Thanks for the fast reply! It's never been like this for me (someone who has done this plenty of times) so that really confused me. I'll check my town once more then I guess I'll wait for tomorrow. Thank you!
Also if you don't see the plot the second time around, continue to save with that new character. Just so you can save your town with it not having a plot. (example, if you were to just quit and load up your mayor it's possible you'll see the plot and probably in a bad spot)
Although, it's weird the plot isn't showing up. Usually only campers take a couple days, and invited villagers will always (or so I thought) show up the next day.
Last edited: