him.

Soleil: 5/10 - her design has been growing on me a bit more. In time, her rating may be higher.

Paolo: 3/10 - maybe lower. I though he was a little cute a few times but I am still unsure since I am still not a big fan of elephants and I don’t like pink (i do like Puddles though but that occurred from bonding in NL). I don’t have his amiibo card so may eventually grab him when looking for a new villager.

Lyman: 1/10 - not a fan of the koalas and I never liked his design. i’ve seen some cute screenshots of him (I think a friend may have posted some) so this could change. My opinions on villagers have been changing relatively frequently.

My villagers are:

Punchy, Rudy, Raymond, Rosie, Merry, Reneigh (temporary), Judy (maybe temporary but keeping until she gets amiibo card maybe), Sherb (dreamie but I may replace with Dom who I regret letting go. Ideally I want to keep both but I still have other villagers I want as well...), Spike, Kiki.

 

[-Blue-]

@IslaYuka My one friend had Goldie on their NL town and I always made it a thing to go and greet her every time I visited. If I had an extra villager spot in my town, I would definitely invite her. I also had Rosie in the same town, but she wasn't one of the mainstays and left because where she plotted, but I did like her. You have a nice line-up of villagers!

@Dunquixote I have Punchy on my island. I kept island jumping because I was getting some really weird lazy designs and just decided to go with him because seemed cool. My original lazy on NL was Walker and I kind of wanted him back when I got into NH, but I've grown to like Punchy too much to let him go.

Your villagers are cool to! The only one I had to look up was Spike. I vaguely remembered him from visiting his RV for some stuff in NL.

Mine are Butch, Hazel, Willow, Margie, Frita, Punchy, Buck, Flora, Curlos, and Kiki.

Punchy, Flora, and Margie were all the villagers I found when doing the scripted island jumping in the beginning. I was originally going to move them out for the villagers I had on NL because I grew fond of them, but now that's not the case since I've grown fond of them lol. I put Curlos, Frita, and Willow's homes together because they're sheep friends.

 

[IslaYuka]

@Dunquixote Thanks for rating! I know Rilla is the least popular Sanrio villager (and gorillas in general are disliked) but I think I'm drawn to unpopular villagers or something lol. On my previous island Truffles was my favorite while she is the least popular peppy.

Punchy: 6/10. I don't really mind punchy but I think he's one of my least favorite cats. Wouldn't mind to let him live on my island though.

Rudy: 10/10. I just love his design! I love the holiday season and he reminds me of that. Also I think his goofy design fits the jock personality perfectly!

Raymond: 4/10. Raymond doesn't have a bad design but he was extremely overhyped when ACNH was still new and I think seeing his face constantly everywhere made me kind of dislike him. I love that he has 2 different eye colours though.

Rosie 8/10: Rosie is relatively new to my island so I can't really tell if I really like her yet but her design is just really cute. Also like her house.

Merry 6/10: She is okay but I wouldn't pick her as my peppy villager. She is comparable to Rosie in terms of cuteness.

Reneigh: 7/10 while the sisterly personality is my least favorite, Reneigh is pretty good. I really like the pink tone in her manes and her design fits the sisterly personality.

Judy: 8/10 She has a very unique design that sets her apart from the other villagers. I understand why she is so popular and she is a must have of you like the more "girly/cute" villagers.

Sherb: 8/10 Sherb may be popular mainly because he's a new villager but I like him because he's cute. The best goat villager imo.
I would definitely invite him if I needed a lazy villager and came across him on a mystery island tour.

Spike 8/10 Not a fan of the crankies but Spike is in my top 5! I really like the rhino villagers and think they're underrated. His color scheme is really good looking.

Kiki 9/10: she's really cute, even her name is cute on itself lol. She might be competition for Rosie if I pull her amiibo card from a pack!

@TheDuke55

I really like Kiki, Flora and Hazel! Hazel just fits for a sisterly villager and Kiki and Flora are just cute. Flora is also a really good pick for a more tropical island. I like flamingos irl aswell and it's nice they made a flamingo villager (although her species is refered to as ostrich in game)

I'm not a fan of Butch and Curlos. I had Frita on my previous island and at first I didn't even notice her fastfood theme until I entered her house lol.

Also really nice you put the sheep together! Very nice villagers overall!

 

[PugLovex]

Your villagers are cool to! The only one

Mine are Butch, Hazel, Willow, Margie, Frita, Punchy, Buck, Flora, Curlos, and Kiki.

Punchy, Flora, and Margie were all the villagers I found when doing the scripted island jumping in the beginning. I was originally going to move them out for the villagers I had on NL because I grew fond of them, but now that's not the case since I've grown fond of them lol. I put Curlos, Frita, and Willow's homes together because they're sheep friends.

punchy - 8/10 love his fun design, he’s very cute! i love lazy villagers so bonus points

flora - 8/10 her design is very unique and her pink color is great! my best friend has her on her island and she loves her

hazel - 7/10 she honestly makes the unibrow work! i had her in my nl town, i love her “uni-wow” catchphrase

willow - 7/10 a classic, although she moved into my NH island and she didn’t move when i gave her the get go to when she asked lol so that made me annoyed. otherwise shes good

margie - 9/10 sweet elephant! i love her design and dobūstu no mori made me like her even more

frita - 6/10 not the biggest fan of her, but she does have the nice burger-like design lol

butch - 8/10 i love his design! i love cranky villagers too so more bonus points, hes a sweet dog

buck - 8/10 hes cool although he reminds me of a guy at my school LMAO

curlos - 8/10 i honestly really love his design. fits his smug personality perfectly.

kiki - 10/10 love her!! she was in one of my wild world towns she’s so precious. i love her design, i would totally have her as a cat irl!

my villagers are:
cranston
raymond
poppy
lolly
dobie
timbra
monty
bea
winnie
beau

 

[Dunquixote]

@Dunquixote Thanks for rating! I know Rilla is the least popular Sanrio villager (and gorillas in general are disliked) but I think I'm drawn to unpopular villagers or something lol. On my previous island Truffles was my favorite while she is the least popular peppy.

Punchy: 6/10. I don't really mind punchy but I think he's one of my least favorite cats. Wouldn't mind to let him live on my island though.

Rudy: 10/10. I just love his design! I love the holiday season and he reminds me of that. Also I think his goofy design fits the jock personality perfectly!

Raymond: 4/10. Raymond doesn't have a bad design but he was extremely overhyped when ACNH was still new and I think seeing his face constantly everywhere made me kind of dislike him. I love that he has 2 different eye colours though.

Rosie 8/10: Rosie is relatively new to my island so I can't really tell if I really like her yet but her design is just really cute. Also like her house.

Merry 6/10: She is okay but I wouldn't pick her as my peppy villager. She is comparable to Rosie in terms of cuteness.

Reneigh: 7/10 while the sisterly personality is my least favorite, Reneigh is pretty good. I really like the pink tone in her manes and her design fits the sisterly personality.

Judy: 8/10 She has a very unique design that sets her apart from the other villagers. I understand why she is so popular and she is a must have of you like the more "girly/cute" villagers.

Sherb: 8/10 Sherb may be popular mainly because he's a new villager but I like him because he's cute. The best goat villager imo.
I would definitely invite him if I needed a lazy villager and came across him on a mystery island tour.

Spike 8/10 Not a fan of the crankies but Spike is in my top 5! I really like the rhino villagers and think they're underrated. His color scheme is really good looking.

Kiki 9/10: she's really cute, even her name is cute on itself lol. She might be competition for Rosie if I pull her amiibo card from a pack!

@TheDuke55

I really like Kiki, Flora and Hazel! Hazel just fits for a sisterly villager and Kiki and Flora are just cute. Flora is also a really good pick for a more tropical island. I like flamingos irl aswell and it's nice they made a flamingo villager (although her species is refered to as ostrich in game)

I'm not a fan of Butch and Curlos. I had Frita on my previous island and at first I didn't even notice her fastfood theme until I entered her house lol.

Also really nice you put the sheep together! Very nice villagers overall!

That’s great that you are drawn to the gorillas and unpopular ones ; I do see why some people may like that and I respect that. I do think they deserve more love even if I personally am not interested in them or like their design.

@TheDuke55 You have a lot of cool villagers yourself! Hazel is one I’ve been interested in. I used to not like her, but she has grown on me. I even think her unibrow is cute. I’d give her 8/10 - maybe higher.

Frita - I had her in NL but can’t remember her sadly. Her design though 10/10. If I had more room, I’d definitely pick her to be my uchi. I really think her design is clever and cute.

Margie - 7/10: I used to not like elephants at all but @xara and others helped me appreciate their different designs and Margie is actually one of the first I started to like. She looks very sweet .

Flora - 7/10: I think she may be my favorite of all the ostriches. I always thought flamingos were cute .

Curlos - 7/10 - he seems really cool. I like a good amount of the sheep villagers and he may have been one of the first I had been interested in. I like his name a lot and his colors are nice

Willow - 7/10 She really is cute. I do like some of the other sheep better but I am finding it very hard not to like her. I thought I didn’t at one point but now I definitely can appreciate her design.

Butch - 6/10 he’s pretty cute. I think in time his rating will be higher as well with the other dogs. I think there is only one dog whose design I dislike.

Punchy - 10/10 my favorite villager. He was my starter in NL so I am extremely fond of him and I love how he looks very smug. I just wish he and the other lazies would not talk about bugs.

Kiki - 10/10 I used to not like her back in NL but then I decided to adopt her from someone on tbt. I have grown very fond of her and her squished nose since then (I think the nose may have been what bothered me lol).

@PugLovex

Cranston - 6/10 - For the longest time I have been indifferent to a lot of the ostriches but his design has been growing on me and may continue on growing on me. He seems pretty cool .

Raymond - 10/10 - I may be biased since I have him and love cats . I totally understand why some may not like him. Me, all that matters to me is his design and if we click; I never understood why he was popular since i paid no attention until I wanted him. His toothy grin and his grumpy appearance is what won me over with him.

Poppy - 10/10 - I love a lot of the squirrels. I have to say she has to be one of the cutest ones in my opinion. I love her smile, her small eyes and her color and overall design.

Lolly - 10/10 - one of my dreamies but I don’t have any more room for her. I used to have a gray tabby cat so that may be part of the reason I like her design and I just love her face and overall design and the fact she is a cat .

Dobie - 6/10 - I have been pretty indifferent to the wolves design but he has grown on me the more I see pictures and hear about him. Interesting design and very lovable looking too. I think in time I may grow to like him more.

Timbra - 6/10 - she’s pretty! Not a fan of a lot of makeup on villagers but I think hers doesn’t bother me as much as others.

Monty - 7/10 maybe 8. I haven’t paid much attention to him honestly but looking at his picture, I do think he is really cute.

Bea - 5/10 - not my favorite dog but I can see her charms and may grow to like her more. I know i keep saying this but I really mean it . Been keeping a more open mind about villagers that I used to be indifferent or even dislike and seeing screenshots and reading people’s opinions helped me reconsider looking at many other villagers even if they were to stay only temporarily.

Winnie - I’m not a big fan of a lot of the horses. I would give her 5/10 - I do think she is pretty cute and I like her a lot more than quite a few of the other horses and I also like her name too.

Beau - 5/10 - I’ve been pretty indifferent about Beau for the most part but I think he is pretty cute and can see why others like him.

 

[Licorice]

My villagers are:

Punchy, Rudy, Raymond, Rosie, Merry, Reneigh (temporary), Judy (maybe temporary but keeping until she gets amiibo card maybe), Sherb (dreamie but I may replace with Dom who I regret letting go. Ideally I want to keep both but I still have other villagers I want as well...), Spike, Kiki.

Punchy: 7/10 Easily one of the best cats imo and I don’t even like cats. He’s on the gamecube game box art so I’ve always lowkey liked him.

Rudy: 3/10 I’m sorry but I cannot stand his face idk why. Also he’s a cat.

Raymond: 2/10 He’s just so boring to me.

Rosie: 8/10 One of the most iconic villagers.

Merry: 5/10 Just meh. I sorta like her bangs and eye shape but I really don’t care for cats.

Reneigh: 6/10 She’s okay. I feel neutral towards her.

Judy: 2/10 I feel so mean lol but I feel like she looks so out of place compared to other villagers. Like she doesn’t belong in animal crossing or something.

Sherb: 4/10 He’s so bland imo and he’s cross eyed.

Spike: 10/10!!! A good boy!

Kiki: 7/10 She’s nostalgic for me because my bff in the 5th grade loved her and she lives in my gc town.


My villagers:
Tad
Bubbles
Cesar
Plucky
Deli
Mac
Tex
Violet
Jambette
Rocco

 

[Dunquixote]

Punchy: 7/10 Easily one of the best cats imo and I don’t even like cats. He’s on the gamecube game box art so I’ve always lowkey liked him.

Rudy: 3/10 I’m sorry but I cannot stand his face idk why. Also he’s a cat.

Raymond: 2/10 He’s just so boring to me.

Rosie: 8/10 One of the most iconic villagers.

Merry: 5/10 Just meh. I sorta like her bangs and eye shape but I really don’t care for cats.

Reneigh: 6/10 She’s okay. I feel neutral towards her.

Judy: 2/10 I feel so mean lol but I feel like she looks so out of place compared to other villagers. Like she doesn’t belong in animal crossing or something.

Sherb: 4/10 He’s so bland imo and he’s cross eyed.

Spike: 10/10!!! A good boy!

Kiki: 7/10 She’s nostalgic for me because my bff in the 5th grade loved her and she lives in my gc town.


My villagers:
Tad
Bubbles
Cesar
Plucky
Deli
Mac
Tex
Violet
Jambette
Rocco

No need to be sorry! I know not everyone will like the same villagers. I appreciate hearing your opinions.

Tad - 7/10 - I think he’s pretty cute .

Bubbles - 6/10 - she is starting to grow on me. I used to not like hippos but seeing Rocco in Bunny Day outfit and pictures of Biff and Bertha helped me realize there were quite a few I liked.

Cesar - 3/10 - he’s alright. i’m only starting to like a few gorillas - namely Peewee and maybe Hans. In time maybe I’ll like Cesar.

Plucky - 0/10 not a fan of the female chickens at all. Sorry ><

Deli - 10/10 - he is one of my favorite of the monkey villagers .

Mac - 10/10 - i think he’s really cute too! I don’t see enough pictures of him.

Tex -8/10 - i used to not like him but that changed sometime after he came from a friend’s void (once i found out that he was from there and was recommended to try dressing him up). He looks adorable in the top hat, tailcoat or vampire outfit (the red one).

Violet - 0/10 sorry. she’s one of the villagers I like the least. It’s great you like her. I just am very picky . It was hard for me to overcome my dislike for gorillas. makeup is just a big turn off for me.

Jambette 1/10 - also close to the bottom of my least liked villager list but I have been enjoying seeing some screenshots of her.

Rocco 10/10 - my favorite hippo. I just love how grumpy he looks. Looks great in the bunny day outfits.

 

[WaileaNoRei]

Punchy: 7/10 Easily one of the best cats imo and I don’t even like cats. He’s on the gamecube game box art so I’ve always lowkey liked him.

Rudy: 3/10 I’m sorry but I cannot stand his face idk why. Also he’s a cat.

Raymond: 2/10 He’s just so boring to me.

Rosie: 8/10 One of the most iconic villagers.

Merry: 5/10 Just meh. I sorta like her bangs and eye shape but I really don’t care for cats.

Reneigh: 6/10 She’s okay. I feel neutral towards her.

Judy: 2/10 I feel so mean lol but I feel like she looks so out of place compared to other villagers. Like she doesn’t belong in animal crossing or something.

Sherb: 4/10 He’s so bland imo and he’s cross eyed.

Spike: 10/10!!! A good boy!

Kiki: 7/10 She’s nostalgic for me because my bff in the 5th grade loved her and she lives in my gc town.


My villagers:
Tad
Bubbles
Cesar
Plucky
Deli
Mac
Tex
Violet
Jambette
Rocco

What a great group!
Bubbles - 9/10 - she is so adorable, I don’t know why but I just love her whole look and think she fits the peppy personality really well.

Mac - 9/10 - I used to think I would not like many jocks, but I really love a lot of their designs. I like how grumpy his little face is and his catch phrase make him extra endearing.

Plucky - 8/10 - I also used to think I did not like the chickens. And I am still not sure I actually like plucky…but I have this very strong interest in her right now and would love to see if I would like having her on my island.

Rocco - 8/10 - I am not big on the cranky personality but a lot of their designs are very interesting. Plus I just like all the hippos, they are very cute and cuddly.

Deli - 6/10 not super familiar with Deli, and I really love Simon, so it makes me kind of biased, but I generally think he is very cute.

Tad - 6/10 - another one I am not very familiar with, but he looks cute and I like his funny little facial expressions

Tex - 6/10 - same as the two above, he is interesting and I generally like the way the penguins look, but I am not familiar with him.

Caesar- 5/10 - like so many people I don’t really favor the gorilla design, though my feeling about them have softened and I think their little butts are adorable and hilarious. Caesar I feel some fondness for because my friend had him for a long time on her island and really liked him and would give him the best outfits. Plus he is orange, my favorite color.

Jambette - 5/10 - her lips are too much for me, but I have seen some great screenshots of her that make me want to like her. Plus her design is just so unique. Sometimes I am sure I now like her or at least feel generally positive toward her, and at others is am convinced I do not like her at all…so I just don’t know. I put 5 but it is more like either a 6/10 or a 2/10 and flipping back and forth from moment to moment. (The video of her singing I just watched swung it toward the higher side)

Violet - 4/10 - I like her color, and the blue details. Gorillas are not my favorites, and I tend to like squishier looking villagers. But she’s a pretty gorilla.

My villagers are:
Genji
Bangle
Flurry
Tabby
Soleil
Sydney
Hamlet
Weber
Deena
Rodney

or alternatively (aka on my second island):
Flip
Reneigh
Merry
Gladys
Mac
Wendy
Judy
Ursala
Bea
Paolo

 

[Dunquixote]

What a great group!
Bubbles - 9/10 - she is so adorable, I don’t know why but I just love her whole look and think she fits the peppy personality really well.

Mac - 9/10 - I used to think I would not like many jocks, but I really love a lot of their designs. I like how grumpy his little face is and his catch phrase make him extra endearing.

Plucky - 8/10 - I also used to think I did not like the chickens. And I am still not sure I actually like plucky…but I have this very strong interest in her right now and would love to see if I would like having her on my island.

Rocco - 8/10 - I am not big on the cranky personality but a lot of their designs are very interesting. Plus I just like all the hippos, they are very cute and cuddly.

Deli - 6/10 not super familiar with Deli, and I really love Simon, so it makes me kind of biased, but I generally think he is very cute.

Tad - 6/10 - another one I am not very familiar with, but he looks cute and I like his funny little facial expressions

Tex - 6/10 - same as the two above, he is interesting and I generally like the way the penguins look, but I am not familiar with him.

Caesar- 5/10 - like so many people I don’t really favor the gorilla design, though my feeling about them have softened and I think their little butts are adorable and hilarious. Caesar I feel some fondness for because my friend had him for a long time on her island and really liked him and would give him the best outfits. Plus he is orange, my favorite color.

Jambette - 5/10 - her lips are too much for me, but I have seen some great screenshots of her that make me want to like her. Plus her design is just so unique. Sometimes I am sure I now like her or at least feel generally positive toward her, and at others is am convinced I do not like her at all…so I just don’t know. I put 5 but it is more like either a 6/10 or a 2/10 and flipping back and forth from moment to moment. (The video of her singing I just watched swung it toward the higher side)

Violet - 4/10 - I like her color, and the blue details. Gorillas are not my favorites, and I tend to like squishier looking villagers. But she’s a pretty gorilla.

My villagers are:
Genji
Bangle
Flurry
Tabby
Soleil
Sydney
Hamlet
Weber
Deena
Rodney

or alternatively (aka on my second island):
Flip
Reneigh
Merry
Gladys
Mac
Wendy
Judy
Ursala
Bea
Paolo

Seeing your ratings, I hope I wasn’t too harsh with anyone. If so, I really apologize. I tried not to be rude but to be honest too. ><. You word things much better than me .

1st island:

Genji - 7/10 - might be 8. I am really interested in this guy. I know you used to mention him from time-to-time which helped a lot in me developing an interest in him. Prior to that, I can’t remember how I felt. I don’t think I ever had a negative opinion or strong of one if I did. He is really unique looking and I really like that . I think he’d be fun to meet and get to know.

Bangle - 8/10 - I still am not much of a fan of the big cats designs but again thanks largely to you, @Rosch, I have a better appreciation for them and am actually starting to like a lot of them (including Rolf and Bangle) minus the lions. I definitely would love to invite Bangle and a couple others to get to know better. She is really cute and from meeting her in your dream address and seeing your screenshots, I can see why you love her.

Flurry: 5/10 - I haven’t formed an opinion on her yet. I have seen a lot of cute pictures of her but still am taking time to decide how I feel. I know I did pass her up plenty of times in my earlier island hopping. I think in time I will have a stronger opinion, but atm I’m neutral.

Tabby: 8/10 - another one you’ve got me interested in. I did see her in my campsite once but sadly I had to pass her up with no spots open. I think she’s cute even though I used to think she was ugly. I am not sure how to describe what about her I now like. It does help a little that I like cats and tabbies. I think her smile and design is pretty interesting and helps make her stand out from the rest and I don’t think in a bad way (for me that is) and then coupled with the peppy energy, I think she seems really sweet and fun.

Soleil - 5/10: her design is growing on me. Her colors are really pretty .

Sydney - 6/10 - I’m not much of a koala fan but I have always thought Sydney’s color was pretty and she looked the most appealing to me. Now, I’m starting to like Gonzo too, so I think in time I may grow to like her more. She does seem very sweet though .

Hamlet - I had a beef with him because he wouldn’t move out in NL when I wanted him to (he did eventually leave) and that muscle talk annoyed me. That is why for the longest time I hated jocks, but Rudy has helped change that (even though I could do without the sweat talk lol). I give hamlet 5/10. I think I’m over what happened in NL and now my opinion is pretty neutral. Maybe in time I’ll grow to like him.

Weber - 5/10: I honestly wasn’t much of a duck fan but your screenshots again have peeked some interest in me. I give him a 5 for now since I am pretty neutral about his design.

Deena - 3/10: she’s alright, but I think I can see her appeal. I can see myself liking her eventually.

Rodney: 10/10 I can’t believe this, but yes I give him 10. I think his face was what initially turned me off but now I think his face is seriously adorable. I love the expression he usually has on his face: gives me a smug lazy vibe; I think he’s also extremely cool . He is also extremely fun to dress up.




I’ll do your second island’s villagers in another post later .

 

[peddleduck]

Rosie: 10/10 - she has been one of my favorite villagers since NL. I always thought she looked derpy but in a cute way and her color is really pretty . She is a dreamie who I have (but may let go and maybe reinvite via amiibo so I can try out villagers out).

Tom: 7/10 - I think he is cute! I did use his amiibo card to kick someone out and then reinvite them; would love to have him longer even if just temporary. I can’t say his design is one of my top favorites but I do like it a lot . He’s not a dreamie but is one I’m interested in.

Etoile: 7/10 - I’m not much into pastel colors - even purple my favorite color, but I strangley still like her colors and overall design. This rating is without having her on my island or talking to her much on other people’s islands. I hope to eventually get around to inviting her for her picture and to get to know her.

Goldie: I’m not much of a dog person but I do think Goldie is adorable. I’d rate her as maybe as 7/10.

Agnes: 7/10 - she as well as the ones I mentioned prior have the potential be rated higher. I’ve been interested in Agnes for at least a couple of months thanks to the screenshots and positive things I have heard about her from other users here. I don’t like pig villagers but I really do like her design and color.

Rilla: 1/10 - sorry. My opinion of some gorillas have significantly improved but I still won’t budge on two of them. I do plan on inviting her eventually to try to get her picture so maybe my opinion will change, but for now, I can’t say I like her design or colors.

Pietro: 3/10 - he has grown on me a little but I still am not a fan of clowns or clownlike designs or villagers with makeup aside from maybe blush. I will try to keep having an open mind on him though; I do like seeing others screenshots of him and hearing how much they love him.

Soleil: 5/10 - her design has been growing on me a bit more. In time, her rating may be higher.

Paolo: 3/10 - maybe lower. I though he was a little cute a few times but I am still unsure since I am still not a big fan of elephants and I don’t like pink (i do like Puddles though but that occurred from bonding in NL). I don’t have his amiibo card so may eventually grab him when looking for a new villager.

Lyman: 1/10 - not a fan of the koalas and I never liked his design. i’ve seen some cute screenshots of him (I think a friend may have posted some) so this could change. My opinions on villagers have been changing relatively frequently.

My villagers are:

Punchy, Rudy, Raymond, Rosie, Merry, Reneigh (temporary), Judy (maybe temporary but keeping until she gets amiibo card maybe), Sherb (dreamie but I may replace with Dom who I regret letting go. Ideally I want to keep both but I still have other villagers I want as well...), Spike, Kiki.

Punchy - 8/10. He's soooo cute, I don't know what it is. I've never had him, but I recently got his amiibo and would like to try him out once I'm ready to let my villagers go!
Rudy - 10/10. He was one of my starters in ACNH, and he's so cute. I have a huge softspot for jocks though, and I just love how much of a baby he is
Rosie - 5/10. I've never had Rosie tbh! But she's cute. But I love a few more than her.
Merry - 9/10. I love her chubby little double chin! She's so cute, I'd love to have her eventually.
Reneigh - 7/10 - I forget she exists, but the pun's too funny. Do feel bad people seem to forget about Renee for her though.
Sherb - 10/10. He's the GOAT. My girlfriend has him on her island, and I've asked her to hold onto him until I can grab him. Ironically, I also got Dom from her, because she somehow managed to get the two of them AND Raymond within starting the game back in March.
Spike - 100/10! Spike's one of my favorites. Rhinos are one of my favorite animals as is cranky being my favorite personality type. Also, he's super punk and orange? It's like he was made for me, lol! I adore him so much and miss him from my island ;_;
Kiki - 7/10. I love that she has a meme face and also would like to have her in my island someday too, but she's no Merry lol.

My islanders are Joey, Gayle [waiting for her to leave since i've had her for ages], Ken, Dom, Coco, Clay, Pashmina, Freya, Chevre, and Audie!

 

[WaileaNoRei]

Seeing your ratings, I hope I wasn’t too harsh with anyone. If so, I really apologize. I tried not to be rude but to be honest too. ><. You word things much better than me .

1st island:

Genji - 7/10 - might be 8. I am really interested in this guy. I know you used to mention him from time-to-time which helped a lot in me developing an interest in him. Prior to that, I can’t remember how I felt. I don’t think I ever had a negative opinion or strong of one if I did. He is really unique looking and I really like that . I think he’d be fun to meet and get to know.

Bangle - 8/10 - I still am not much of a fan of the big cats designs but again thanks largely to you, @Rosch, I have a better appreciation for them and am actually starting to like a lot of them (including Rolf and Bangle) minus the lions. I definitely would love to invite Bangle and a couple others to get to know better. She is really cute and from meeting her in your dream address and seeing your screenshots, I can see why you love her.

Flurry: 5/10 - I haven’t formed an opinion on her yet. I have seen a lot of cute pictures of her but still am taking time to decide how I feel. I know I did pass her up plenty of times in my earlier island hopping. I think in time I will have a stronger opinion, but atm I’m neutral.

Tabby: 8/10 - another one you’ve got me interested in. I did see her in my campsite once but sadly I had to pass her up with no spots open. I think she’s cute even though I used to think she was ugly. I am not sure how to describe what about her I now like. It does help a little that I like cats and tabbies. I think her smile and design is pretty interesting and helps make her stand out from the rest and I don’t think in a bad way (for me that is) and then coupled with the peppy energy, I think she seems really sweet and fun.

Soleil - 5/10: her design is growing on me. Her colors are really pretty .

Sydney - 6/10 - I’m not much of a koala fan but I have always thought Sydney’s color was pretty and she looked the most appealing to me. Now, I’m starting to like Gonzo too, so I think in time I may grow to like her more. She does seem very sweet though .

Hamlet - I had a beef with him because he wouldn’t move out in NL when I wanted him to (he did eventually leave) and that muscle talk annoyed me. That is why for the longest time I hated jocks, but Rudy has helped change that (even though I could do without the sweat talk lol). I give hamlet 5/10. I think I’m over what happened in NL and now my opinion is pretty neutral. Maybe in time I’ll grow to like him.

Weber - 5/10: I honestly wasn’t much of a duck fan but your screenshots again have peeked some interest in me. I give him a 5 for now since I am pretty neutral about his design.

Deena - 3/10: she’s alright, but I think I can see her appeal. I can see myself liking her eventually.

Rodney: 10/10 I can’t believe this, but yes I give him 10. I think his face was what initially turned me off but now I think his face is seriously adorable. I love the expression he usually has on his face: gives me a smug lazy vibe; I think he’s also extremely cool . He is also extremely fun to dress up.




I’ll do your second island’s villagers in another post later .

you are fine! Honest but never mean! I am just wishy washy and prone to liking a new villager everyday (I tried to make a short favorites list and added 60 villagers to it)! And like you, my opinion is always being changed by the cute pics and videos I see.

 

[Dunquixote]

@WaileaNoRei

2nd Island
Flip - 10/10! He’s the other monkey I really like. I really love his face, color and overall design . Such a cutie.

Reneigh - 8/10 - I’m not attached to her yet but I do like her design a lot .

Merry - 10/10 - one of my dreamies. I love her little teeth and her bangs. I had always thought I liked Rosie more than her, but now I like them equally or maybe Merry a little more.

Gladys - 4/10 - she’s a sweetheart. I had her in NL. I don’t dislike her, though I may have had a little tough time getting her to move in NL.

Mac - 10/10. I love his face. I think he was the first dog to give me a strong impression; I recall you talking about him and how you were starting to like him when I starting paying more attention to him too.

Wendy - 8 or 9/10. One of the first sheep that have caught my eye. I love the color and her face looks so gentle and kind.

Judy - I used to not like her mainly because of her eyes but now I give her between 8-10/10 rating. Not a fan of pastel or pink but I still like the color combination; I like the color of her eyes (and how galaxy looking they are) more. I have grown fond of her since I found her at my campsite. She is taking up a temporary spot but I am not ready to let her leave yet.

Ursala - 6/10 - I honestly didn’t like the bears at all but I think she is one of the few that have been slowly starting to grow on me. She has a pretty cute face .

Bea - 5/10 - will need more time. Atm, I’m neutral about her. I do think she does have a sweet face and can see why others may like her :$.

Paolo - 3/10. I may like him in time. Will eventually invite him if I see him on a tour since I don’t have his amiibo. Maybe then while trying to get his picture he’ll grow more one me.

@peddleduck

Joey - 7/10. I didn’t think I liked the ducks much but after hearing about him recently and seeing some cute pictures, I have started to appreciate his cuteness. I never had an issue with him but I guess I was mostly indifferent. There are quite a few ducks I disliked outright but he wasn’t one of them.

Gayle - 1/10 - not a fan of any of the alligators and I don’t like her color scheme or design. I think though I could grow to like (or become more neutral) her and all but one of the alligators.

Ken - 8/10 maybe higher. I don’t like a lot of the chickens but I definitely like him and his color scheme. His expression is pretty cool too!

Dom - 10/10. I used to not like those eyes but those eyes are honestly part of his charm. I plan on making him a permanent on day. I love his expressions so much!

Coco - 7/10 - She’s pretty interesting! i like her.

Clay 7/10 - he also has a pretty interesting design as well.

Pashmina - I like very few goat villagers but she and Kidd are ones I have been interested in for awhile. I give her 6/10. Definitely would like to invite her to my island eventually to get to know.

Freya - 4/10 - I personally don’t like heavy eye shadow or lipstick on most villagers. I can see how she is pretty though and I think if I bonded with her I could grow to like her.

Chevre - 4/10. I definitely can see how she is cute and very sweet. I think I could grow to like her more. Hearing about her relationship with nan definitely peeked my interest in them both. l

Audie 8/10 - I’m indifferent to most wolves but I really think Audie is pretty. Not a dreamie though I’d like to invite her temporarily and get to know here eventually.

 

[Xara]

My villagers are:

Punchy, Rudy, Raymond, Rosie, Merry, Reneigh (temporary), Judy (maybe temporary but keeping until she gets amiibo card maybe), Sherb (dreamie but I may replace with Dom who I regret letting go. Ideally I want to keep both but I still have other villagers I want as well...), Spike, Kiki.

punchy: 7/10! he’s not my absolute favourite but he’s still adorable and is a great villager overall! plus, the fact that he’s special to you and another friend of mine makes me love him even more.

rudy: 10/10!! my love for him has grown quite a bit thanks to you and he’s slowly becoming one of my all time favourites!

raymond: 2/10. i might be a bit biased since the smug villagers aren’t my favourite in general but i’m not really a fan of him.

rosie: 4/10. i don’t mind her at all and definitely think that she’s cute but she’s just never interested me all that much, sadly. she’s still a cutie, though!

merry: 10/10!! she’s the sweetest and i love her so, so much. and thank you again for her photo!

reneigh: 0/10. idk what my problem is but she just. irritates me a bit?? i have no idea why, though LOL. i do think her design’s pretty cool so i’m hoping i’ll warm up to her eventually lol.

judy: a bit undecided but i think i’ll go with 6/10. most of the new villagers tend to fall flat for me apparently but judy’s definitely adorable!

sherb: 8/10! a few months ago, this rating probably would’ve been lower but after having him on my own island for a while, i’ve grown to really like him! he’s an adorable lil dude and his house is quite nice as well!

spike: 5/10. his design’s pretty cool and he gets bonus points since seeing him always makes me think of @Hobowire.

kiki: 7/10! she’s super adorable and makes me nostalgic since i had her in wild world for a bit. plus, she reminds me of my kitty. <3

my villagers are audie, beau, margie, fuchsia, sprinkle, whitney, chèvre, chai, toby and freya.

 

[BalloonFight]

punchy: 7/10! he’s not my absolute favourite but he’s still adorable and is a great villager overall! plus, the fact that he’s special to you and another friend of mine makes me love him even more.

rudy: 10/10!! my love for him has grown quite a bit thanks to you and he’s slowly becoming one of my all time favourites!

raymond: 2/10. i might be a bit biased since the smug villagers aren’t my favourite in general but i’m not really a fan of him.

rosie: 4/10. i don’t mind her at all and definitely think that she’s cute but she’s just never interested me all that much, sadly. she’s still a cutie, though!

merry: 10/10!! she’s the sweetest and i love her so, so much. and thank you again for her photo!

reneigh: 0/10. idk what my problem is but she just. irritates me a bit?? i have no idea why, though LOL. i do think her design’s pretty cool so i’m hoping i’ll warm up to her eventually lol.

judy: a bit undecided but i think i’ll go with 6/10. most of the new villagers tend to fall flat for me apparently but judy’s definitely adorable!

sherb: 8/10! a few months ago, this rating probably would’ve been lower but after having him on my own island for a while, i’ve grown to really like him! he’s an adorable lil dude and his house is quite nice as well!

spike: 5/10. his design’s pretty cool and he gets bonus points since seeing him always makes me think of @Hobowire.

kiki: 7/10! she’s super adorable and makes me nostalgic since i had her in wild world for a bit. plus, she reminds me of my kitty. <3

my villagers are audie, beau, margie, fuchsia, sprinkle, whitney, chèvre, chai, toby and freya.

Audie: 7/10 She's not my favorite Wolf, but she's definitely quite awesome.

Beau: 9/10 One of my favorite villagers for quite a long time. I generally don't actually have him on my island playthroughs as I always have my lazy spots filled, but he's great nonetheless.

Margie: 3/10 Margie's fairly cute, but she has never really been one of my favorites. Don't really dislike her, but I dunno, just not for me.

Fuschia: 7/10 Cool villager and definitely one of the best sisterly options. I've only had her briefly before, but I enjoyed her.

Sprinkle: 10/10 Honestly, I just love Sprinkle. She was one of the first penguin villagers I went for their villager photo when I finally found her on an island. She's not a permanent villager for me, but she's definitely up there in my favorites list.

Whitney: 10/10 One of my favorite villagers of all time. I chronically rotate most of my roster, but she was on my ACNH island for about 5 or 6 months.

Chèvre: 2/10 I'm not sure why, but the villagers that have the 5 dotted nose designs just bother me lol. Chevre definitely is a sweetheart though, just not one of my favorites design wise.

Chai: 9/10 Possibly my favorite of the Sanrio additions. I wish I had a token or card of her, as I'd like to have her on my own island. Awesome design all around.

Toby: 7/10 Cool design. I haven't ever seen him on anyone's island yet so it's fairly hard to fully judge. Seems like a cool villager though.

Freya: 8/10 Freya's design is just beautiful. I prefer her to Audie, personally.

My current villager list = Bones, Cherry, Dobie, Dom, Genji, Lucky, Sherb, Sprocket, Tammi, and an empty plot for villager hunting.

 

[Chris]

Please stick to The Official "Rank My Villagers" Thread rather than making similar threads, thank you!