Who has to go?

[kemdi]

Aurora's moving in and I don't want three normal villagers.

Etoile is my fav villager, but on the other hand she's been here for too long and I feel like her presence is kinda getting stale.
Kiki is great too, but unlike Etoile I can try to find her a new home.

I have both their photos already, so I won't be missing out.

 

[Aerith]

I think Kiki is cuter, personally. And assuming you still have the Sanrio card, you can always invite Etoile back and find Kiki a new home then. I would see if things feel fresher with Kiki and Aurora.

However, if you no longer have Etoile's card, I'd probably keep her since you say she's your favorite.

 

[Clock]

Keep Kiki and move out Etoile.

If you have Etoile’s card, then you can move her out since you can move her back in anytime with the amiibo card.