Mafia The Quest for King - Mafia | Game Thread | GAME OVER
- Thread starter EpicGamer12
- Start date
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
how do you explain geoni moving his vote to me when his vote on jacob was not questioned or pressured at all
Geoni
You're doing great!
That moment was literally what had me catch this entire team aside from you Annika
My guess is you were just gonna vote Jacob last minute if the outlook was good but Tessa and Jacob did it sloppily
Post automatically merged:
My guess is you were just gonna vote Jacob last minute if the outlook was good but Tessa and Jacob did it sloppily
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
you voting me or even questioning jacob dont rly matter. you just pushed him to explain his plan better and distance in the process
then you backtracked on it in the next days, and went to "i think he was town for that after i thought abt it"
then you backtracked on it in the next days, and went to "i think he was town for that after i thought abt it"
I was originally fine with kinging either Jacob or Volt
but like, Jacob advocated for it so hard that I got a lil suspicious of it, ironically
they're both killing the same person so I was just confused by his perspective, it's something to talk abt tmrw though if we're still here ig
volt pls read this
this is the only way you find me here i think
mafia could've won there if they got four votes on jacob but i kept saying jacob wanting to be voted was weird
I thought it was bc jacob had a special role but it was bc THEY HAVE FOUR MAF
I wouldn't have done this if I were maf I would've just gone for the win
Post automatically merged:
THIS WAS RIGHT
Post automatically merged:
nonono but
at that exact moment mafia were so close to the win
ofc they would try going for the sweep
like yes, I DID change my mind on Jacob, but I still advocated to kill Tessa that day
and eventually I advocated to kill Jacob too, I just had to think about it
I'm a townie who doesn't know everyone's alignments, I ofc read ppl wrong to begin with but like- I re-evaluated and eventually got the right answers
I advocated to kill all three Ribbit, Tessa and Jacob
even if I townleaned Ribbit I still wanted her to die
(and also I wanted to kill Geoni who from my pov is now confirmed mafia, but that won't help you ahaha)
OH SPEAKING OF THAT
THEY AVOIDED KILLING GEONI FOR SOOOO LONG
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
hmm welp answer this tho
hmmm I don't know for sure
this is maybe a bit of a biased pov but maybe because I said "geoni voting jacob makes me not want to vote jacob"?
but tbf they're probably not basing their decision on what I say ahaha
so they probably just generally realized jacob couldn't get crowned
Geoni
You're doing great!
Nothing about that EoD panic that isn't fake able considering your theater early game like I'm not surprised but also I'm not that engaged with the game at this point this is my weekend and I have a schedule of personal life plans that this game ain't worth taking precedent over so yall do yall
Like if it wasn't already clear you have a whole bunch of notes prepared for this f3 you're just outing that as well
Can't wait to respond to your walls drunk.
Post automatically merged:
Like if it wasn't already clear you have a whole bunch of notes prepared for this f3 you're just outing that as well
Post automatically merged:
Can't wait to respond to your walls drunk.
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
good legacy left by ness here@voltairenism how real or fake do you think this exchange between Ribbit and Annika is? Annika’s first message feels genuine
Post automatically merged:
This gives me like 60% confidence that Geoni really is town
Post automatically merged:
Oh my goodness gracious, she was definitely trying to bus Tessa
Post automatically merged:
Well I think things definitely come full circle with this post in the beginning lol, she herself was trying to distance from Tessa
Post automatically merged:
Food for thought: Ribbit has interacted the following players:
Geoni: 2-3 interactions
Jacob: 2-3 interactions at EoD 3 (she proposed kinging Jacob on Day 2 in an Ender interaction)
Annika: Multiple interactions and mentions throughout the thread
Oath: Zero interactions (barring Ribbit mentioning Oath coming across as “disinterested town” that everyone dogpiled on)
Tessa: zero interactions lmao
Post automatically merged:
Volt I’m gonna be real I have no clue how you should proceed after this phase but I do think you should try and glean information from Tessa’s interactions assuming her high probability of flipping red. The truth is somewhere in the middle here.
To me, the most likely scenario is that it’s just Jacob and he’s really good at pulling out the emotional beats. On the other hand I think I should have stuck to my gut about killing Oath. And on my third hand I think Annika has managed to seep through the cracks.
Maybe look to see if mafia were worried about trying to save Oath and suggested other targets?
Post automatically merged:
@Trundle Will any player that doesn’t vote this phase be modkilled? (Example: Tessa)
if i get it wrong its your fault
aaaaaa
man i do not envy you lol
this is definitely a hard decision
geoni actually wolfread two of his partners and kept the third in null, he's been mostly townsiding
but
I'm town because I was wrong at points but struggled to eventually get to the right answer
townies get things wrong, there's no such thing as a perfect player
yes, Geoni DID scumread wolves and had very townsided reads in general. I can't argue that— I'm sure he's a v good player and would be able to have flawless reads as town too
but I implore you to go through both our ISOs today (when you have time)
which of us looked like they were thinking and struggling to make sense of the game, and which of us looks like they had the answers from the start?
no okay look
Ness' legacy doesn't completely matter here, he was just the most townread player besides you
he died bc geoni and jacob couldn't die, and oath and I were less townread
ftr if I were mafia, I think I could've just easily killed Geoni there instead
I figured the game might just end tn and I was actually shocked when I saw Jacob was maf and the game was still going ahaha
dude wtf there were literally two townies in this game, Ender and I
how did I get this unlucky LOL
man i do not envy you lol
this is definitely a hard decision
geoni actually wolfread two of his partners and kept the third in null, he's been mostly townsiding
but
I'm town because I was wrong at points but struggled to eventually get to the right answer
townies get things wrong, there's no such thing as a perfect player
yes, Geoni DID scumread wolves and had very townsided reads in general. I can't argue that— I'm sure he's a v good player and would be able to have flawless reads as town too
but I implore you to go through both our ISOs today (when you have time)
which of us looked like they were thinking and struggling to make sense of the game, and which of us looks like they had the answers from the start?
Post automatically merged:
no okay look
Ness' legacy doesn't completely matter here, he was just the most townread player besides you
he died bc geoni and jacob couldn't die, and oath and I were less townread
ftr if I were mafia, I think I could've just easily killed Geoni there instead
Post automatically merged:
I'm a fast typer, these aren't prepared
I figured the game might just end tn and I was actually shocked when I saw Jacob was maf and the game was still going ahaha
Post automatically merged:
Post automatically merged:
dude wtf there were literally two townies in this game, Ender and I
how did I get this unlucky LOL
Last edited:
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
ngl i expect us to be last 3 to be us even though i tr geoni
geoni has been the lowest hanging fruit of all low hanging fruit this game
Post automatically merged:
im reading back and tessa pushed for a geoni policy chop d3 sighs
Volt, I actually have a question for YOU
Why do you townread Geoni?
besides the fact that he scumread Tessa and Ribbit (yes I'll admit I townread him for that too but I can make arguments about how what I did is arguably more townsided bc I was louder)
I wanna understand what reasons you have for leaning me here so I can try to counter them
and also if you try explaining it you might realize some reasons are flawed idk
ik but
she advocated against killing him d1
Why do you townread Geoni?
besides the fact that he scumread Tessa and Ribbit (yes I'll admit I townread him for that too but I can make arguments about how what I did is arguably more townsided bc I was louder)
I wanna understand what reasons you have for leaning me here so I can try to counter them
and also if you try explaining it you might realize some reasons are flawed idk
Post automatically merged:
no help
ik but
she advocated against killing him d1
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
she advocated against killing gabby/ender too
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
i have a migraine imma lay down
you hold the key to end this suffering
you hold the key to end this suffering
you should lay down and get some resti have a migraine imma lay down
you hold the key to end this suffering
wdym by the second part, i thought hammering was disabled?
Post automatically merged:
oh right ghgbghfbgfbh
Post automatically merged:
ummhh
im not gonna yet, I'll do it sometime tomorrow
i wanna do my best to help you win this for town
Post automatically merged:
unironically
why would Ender die over Geoni when Geoni was scumreading both Tessa and Ribbit and had Jacob in null
unless he was mafia
Post automatically merged:
think about this:
Ender was SRing Ribbit and Tessa, but also hard townread Jacob and I
Geoni was SRing Ribbit and Tessa, had Jacob in null and had me as a very slight townlean
if I'm on a team with Ribbit, Tess and Jacob, we easily kill Geoni there over Ender
if Geoni is on the team, it makes much more sense why Ender died, as he had Geoni null too i think? I have to go recheck actually
Post automatically merged:
i think this is the last thing ender said about geoni
so...yeah
Post automatically merged:
lmao wait
Ribbit, Jacob and even Geoni were all advocating for king on D3 LOL
mannn they were really going for the win help
Last edited:
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
bc ender was way more active
d2 geoni was only catching up. his reads didn't have much value for anyone bc they were based on outdated data
Post automatically merged:
why would geoni want to split the votes
Last edited:
