ACNH Villager Rankdown (#1 and #2 HAVE BEEN POSTED!)

[Verecund]

RIP Sheldon, I was initially going to save him but I knew it was futile as he didn't really stand much of a chance.

Which reminds me, time for a new (old) avatar. :P

 

[Bk1234]

RIP Sheldon, I was initially going to save him but I knew it was futile as he didn't really stand much of a chance.

Which reminds me, time for a new (old) avatar.

Aah, nice avatar! I’m a little disappointed by Ankha’s placement, not gonna lie.

 

[WaileaNoRei]

RIP Sheldon, I was initially going to save him but I knew it was futile as he didn't really stand much of a chance.

Which reminds me, time for a new (old) avatar.

aww, sorry! If it makes you feel any better, trying to do the write up made me feel pretty mean (and I possibly like him a bit more /dislike him less now. idk how that works?...)

love the protest avatar! Haha. Fight the power (even if the ‘power’ is me in this case)

can’t wait to see who else comes out of this round!

 

[Bk1234]

can’t wait to see who else comes out of this round!

Same. I believe we are just waiting on @saucySheep, @Asarena, and @Florence + The Machine.

 

[Florence + The Machine]

Save: Walker
Cut: Billy

As someone who cares probably a bit too much about villager houses, Billy easily has one of the worst out of all the villagers and he’s not cute enough to make up for it. His house is filled with cardboard furniture and he has the trash flooring to boot. It’s kinda funny that’s he’s a senile goat who only cares about his muscles, but I’m still not a fan. Also his eyes always being closed is kind of a weird choice, and I’m not sure if it suits him (I’m leaning towards no). I like a lot of the jock villager designs (rip Sheldon), but there’s nothing particularly interesting about Billy.

 

[Asarena]

I'm going to save Blaire and cut Flip! Will post my write up soon~

Post automatically merged: Sep 27, 2020

The villager I have decided to cut is Flip. First of all, I'm not a big fan of the monkey villagers to begin with. The only one I really like is Deli. On top of that, Flip happens to be my least favorite personality type, a jock. His appearance isn't what I would call the most appealing either. The orange fur, the yellow skin, the lime green ears, the buck teeth, and that pointy spike of hair on his head... He just looks kind of goofy to me overall, which is fine if you like villagers with that particular type of goofiness I guess, but it's just not for me!

 

[Bk1234]

The fates of Frita and Margie are in the hands of @saucySheep.

 

[WaileaNoRei]

The fates of Frita and Margie are in the hands of @saucySheep.

i can’t wait! I always enjoy reading @saucySheep ‘s take on things ! This was a tough round! Lots of good villagers.

 

[saucySheep]

oh! i have to cut again...?
im cool wit dat lol


Save: Frita
Cut: Margie

I have never personally been a fan of the elephant villagers in particular... Margie is no exception. She makes me think of knock-off Tia. I guess her Indian sort of style is nice but I think that the developers made a mistake adding pink to her color scheme. She's sort of boring overall, especially since she's a normal - she could be far more interesting as a peppy, if you ask me. Ehh. I suppose she's an OK villager though I wouldn't want her on my island and she's definitely not as good as Frita... therefore, she must be cut. I apologize to Margie fans. >.>

tHat was hardly more than 100 words but it still counts ig lol

Spoiler: margie sdfsesesd

 

[Bk1234]

oh! i have to cut again...?
im cool wit dat lol


Save: Frita
Cut: Margie

I have never personally been a fan of the elephant villagers in particular... Margie is no exception. She makes me think of knock-off Tia. I guess her Indian sort of style is nice but I think that the developers made a mistake adding pink to her color scheme. She's sort of boring overall, especially since she's a normal - she could be far more interesting as a peppy, if you ask me. Ehh. I suppose she's an OK villager though I wouldn't want her on my island and she's definitely not as good as Frita... therefore, she must be cut. I apologize to Margie fans. >.>

tHat was hardly more than 100 words but it still counts ig lol

Perfect, except you forgot to add a picture!

 

[saucySheep]

omfg

 

[Bk1234]

With the conclusion of @Emmsey ’s nominations, it is now @Florence + The Machine ’s turn to nominate. Remember, you can nominate any villager in the Top 140, as long as they aren’t fast pass recipients or villagers that were saved in the last set of nominations.

 

[saucySheep]

ok... fixed it

 

[Pintuition]

oh! i have to cut again...?
im cool wit dat lol


Save: Frita
Cut: Margie

I have never personally been a fan of the elephant villagers in particular... Margie is no exception. She makes me think of knock-off Tia. I guess her Indian sort of style is nice but I think that the developers made a mistake adding pink to her color scheme. She's sort of boring overall, especially since she's a normal - she could be far more interesting as a peppy, if you ask me. Ehh. I suppose she's an OK villager though I wouldn't want her on my island and she's definitely not as good as Frita... therefore, she must be cut. I apologize to Margie fans. >.>

tHat was hardly more than 100 words but it still counts ig lol

Spoiler: margie sdfsesesd

View attachment 322833

Thank goodness! I was so hoping Frita would make the cut!!

 

[Florence + The Machine]

I'm calling this one: Battle of the (mostly) Normals

Nominations:
1. Caroline
2. Pecan
3. Prince
4. Gala
5. Fauna
6. Whitney
7. Maple
8. Poppy
9. Lolly
10. Coco
11. Marina
12. Tia

 

[Pintuition]

Save Maple, cut Pecan!

Cutting Pecan reasoning: Listen up, ya'll, cause I've got a controversial opinion I'm dropping on you: Pecan is budget Poppy. Full stop! They're like the same color and everything. Nothing against Pecan, she's a fine character but her whole vibe is off. She has relaxed default clothing making her more similar to normal or lazy yet she's actually a snooty. What? And plus the color they chose for her makeup just feels kind of trashy, like halloween makeup. Overall I'm just not a fan. I gotta give it to Pecan, though, she does have a pretty nice house! If it wasn't for the odd makeup and mismatched personality style she wouldn't have gotten the axe!

 

[Verecund]

Save Caroline, cut Fauna. Write-up to follow.

 

[WaileaNoRei]

Save Coco cut Marina. Write up to follow.

 

[Asarena]

Save Whitney cut Lolly

Write up soon!

Post automatically merged: Sep 27, 2020

The villager I'm cutting this round is Lolly. Is she the worst cat villager? I wouldn't say so; there are certainly ones I like less than her, but at the same time she's definitely not my favorite either. The main thing that bothers me about Lolly is her eyes. In general, I don't like most villagers that just have solid colored or weirdly shaped eyes, and her eyes are both. If you can get past her disturbing eyes, then her mouth is kind of cute, but it isn't enough to make up for the eyes. On top of that, there are so many colorful and unique cat villagers that Lolly just seems plain in comparison.

 

[Verecund]

Out of every villager here, Fauna was probably the highest priority on my target list. It's not that I dislike her, it just that I can't find anything interesting about her. I'm frustratingly indifferent towards her (and at least for villagers I don't like, they at least have a quality that make me feel something), and her colour scheme is just dull all around. Is she cute? Kind of, I guess. I wouldn't call her ugly. But that's the thing. In pretty much every way, she's as neutral as her colour scheme. In the case of popular villagers, I can usually find some appeal in them and I try not to be too liberal with who I call 'overrated', but to me, Fauna is definitely the most overrated villager in ACNH. Her house is cool, though, and I can appreciate the more natural vibes she gives off, but... she just seems so forgettable. Among all the cool-looking deer in the game, Fauna just doesn't stand out at all.