What rating did Isabelle give your island?

[chocovelvetcake]

In New Horizons, you're able to sit down with Isabelle and talk about your island evaluations, which is a really cool feature in the game. If you were able to unlock this feature, how many stars did Isabelle date your island and are you happy with it?

 

[Rainy.Nights]

Original post: My island seems stuck on 4 stars no matter what I do. It's very decorated but maybe I have too many flowers or something. I've only been playing less than a year though so maybe it takes awhile to get just right. If 5 stars never happens I'll probably just follow a guide eventually, but I'm fine with it for now.

Edit: I eventually got 5 stars and didn't even have to research how to do so. It just required a bit more effort!

 

[Clock]

4, I put way too much junk on the floor and I feel lazy cleaning it up. It would be 5 if there was no items on the floor. I did used to have 5 stars though.

 

[xxcodexx]

5 stars. no idea why either. my island is basically barren except for a few trees and the flowers that im breeding. i do have three beach lounge areas though, maybe thats whats doing it.

 

[Doo]

I’m pretty sure mine’s at 4 stars right now. I often have a lot of stuff on the ground lol. I have had it be 5 stars before and I have enough Jacob’s ladders and the gold watering can so I’m not bothered about my rating anymore.

 

[. Rarity .]

5 stars. Isabelle likes them fandoms, and well flowers. She's a flower nerd, and will not rest until your whole island is floral.

 

[azurill]

I restarted my second island in October and checked the other day and it was at 5 stars. It’s been awhile since I checked the rating of my main island but last time I checked it was also at 5 stars.

 

[Fruitcup]

My main island is 4 stars because I have too many tree and I am not getting rid of them!
My second island is 5 stars and it looks kinda sparse..

 

[mermaidshelf]

mine is at 5 and it's nowhere near finished. i just put some flowers and items haphazardly around the island and got a 5 star rating. thats why it doesnt mean much to me (happy home evals either), its more important that the island/homes be aesthetically pleasing to me. i do need a lot of lilies of the valley so im trying to keep it at 5 stars while i work on my island but eventually i plan to use a lot of "clutter" items like star fragments, wedding crystals, mushrooms, etc. which i know will bring down my rating.