You don't say game!

[Snazzapple]

Here's how it works

Person 1: Not a cake, but a ___

Person 2: Cookie

Not a shoe, but a ___

Person 3: Boot
Not a fruit, but a ___


And so on...

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'll start not a shirt, but a ___

 

[Extra]

Jacket

Not a cake but a ___

 

[Invi]

Muffin.
Not a bagel, but a ___

 

[Extra]

Donut

Not a plate, but a ___

 

[ACupOfTea]

napkin.

Not a sausage, but a _

 

[DarkFox7]

Hotdog.

Not a foot, but a ___.

 

[Snazzapple]

Toe

Not a fruit, but a ___

 

[Leela]

vegetable

Not a tree, but a ____.

 

[Captain Crazy Chicken]

Whispy Woods.

Not Pokemon, but...

 

[Snazzapple]

Digimon

Not a cat but a ___

 

[Jarrad]

lonely depressed middle-aged single woman

not a pickle but a ____

 

[Captain Crazy Chicken]

Grey old face made out of barf.

Not a dumb book, but...

 

[Mercedes]

Bonnie toy

Not a crazy chicken

 

[Snazzapple]

a crazy goat

Not a pie but a...

 

[Vizionari]

Cake

Not a star, but a__

 

[Snazzapple]

Asteroid

Not a drawing but a ___

 

[X2k5a7y]

Painting.

Not a movie but a ___.

 

[Captain Crazy Chicken]

Giant Baby Princess!!

Not orange, but...

 

[Aestivate]

mandarin

Not a bath but a ___

 

[Snazzapple]

Shower

Not a bear but ___