ACNH Villager Rankdown (#1 and #2 HAVE BEEN POSTED!)

[Bk1234]

Chop and save - or am I taking that a little too literally!

My guess is the first picture is a hint about cutting villagers since it's a picture of cutting wood, while the second picture is a hint for saving villagers since "save and end" is selected.

These two are correct!!! The next round will involve cutting and saving villagers.

 

[Ananas Dragon]

Does it involve the actual cutting of villagers

 

[Bk1234]

Does it involve the actual cutting of villagers

No, of course not!!!

 

[Bk1234]

Round 3 will be posted tomorrow morning!

 

[WaileaNoRei]

I can’t wait! Love having this to look forward to all week. I wonder how much disagreement there will be

 

[Bk1234]

I can’t wait! Love having this to look forward to all week. I wonder how much disagreement there will be

I’m glad you’ve been looking forward to each round! I’m also curious how everyone’s opinions will differ...

 

[Bk1234]

Round 3: Cuts and Saves
​

Cutting and saving are two key features in ACNH. We cut trees with our axe, and we save our progress when we’re done playing. In this round, we’ll come to know those terms in a completely different way.

Round Details: Each judge will nominate any 12 villagers that are in the Top 140. The other 6 judges will each save one and cut one on a first-come, first-serve basis. Each judge is responsible for posting a 100-word write-up, with a picture, about the villager they choose to cut within one hour of posting their cut and save. If they fail to do so, their cut and save will be declared null and void and another judge can swoop in and choose those villagers. Once all 6 judges have cut, save and posted their write-ups, the next judge on the list will post their 12 nominees. You cannot nominate anyone that was given a fast-pass or anyone saved in the previous set of nominations.

Nomination Order:

@Asarena will nominate first!

@Asarena @Emmsey @Florence + The Machine @WaileaNoRei @Pintuition @Verecund @saucySheep​

 

[Bk1234]

Just a reminder that Round 3 has been posted!

@Asarena @Emmsey @Florence + The Machine @WaileaNoRei @Pintuition @Verecund @saucySheep​

 

[Emmsey]

Question, once a judge before you has saved someone presumably you then can’t cut them?

 

[Asarena]

My nominations:
Bianca
Apollo
Snake
Julian
Bella
Punchy
Julia
Lily
Cherry
Chevre
Eunice
Fang​

 

[WaileaNoRei]

I choose to save Punchy and cut Apollo (write up to follow)!

 

[Emmsey]

I choose to save Fang and cut Julian - write up to follow also!

Sorry Julian but never been one for the unicorn hype that seems to be spreading the country. Let’s face it he’s just a horse with a horn and well horses freak me out. Oh and the eyes why not open them once in a while and you might actually be able to see where your going and not take someone’s eye out with that horn of yours. I’m digging your pad more generally but no one likes a show off ( unless it’s Pietro) all those Celeste diy’s within you are trying way too hard. So farewell Julian I hope you and Peaches have fun together in the creepy eyes club!

 

[Bk1234]

Question, once a judge before you has saved someone presumably you then can’t cut them?

Yes. You can’t cut them unless the judge hasn’t produced a write-up within an hour after they announce their cut.

 

[Verecund]

Save Chevre, cut Cherry; write-up to follow.

 

[WaileaNoRei]

Okay on Apollo - not to ruffle any feathers (harharhar) but I just don’t like him or get the appeal. I find his design blah blah. I don’t enjoy his nod to American patriotism (though I realize that was created in Japan and it’s no other reason than they had a bald eagle and so naturally thought oh, we’ll make his birthday America-y).

Crankies are a hard sell for me in general and so are the eagle designs (though some of them are pretty cool). There’s a quite a few cranky eagles and I think Avery, Frank, and Buzz are all more interesting.

Don’t get me wrong, bald eagles are amazing animals in real life. But Apollo is just ... uninteresting to me. So goodbye to Apollo!

(sorry Apollo fans!)

(This picture is actually so nice it is making me like him a little more)

 

[Verecund]

Alright, so the punk rock concept of Cherry is pretty cool, but to me it could have been executed a lot better than this. Her mouth is the main thing that bothers me; I'm just not a fan of lopsided mouths in general (with a few exceptions), but it just looks especially weird on the dog model. I'm not a fan of the eyes, either; there are too many lashes for my liking. Her bright purple nose blends in and doesn't really work with her rocker vibe, either, which is a shame because the bright red and black look great. So in conclusion, her theme is cool but her appearance is lacking; I'm just not a fan of her, wouldn't really want to get her, and that's why I'm cutting her. Sorry, Cherry. :(

 

[saucySheep]

hi there. whats for round 3? im sorry but i never got any notifications for this :C am i late or can i stil be in it

 

[Bk1234]

hi there. whats for round 3? im sorry but i never got any notifications for this :C am i late or can i stil be in it

Round Details: Each judge will nominate any 12 villagers that are in the Top 140. The other 6 judges will each save one and cut one on a first-come, first-serve basis. Each judge is responsible for posting a 100-word write-up, with a picture, about the villager they choose to cut within one hour of posting their cut and save. If they fail to do so, their cut and save will be declared null and void and another judge can swoop in and choose those villagers. Once all 6 judges have cut, save and posted their write-ups, the next judge on the list will post their 12 nominees. You cannot nominate anyone that was given a fast-pass or anyone saved in the previous set of nominations.

I’d recommend looking at the other judges’ cuts and saves for examples.

 

[saucySheep]

My nominations:
Bianca
Apollo
Snake
Julian
Bella
Punchy
Julia
Lily
Cherry
Chevre
Eunice
Fang​

save enuice. and cut bella.

Bella genuinely freaks me out... she's a short little punk rat, of all things - buck teeth, nasty looking blush, and some weird eyes that stare straight into your soul. maybe i'm weird but i hate how her ears are larger than her body - i get that that's meant to be cute but with the rest of her design it's just foul. She honestly makes me think of a mass murderer. Not to mention that strange picture quote - "a head shot is worth a thousand words". That honestly just makes her seem a lot more liable to murder someone.... with a gun.... eugh. scary rat demon. And, uh, her house definitely looks rat-infested too.... not too great for an upcoming popstar.


(counted, that's 120 words)

Spoiler: Creepy bella picture

 

[Bk1234]

save enuice. and cut bella.

Bella genuinely freaks me out... she's a short little punk rat, of all things - buck teeth, nasty looking blush, and some weird eyes that stare straight into your soul. maybe i'm weird but i hate how her ears are larger than her body - i get that that's meant to be cute but with the rest of her design it's just foul. She honestly makes me think of a mass murderer. Not to mention that strange picture quote - "a head shot is worth a thousand words". That honestly just makes her seem a lot more liable to murder someone.... with a gun.... eugh. scary rat demon. And, uh, her house definitely looks rat-infested too.... not too great for an upcoming popstar.


(counted, that's 120 words)

Just add a picture and then you’ll be good.