Mafia Xenoblade Chronicles Mafia-Endgame
- Thread starter Damniel
- Start date
I am not thinking of the two as the same thing as much as the last game, its more I am looking at roles and wondering what could be in play, I am not sure how often certain roles are played and I know jester is a role trying to get its self lynched so that is where my mind goes to when I see someone act scum like on what seems like purpose
- - - Post Merge - - -
wolfy?
Also, thank you for the information
Calling me scummy </3 I'm hurt cory.
In seriousness, it was more a legit question about jester, not protecting some rando scummy man
I'm reading back from last night and haven't read recent posts so soz if this is not on the discussion whatsoever but I meant to reply to this before I went to sleep lastnight.
I completely understand this. I get it. We were all nubs at one point or another. In BoI I was so lost. I couldn't even give a good case until my 3rd game, so I'm not expecting anyone who is on their 1st or 2nd game to come up with this huge scum case... but, what you can do is read all the cases that have been given so far and give your thoughts. What do you agree with, what do you disagree with?
It's been a bit the same with me in Aron's case, but not completely. Just been a bit busy to read through some posts or post myself, or know what to post.
- - - Post Merge - - -
in other words: soz for not posting, stil a noob to mafia
I completely understand this. I get it. We were all nubs at one point or another. In BoI I was so lost. I couldn't even give a good case until my 3rd game, so I'm not expecting anyone who is on their 1st or 2nd game to come up with this huge scum case... but, what you can do is read all the cases that have been given so far and give your thoughts. What do you agree with, what do you disagree with?
holy **** i didn?t even realize till i sat down and wrote this how inactive you are all being. like i don?t even care at this point, we SHOULD lynch an inactive because thats what 60% of the playerlist is and I?m a utilitarian dictator that would rather lynch someone being un-useful than someone that posts so therefor we can read them. but since tom is trying to lead a bandwagon on me, then crys flipped from me to ares so fast, yeah i?m pretty sure crys is scum and maybe even tom too if he?s really that blatant.
k lets get this started. these reads will be an analysis on everyone in the game so far, which i normally never do because of how overwhelming it is (hence why it took me awhile) but in this case most people are pretty inactive so it?s not too bad. (these aren't in order btw)
Scumreads:
Dolby is following his usual scum meta of being inactive and making small posts to avoid being modkilled. i saw him lurking the thread for about an hour this morning. here are all his posts
this is in reply to Ashtot. is it me or this exchange is just extremely weird? like ashtot made it seem it was kind of a joke
when he is town he usually makes at least one contributing post before the day cycle ends. and of course he hasn?t yet. the only reason i?m not set lynching him is because in discord the other day he was talking about having a lot of AP tests so i?m giving him the benefit of the doubt for now but
a silent dolby is a dangerous dolby
Tom - i?m trying to figure out if scum would be so bold as to lead a ****lynch on me. he criticizes me for ?****posting? when literally everybody else has too. Dolby, Cory, Ashtot, Tae, seriously half the game is either ****posting or being inactive. even you, Tom.
10/10 posts tom, no ****posts here amirite???
first of all, i have scum meta. and i do NOT avoid the thread in the slightest. actually, avoiding the thread usually is my blue meta lmfao so get out
>sides with xine on cory
>votes me due to their gut feelings based on weak reasoning about my meta which doesn?t even apply to me
are you saying that i don?t contribute ?right off the bat?? are you ****ing kidding me? i lead on scum d1 last game. xine had a stronger case but i still lead on scum lmfao. and what was the difference between now and then? o rite people were actually posting seriously from the beginning of gamestart.
so tom, tell me, are you just rly contradicting town or just painfully obvious scum? i thought your leading a lynch on me was a joke, and i'm pretty sure that everyone else literally took it as one. but i can't believe you're still persistent on this. if you are trying to use meta on me, then state that and state examples. or something. but you saying that i've been avoidant of the thread but that i've also been ****posting is completely contradictory. cognitive dissonance level contradictory. i cannot be avoidant and ****posting at the same time, and while i don't deny that i'm not playing at the most serious level, that's not a competent enough reason to scumread me considering that:
1. i said i would deliver actual reads, and fell asleep while writing them
2. i was busy most of yesterday
3. inactiveness is not in my scum meta
so unless you have more to expand on why you think i'd be a good lynch then yeah i scumread you entirely.
Crys - normally a much more eccentric (if that?s the right word?) play style so they?re definitely changing up their playstyle but imo it?s in a good way. initially i actually townread them up until the point of when they started voting and interacting with tom. but the problem with crys is this fence sitting, which i haven?t seen them do in almost every single game. normally they gave a pretty good gut read on someone, and stay persistent with it. but the flipflop vote on me after voting ares was really not like crys.
>hey guys lets lynch ares
>votes ares
>tom: no lets ****lynch entropy
>yeah why not!!!
>votes entropy
you need to elaborate how i seem off. because it just looks like you?re trying to bandwagon whatever anyone says and you aren't forming your own opinions. am i being off by not posting reads? if anything this correlates with my town meta when i?m busy, aka this weekend. i normally barely post d1 anyway besides reaction testing, and then i wait until i have enough reads to make an actual post. am i being off by avoiding the thread? because in reality i'm not actually avoiding the thread at all. your vote on me was so quick and there's only a few hours left in the day, it's weird that you agree with tom when he never even made a valid case on me but you didn't agree with xine when she actually had a decent case on cory.
you never explained your own reasoning for anything, and that's what makes me scumread you the most out of everyone in the game.
Ashtot
yeah this exchange is just so weird. i?m pretty sure that ashtot started this off as a joke and then later realized he was being too trolly so then he said he was being serious about it later.
in regards to lynching me. pretty sure this is just setting up for the future when he could hammer me without being suspicious about it
but he said it jokingly so that it wouldn?t seem serious enough to use against him
and then we have this awful pocket.
he posts this like it?s of anything contributing. i mean yeah it?s a townread, cool you?ve posted more than half the playerlist congrats. but giving town reads without any actual scum reads is just trying to make it seem like you?re contributing when you?re really not.
lol you know who else speaks like what they?re saying is fact? scum. confident town can do this too, and i know trundle is confident town but that?s because of meta. ashton i would?ve
it?s not even that i disagree about trundle, it?s that this came out of absolutely nowhere. there are others that have towntold more than trundle, like even trundle should be aware that he?s being pocketed at this point. when i called him out for it:
it takes .2 seconds to google search. how have i heard of this term but you haven?t? you?ve played 33 games. and i?ve played like less than 10 including micro games lol but whatever. when i told him what it means i really hated his reply:
it?s actually not a stupid strategy if you think about it for a second. if you do it well, and people don?t realize that they?re being buddied, you can end up looking scummy with them if they flip and they can also begin to influence your decisions in the game. I.E. when daniel was pocketing cory last game, i thought they were both scum so i roleblocked cory.
bussing has NOTHING to do with it and it irks me that you even brought it up because it seems like deflection. bussing is a total different subject, and that?s not what i was talking about here.
>hasn?t been trolling at all
>half his posts are said jokingly
if you were actually serious about dolby to begin with, you would have said a bit more than just ?ya dolby get wrekt?. if you were serious about dolby even when you posted that, you would have voted him. if you want to use dolby?s meta against him, and i totally see your point here, then say that and give examples.
why are you defending tom when he?s done nothing but either piggyback off of xine?s opinions and then criticize the rest of everyone for not contributing enough when he?s been ****posting himself? there?s no logic here.
Scumleans:
inkling - following her scum meta of posting little to nothing substantial, but still posting. i find it really weird that xine didn?t mention this consider that she tunneled on her for it last game.
she answered the RQS and have post two other posts besides that:
and the second part is in reply to ashton calling her ?confirmed scum?.
this is in reply to tardis saying we should lynch inkling d1 for the sake of memes. and then nothing. i can?t tell if she is just busy or if she just doesn?t want to keep posting because last game she was pretty easily caught in a couple slips and in general made contradicting reads as scum. my problem is that i think she would be trying harder as scum, so she's only in scumleans for now.
mother of all lamas is my #1 policy lynch k thank u
Null:
Nightmares null - post your opinions. it bothers me that you?re active all over the rest of the site but not in the game that you signed up for. nobody forced you to play.
Xerolin - null - post your opinions. i don?t really like her defense of nightmares but idk this is basically her first game. she seems like she?s trying and just doesn?t know what to post though, so that puts her back into null.
Panda is being quiet because she doesn?t have internet access (she said this in discord from her phone) so it?s not really alignment indicative at all
Leaning town
Xine- self explanatory considering she?s basically the only one trying lmao. but she?s kind of cherry picking, which i am gonna interpret is supposed to be purposeful for a reaction test but i?m not really solid on this read.
Alexi - i feel like her posts when she?s scum are pretty forced/contradictory but so far she?s been consistent although she?s less active than normal
Trundle - scumdle is ez to spot and tbh i think
Ness - emotional at first, but i can understand that given his circumstances. i think he reacted fairly well to xine?s post on him and he is getting replaced anyway so i think we should
taesaek -
Tardis - this is just a gut feeling because when i?ve seen him as scum he mostly coasts and doesn?t say anything too controversial but when he?s town he gives lynch suggestions, idk why everyone got on him for pushing llamas when llamas is useless and it?s really not a bad idea to policy lynch
people i don't have time for rn because i gtg:
Aronthaer
Cory
Jacob
Ares
Hayden
i will come back to them, hopefully before day ends. but i will color coordinate them for now
in conclusion, i wanna lynch between crys, tom, or ashtot. that?s in order of who i want lynched the most to the least. worst case scenario we should policy lynch llamas.
k lets get this started. these reads will be an analysis on everyone in the game so far, which i normally never do because of how overwhelming it is (hence why it took me awhile) but in this case most people are pretty inactive so it?s not too bad. (these aren't in order btw)
Scumreads:
Dolby is following his usual scum meta of being inactive and making small posts to avoid being modkilled. i saw him lurking the thread for about an hour this morning. here are all his posts
this is in reply to Ashtot. is it me or this exchange is just extremely weird? like ashtot made it seem it was kind of a joke
when he is town he usually makes at least one contributing post before the day cycle ends. and of course he hasn?t yet. the only reason i?m not set lynching him is because in discord the other day he was talking about having a lot of AP tests so i?m giving him the benefit of the doubt for now but
a silent dolby is a dangerous dolby
Tom - i?m trying to figure out if scum would be so bold as to lead a ****lynch on me. he criticizes me for ?****posting? when literally everybody else has too. Dolby, Cory, Ashtot, Tae, seriously half the game is either ****posting or being inactive. even you, Tom.
tfw there's so much tea being spilled here and it's only day one
10/10 posts tom, no ****posts here amirite???
first of all, i have scum meta. and i do NOT avoid the thread in the slightest. actually, avoiding the thread usually is my blue meta lmfao so get out
>sides with xine on cory
>votes me due to their gut feelings based on weak reasoning about my meta which doesn?t even apply to me
are you saying that i don?t contribute ?right off the bat?? are you ****ing kidding me? i lead on scum d1 last game. xine had a stronger case but i still lead on scum lmfao. and what was the difference between now and then? o rite people were actually posting seriously from the beginning of gamestart.
so tom, tell me, are you just rly contradicting town or just painfully obvious scum? i thought your leading a lynch on me was a joke, and i'm pretty sure that everyone else literally took it as one. but i can't believe you're still persistent on this. if you are trying to use meta on me, then state that and state examples. or something. but you saying that i've been avoidant of the thread but that i've also been ****posting is completely contradictory. cognitive dissonance level contradictory. i cannot be avoidant and ****posting at the same time, and while i don't deny that i'm not playing at the most serious level, that's not a competent enough reason to scumread me considering that:
1. i said i would deliver actual reads, and fell asleep while writing them
2. i was busy most of yesterday
3. inactiveness is not in my scum meta
so unless you have more to expand on why you think i'd be a good lynch then yeah i scumread you entirely.
Crys - normally a much more eccentric (if that?s the right word?) play style so they?re definitely changing up their playstyle but imo it?s in a good way. initially i actually townread them up until the point of when they started voting and interacting with tom. but the problem with crys is this fence sitting, which i haven?t seen them do in almost every single game. normally they gave a pretty good gut read on someone, and stay persistent with it. but the flipflop vote on me after voting ares was really not like crys.
>hey guys lets lynch ares
>votes ares
>tom: no lets ****lynch entropy
>yeah why not!!!
>votes entropy
you need to elaborate how i seem off. because it just looks like you?re trying to bandwagon whatever anyone says and you aren't forming your own opinions. am i being off by not posting reads? if anything this correlates with my town meta when i?m busy, aka this weekend. i normally barely post d1 anyway besides reaction testing, and then i wait until i have enough reads to make an actual post. am i being off by avoiding the thread? because in reality i'm not actually avoiding the thread at all. your vote on me was so quick and there's only a few hours left in the day, it's weird that you agree with tom when he never even made a valid case on me but you didn't agree with xine when she actually had a decent case on cory.
you never explained your own reasoning for anything, and that's what makes me scumread you the most out of everyone in the game.
Ashtot
yeah this exchange is just so weird. i?m pretty sure that ashtot started this off as a joke and then later realized he was being too trolly so then he said he was being serious about it later.
Well you know how I feel about gut feelings.
in regards to lynching me. pretty sure this is just setting up for the future when he could hammer me without being suspicious about it
but he said it jokingly so that it wouldn?t seem serious enough to use against him
and then we have this awful pocket.
he posts this like it?s of anything contributing. i mean yeah it?s a townread, cool you?ve posted more than half the playerlist congrats. but giving town reads without any actual scum reads is just trying to make it seem like you?re contributing when you?re really not.
lol you know who else speaks like what they?re saying is fact? scum. confident town can do this too, and i know trundle is confident town but that?s because of meta. ashton i would?ve
it?s not even that i disagree about trundle, it?s that this came out of absolutely nowhere. there are others that have towntold more than trundle, like even trundle should be aware that he?s being pocketed at this point. when i called him out for it:
it takes .2 seconds to google search. how have i heard of this term but you haven?t? you?ve played 33 games. and i?ve played like less than 10 including micro games lol but whatever. when i told him what it means i really hated his reply:
it?s actually not a stupid strategy if you think about it for a second. if you do it well, and people don?t realize that they?re being buddied, you can end up looking scummy with them if they flip and they can also begin to influence your decisions in the game. I.E. when daniel was pocketing cory last game, i thought they were both scum so i roleblocked cory.
bussing has NOTHING to do with it and it irks me that you even brought it up because it seems like deflection. bussing is a total different subject, and that?s not what i was talking about here.
>hasn?t been trolling at all
>half his posts are said jokingly
if you were actually serious about dolby to begin with, you would have said a bit more than just ?ya dolby get wrekt?. if you were serious about dolby even when you posted that, you would have voted him. if you want to use dolby?s meta against him, and i totally see your point here, then say that and give examples.
why are you defending tom when he?s done nothing but either piggyback off of xine?s opinions and then criticize the rest of everyone for not contributing enough when he?s been ****posting himself? there?s no logic here.
Scumleans:
inkling - following her scum meta of posting little to nothing substantial, but still posting. i find it really weird that xine didn?t mention this consider that she tunneled on her for it last game.
she answered the RQS and have post two other posts besides that:
oh actually 3 1/2
your welcome
and the second part is in reply to ashton calling her ?confirmed scum?.
check ur grammar, i have no clue what youre trying to say!
this is in reply to tardis saying we should lynch inkling d1 for the sake of memes. and then nothing. i can?t tell if she is just busy or if she just doesn?t want to keep posting because last game she was pretty easily caught in a couple slips and in general made contradicting reads as scum. my problem is that i think she would be trying harder as scum, so she's only in scumleans for now.
mother of all lamas is my #1 policy lynch k thank u
Null:
Nightmares null - post your opinions. it bothers me that you?re active all over the rest of the site but not in the game that you signed up for. nobody forced you to play.
Xerolin - null - post your opinions. i don?t really like her defense of nightmares but idk this is basically her first game. she seems like she?s trying and just doesn?t know what to post though, so that puts her back into null.
Panda is being quiet because she doesn?t have internet access (she said this in discord from her phone) so it?s not really alignment indicative at all
Leaning town
Xine- self explanatory considering she?s basically the only one trying lmao. but she?s kind of cherry picking, which i am gonna interpret is supposed to be purposeful for a reaction test but i?m not really solid on this read.
Alexi - i feel like her posts when she?s scum are pretty forced/contradictory but so far she?s been consistent although she?s less active than normal
Trundle - scumdle is ez to spot and tbh i think
Ness - emotional at first, but i can understand that given his circumstances. i think he reacted fairly well to xine?s post on him and he is getting replaced anyway so i think we should
taesaek -
Tardis - this is just a gut feeling because when i?ve seen him as scum he mostly coasts and doesn?t say anything too controversial but when he?s town he gives lynch suggestions, idk why everyone got on him for pushing llamas when llamas is useless and it?s really not a bad idea to policy lynch
people i don't have time for rn because i gtg:
Aronthaer
Cory
Jacob
Ares
Hayden
i will come back to them, hopefully before day ends. but i will color coordinate them for now
in conclusion, i wanna lynch between crys, tom, or ashtot. that?s in order of who i want lynched the most to the least. worst case scenario we should policy lynch llamas.
It's been 14 hours and you haven't posted any cases
I don't want to policy lynch. I want to get the gears turning and town to work together to get scum lynched
I don't like the bold. You are making it seem like no one cares about the game and in actuality people do.
Have you seen ashtot play? He always trolls day 1. And trundle has not been very scummy.
Do you just want to lynch tom because he was pushing you?
- - - Post Merge - - -
OH COME THE **** ON
- - - Post Merge - - -
ignore the first line
i was calling myself scummy. not you
the wolfy pop in was referring to me, its a joke.
Oh, got it, got it, you quoted me making me think it was about what I said, my bad Cory. Sorry
The thing is, Ares isn't really that inactive. They answered the questions which were already scummy with the Crys and RQS thing. then they also said they react well under pressure. So, I'm assuming that's why Crys decided to vote for Ares to see what he/she would do. Then Ares comes in and votes Crys right back? lmao... without a reason? Thats scum.
don't be sorry. I liked your reaction to me thinking I called you scum. I think you are town.
1. i've put in more effort than you and also explained why i wasn't putting in effort
2. i've done more than you kthx
- - - Post Merge - - -
k and why? when i wasn't even on your reads list besides the point where you said you "weren't sure about me"
am i the only one bother by whats in italics
Well thank you for the town read, I was worried you were scum with some posts but you seem to be helping, I wouldn't count you so deep as scum any more
Maybe a little but that is just because I dont know your playing style, you are like a wild cardSimilar threads
- Locked
