Whitney, I used to like her but now I just view her as a villager who looks like she's in her thirties. Maybe it's new leaf that made her look a little different, but I used to love her in ACWW.
Proabably Zucker or Julian, that is, when they were in Tier 1 which has changed. If I had to have an all food animal town, I'd definitely grab Zucker since he has more detail to him, but in general I dislike him. Compared to the actual food he's based off of, I find him to be gross, and while reading the first few posts on this thread I thought it was funny that my favorite top tier villagers were everyone else's least favorites due to being too popular I guess.
Merengue. I just dont like rhinos, purely my preference. I also dont like "fake" animals? Like stitches or dessert or food. Like that octapus that was super popular for a while, wasnt he food? Even has a toothpick on his head! No...
Bob, he's turned up in both of my towns this week, and I just can't get on with him! And this is coming from a crazy cat lady!!! Plus I don't like his house
I was going to say Stitches, but apparently he's not tier 1... I guess I'll go with Skye. Her eyes really bother me and I just think there are a lot of cuter villagers with her personality type, but hey to each their own.