Mafia American Politics Mafia - Game Over - Town Wins!

[Dolby]

Who do you want to be President? Preferably myself, but other than that I do not have a clear choice in mind. I would like to take this opportunity to say that I think it is a horrible idea to elect someone purely due to them being an experienced player. as Dolby has chosen to point out.

No, I don't want somebody President purely based off of their experience. When I said "Generally Experienced" I meant somebody who wasn't going to be a kill target by the mafia in any way at any point in the game. Of course, I do want a town President, but the purpose of the question was to see what people wanted in terms of stuff beyond towniness at this part of the game

- - - Post Merge - - -

*Wasn't not going to be

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Experience: I've played a few games now, I have not played one with elected roles
How I will use my role: Well, I don't really know how I would. DO NOT SEND IN VOTES FOR ME. I'LL SCREW UP SOMEHOW.
Who should be pres: I seriously have no idea. Maybe Dolby?
This last question: um what? Probably not.
BTW, I have not read up on the thread until Trundle answered Jacob's question.

 

[unravel]

What is your general experience with mafia, including in games with elected roles? I lost count but just came back aro7nd 2017 so im not a new player and just have decent play I dont consider myself as experienced player


As mayor, how do you intend to use your role? I dont deserve to be a mayor because im not experienced player I rather choose someone whos trustworthy and more experienced

Who do you want to be President? Who is more logical and good at scum hunting

In an anomymous election, is there ANY situation (as town) in which you would lie about who you voted for? we work together to get rid of scum and i dont see the rrason why we have to lie right?

- - - Post Merge - - -

What is your general experience with mafia, including in games with elected roles? I lost count but just came back aro7nd 2017 so im not a new player and just have decent play I dont consider myself as experienced player


As mayor, how do you intend to use your role? I dont deserve to be a mayor because im not experienced player I rather choose someone whos trustworthy and more experienced

Who do you want to be President? Who is more logical and good at scum hunting

In an anomymous election, is there ANY situation (as town) in which you would lie about who you voted for? we work together to get rid of scum and i dont see the rrason why we have to lie right?

 

[N e s s]

No, I don't want somebody President purely based off of their experience. When I said "Generally Experienced" I meant somebody who wasn't going to be a kill target by the mafia in any way at any point in the game. Of course, I do want a town President, but the purpose of the question was to see what people wanted in terms of stuff beyond towniness at this part of the game

Understandable, it wasn't a jab at you or anything, I was just saying that I don't want someone to be elected solely for the fact that they're an experienced player. I probably won't vote anyone until around the last 24 hours since I want to get a semi-clear read on someone first.

Also, I would also like to point out that I think it's probably best that we don't tunnel vision on determining who should be elected president right now. It's important to also look into alignments of players to better determine who really should be elected.

 

[Dolby]

I'm just gonna say that if Glow was legitimately hard-claiming there, she'd pretty much have to become Mayor by default. But I have known her to make dumb softs at the start of the game. If it's legit that she's a delayed innocent child, the only real concern would be that she's a third-party who wins once they're elected mayor or a jester (as no maf would claim that seriously, as would no lying town)

- - - Post Merge - - -

Actually, come to think of it, retracting my statement on that until I can look at some of the past games Trundle's hosted because this is experimental

- - - Post Merge - - -

Actually, come to think of it, retracting my statement on that until I can look at some of the past games Trundle's hosted because this is experimental

 

[Jacob]

Who do you think is the right candidate and why?
Byngo, Locket, Vanessa, and maybe AmazonEvan I feel like are the most ideal candidates idk

What do you think the setup how many scum/tp in this game?
17 players so probably 3 mafia. 1 TP is likely because there was 1 late signup and TPs are easy with adjusting set-ups, and it might be a hostile 3rd considering the president's bodyguards and 13 v 3 v 1 seems a little town heavy to me. (I also had one of the worst games balance-wise so this all might be BS)

Who do you think is scum?
Idk odds are 1 of them has already talked in the thread based of numbers so maybe that helps narrow it down

 

[Jacob]

Who do you think is the right candidate and why?
Byngo, Locket, Vanessa, and maybe AmazonEvan I feel like are the most ideal candidates idk

What do you think the setup how many scum/tp in this game?
17 players so probably 3 mafia. 1 TP is likely because there was 1 late signup and TPs are easy with adjusting set-ups, and it might be a hostile 3rd considering the president's bodyguards and 13 v 3 v 1 seems a little town heavy to me. (I also had one of the worst games balance-wise so this all might be BS)

Who do you think is scum?
Idk odds are 1 of them has already talked in the thread based of numbers so maybe that helps narrow it down

 

[Dolby]

Who do you think is the right candidate and why?
Byngo, Locket, Vanessa, and maybe AmazonEvan I feel like are the most ideal candidates idk

What do you think the setup how many scum/tp in this game?
17 players so probably 3 mafia. 1 TP is likely because there was 1 late signup and TPs are easy with adjusting set-ups, and it might be a hostile 3rd considering the president's bodyguards and 13 v 3 v 1 seems a little town heavy to me. (I also had one of the worst games balance-wise so this all might be BS)

Who do you think is scum?
Idk odds are 1 of them has already talked in the thread based of numbers so maybe that helps narrow it down

I’ve personally been avoiding answering that first question until veryone has spoken, but you are aware that two of your top four picks haven’t said a word right? Also, really want to see your logic in these, particularly for Locket as they’ve only played one game and haven’t spoken yet

 

[N e s s]

Who should be pres: I seriously have no idea. Maybe Dolby?

Why should he be president exactly? If you're going to say "bc he's experienced" i'll be both unsurprised and disappointed due to what i had just said about that.

Who do you think is the right candidate and why?
Byngo, Locket, Vanessa, and maybe AmazonEvan I feel like are the most ideal candidates idk

None of those players have done anything remotely alignment telling...if you're saying it just as a matter of fact and that you think they might be decent choices, then I can sorta get that but the only one out of any of those 4 worth considering should be Vanessa since she's put out more content then the other 3 so far...

 

[Jacob]

I'm not feeling the slowness of site right now because it isn't loading any of the quotes, but I chose them because they are the players I actively remember playing games with and not being too difficult to read, so I'd be able to go back and compare play styles if needed. and I eliminated everyone else if they were like too experienced/unreadable or not experienced enough

 

[unravel]

We can't just rash vote Dolby sorry dude but its really risky for you to vote man aside from you as experienced player i rather vote someone confident of alignment like for example Vanessa ya get what i mean right?

We should focus on player's alignment rather vote whos gonna be the president chances are we might vote a wrong player

- - - Post Merge - - -

Sorry with wording i cant think straight rn

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also I am receiving database problem in this site frequently

 

[Dolby]

Glitch

 

[unravel]

GUYS MY POST ARE MISSING HELP

- - - Post Merge - - -

Glitch

 

[cornimer]

I'm not feeling the slowness of site right now because it isn't loading any of the quotes, but I chose them because they are the players I actively remember playing games with and not being too difficult to read, so I'd be able to go back and compare play styles if needed. and I eliminated everyone else if they were like too experienced/unreadable or not experienced enough

I understand your logic, Locket has only played one game though so I wouldn't really consider that "experienced enough", is there a particular reason why you picked her?

 

[Jacob]

For some reason I had Locket pegged for someone who played more than one game, I really don't recall them being particularly noobish. It was just a suggestion though

 

[Locket]

What is your general experience with mafia, including in games with elected roles? Honestly this is only my third game. I don't think any games have had elected roles.

As mayor, how do you intend to use your role? I think I'd mainly enjoy having the body guard and the two votes. I guess I don't really know how the whole president/mayor thing is gonna work.

Who do you want to be President? I mean, someone who's not scum. Also I'd prefer if they were more experienced.

In an anonymous election, is there ANY situation (as town) in which you would lie about who you voted for? I mean maybe, but I can't think of any situations that I would off the top of my head.

Who do you think is the right candidate and why? I'd like to see how the others act, but I'm not sure if I'll get to see that or not. At the moment I have no idea.

What do you think the setup how many scum/tp in this game?
Two or three. I don't know much about mafia setup so this is just a guess.

Who do you think is scum? I'd have to see how others act before I say "that person is scum!"

- - - Post Merge - - -

For some reason I had Locket pegged for someone who played more than one game, I really don't recall them being particularly noobish. It was just a suggestion though

I've played two games, but I got mod-killed in my first game (didn't know how to vote.) So technically I have only done one full game.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Runeraider post already. Please.

 

[illunie]

didn't think i had anything useful to say and im on mobile so cant write a well constructed post yet but geez fine

- - - Post Merge - - -

gonna answer the questions when i can use a good machine in like 2 hrs

- - - Post Merge - - -

gonna answer the questions when i can use a good machine in like 2 hrs

 

[unravel]

Runeraider post already. Please.

Targeting newbies?

 

[N e s s]

Yeesh, it got quiet all the sudden.