So you we have
Marii
Ryan
Sid
Sataric
Me
Jeremy
VillageDweller
Tom?
Sataric and Marii are
Clear in my eyes
Much like Sid, I'm curious as to why you think this
Jello? Sataric is understandable as they've been contributing and assisting town, but Mari hasn't really done much? I think three posts total, two good one jokish post. Not saying that doesn't mean Mari isn't town but I don't see how everyone is coming to this conclusion unless I missed something?
I'll go ahead and share my notes and suspicions as well.
Ryan88 - Potential Mafia member with a somewhat erratic playstyle. Came across as really suspicious to me early on and that opinion has not changed, but it's been pointed out that they play this way even when Town aligned. I'd say about 50/50 percent chance of being Mafia.
Tom - Difficult to get a good read on so far. The deaths tonight also seems like targets that Tom might pick, since he knows Gandalf very well and Tsundere and him seem to have some kind of love/hate relationship thing going on that I don't quite understand. Possibly the main player pulling the strings for the Mafia team? Want to hear more from him.
ITookYourWaffles - I've always had a hard time getting solid reads on them. I think that they are indeed busy like they've said but they could still be Mafia for all we know. Worth keeping an eye on at least.
Jeremy - Been getting some mixed signals from his posts so far, but he's not one of my primary suspects right now.
Marii - Seems to be very much town aligned this game.
Feloreena - For the most part I do tend to notice what kind of role Feloreena is since we're close and know each other in real life, though it is of course harder to get a proper read with no outside-of-the-thread discussion. I think she's town though. Normally more aggressive when scum.
Sid - Not sure. Possible a Mafia goon. Claimed Townie really early and for no proper reason, if you ask me. Maybe just to be able to slide on by in the later phases of the game. Possible Godfather too.
JelloFish - Although I was suspicious of JelloFish at first, I now think that it's more likely that they are indeed a Townie than the Mafia Godfather. They were the first to claim the Immortal role, and got the name right, and although it's possible a Godfather SafeClaim I'm not as sold on that idea anymore as I was previously.
Crystal - A little bit more aggressive this time around than in previous rounds from what I gather, but I believe someone called them out to step up their game, so that could be the reason why.
Harry - Made some comments that didn't quite make complete sense to me but overall my gut instinct tell me he's probably town. He did seem slightly cocky (no offence intended!) about his performances in a previous Mafia game and leading a successful lynch there, so it's possible that he's being more daring this time around because of it. Therefore it's a chance that he's Mafia. However, it must be noted that his playstyle this time isn't particularly similar to how he played as 3rd party Scum in XCOM, in my opinion.
Conclusion: I would really like to hear more discussions taking place this day phase. I want to hear a proper defense from Ryan. And it would be nice to hear more from Tom as well. He's normally got really good instincts on calling out who's scum when he's on the Town team so hearing whom he suspects would make me feel more at ease about him.
Honestly if I wasn't mafia in Sunleth, I would have been convinced Ryan88 was mafia. >.> Ryan is clearly not a big contributor and their radio silences outside of voting isn't helping anyone. Would definitely be a safe lynch, but with everyone pointing out possible MYLO I'd rather not take that chance.
Potential frames I assure you, though honestly I'm very surprised Gandalf died as I believe he only contributed a single post or two. Very well thought the kill Gandalf N1 tradition had died out, but somebody seems interested in keeping that alive. And honestly I target threats, players namely like you Sataric, not Tsun who half jokes or Gandalf N1 when he hasn't contributed squat yet.
Waffles is in school, so I'm inclined to believe being busy as an excuse but who knows.
Jeremy is well... Jeremy. I think if he's scum, he's cautious enough to not kill anyone who is suspicious of him but at the same time he'd be smart enough to try and frame that player.
I don't have much to say about the rest of the names other than I'm wary of Harry and Sid.
Tom: honestly is just not doing much and could be doing more. I feel like he's a potential mafia right now.
i've written this after feloreenas part but i give up so like go look at his posts he kind of seems 50/50 to me
Crystal: seems to be improving, honestly willing to bet that she's town.
Feloreena: I think could be mafia. I don't know what it is but something just seems off.
Crystal posted basically the same thing in Makar Mafia, where Crystal was Mafia. While it's pointing out mistakes.. I feel like it's just something mafia would say, even to their mafia teammate. Lo and behold, the exact same thing Crystal did in Makar Mafia to their teammate, ryan88. Bet it's the same thing right here with Feloreena and ryan88 again.
Still a bit worried that Sid is ignoring anything I post about her.
This post here just reiterates what I was feeling earlier idk, how she talks about MissNiamh acting odd for a townie it just kind of seems like something mafia would say ok LOL
ok the end
I think it would be best to lynch either someone out of ryan88, Jellofish and Sid just to try and lower KP, but I think it would also kind of be better to lynch a stronger player. not totally sure at this point.
What do you people expect from me, paragraphs upon paragraphs and gut feels all the time? Can't always churn something satisfactory out, unless you'd like me to parrot some of you. My slight suspicion of Jeremy is all I really got that I feel really comfortable with (though you're a little unnerving VD) but so far nobody is sticking out like a sore thumb to me.
Wow, 4 mafia in a game of 14. I just realized how many players they have on their team. Compared to my mini, with 2 out of 16!
I want to say that I'm getting a gut feeling about Tom, but then again he always gives off these vibes from my experience.
ILYT Jer c:
I agree with you about ryan88, it looked odd to me. It looked like he couldn't think of anything to say, so he copied Tom's criticism of his own vote and directed it at me. Even though I had given a reason 2 posts above my vote. This could be because he's not paying close attention to who might be scum since he is scum himself and already knows who's who. It could be a newbie scum mistake to give the impression that he's not interested in figuring out who scum is. Thoughts?
I don't think Ryan honestly cares, even when they're called out to contribute they don't do much. Now that their attempt to host a game is done, you would expect them to try and contribute now but I'm just expecting more radio silence with a bandwagon vote.
Honestly I feel like the inactive/Ryan lynch seems to easy overall as I'm already flashing back to Cell Mafia where nobody wanted to lynch contributors/strong players (minus myself) as being too "Pro-Town" is stupid and mafia is clearly one of the inactives. >.>
