Mafia Battle for Mount Olympus Mafia (Game Over/Mafia Win)

[Sataric]

Sid and Waffles then?
we have to go for the MOST obvious if Tom or Jeremy flip town its game over Id go for Waffles but IDK yet
##VOTE ITookYourWaffles (will consider switching)

Well, now you're making me second-guess myself. First you seemed really uncertain of wanting to vote at all. Now you seem quite happy to vote for Waffles, even though there is many hours left in the day. What's the rush? There's multiple Mafia left alive and I think we should give everyone a chance to defend themselves before voting at all, surely? How can you be so confident that Waffles is Mafia? You've claimed Townie so you cannot have inspected her, unless you're the Godfather after all and then you'd obviously know who's on your team. I agree that she does seem suspicious of course, but so does Sid - Definitely more suspicious, if you ask me. I feel very uncomfortable with the fact that you're trying to rush this vote when there's more than twelve hours left for us to make up our minds, and I don't know who to trust anymore. Would really like some input from the other players in the game, and I think some of them are still asleep. We must have a Detective in the game - And I think I can guess who it is, perhaps - So maybe we should let them say who they've inspected and cleared. That might narrow the scope down a bit!

 

[Sid2125]

i know i was back and forth on who i thought was suspicious. But i couldnt find anybody to sus for any reason. So i was bandwagoning a bit. But i tried to state my own opinions so i wasnt just voting for someone only because everybody else was. But if you lynch me. You will be screwing yourself's over. I will come up townie and you will just lose the game. And i would prefer not to lose because i hate losing. I dont know if this will change anybodys mind at all. But i hope it will.

 

[Sataric]

i know i was back and forth on who i thought was suspicious. But i couldnt find anybody to sus for any reason. So i was bandwagoning a bit. But i tried to state my own opinions so i wasnt just voting for someone only because everybody else was. But if you lynch me. You will be screwing yourself's over. I will come up townie and you will just lose the game. And i would prefer not to lose because i hate losing. I dont know if this will change anybodys mind at all. But i hope it will.

Okay, so convince me - If you had to pick three people you guess to be the Mafia team, who would you pick?

I was inclined to believe Jello over you since they stated that they were the Townie role first, but as we've mentioned multiple times they could still potentially be the Godfather. And you have been somewhat back and forth on things. More so than anyone else. It's normal to be a little hesitant since you cannot be certain of almost anything in this game of course. What I found the most odd is how you claimed to be suspicious of the blue roles, so that they likely wouldn't be healed, and then they die the next day. That just doesn't look right to me.

 

[Sid2125]

I would take a guess and say Waffles, Jello and maybe Tom. But i have no evidnece what so ever and its more of a feeling. Well how was i supposed to know they were blue. they seemed kinda of scummy to me. so i was inclined to think they might be scum. But obviously i was completely wrong.

 

[unravel]

I'm back for yoloing guys okay just kidding
I'm would like to apologies all of you for inactivity this week was unexpected I have to make a treasure map related to Physics, Trigonometry and Advance Algebra. Practice for chess try outs, doing my persuasive essay also doing my economic's project I tried my best to catch up and was about to contribute but I have no time for that. Currently multi tasking and read all the post

Going back to the real topic going to be serious this time, we shouldn't give up and we have to read everything. I'm going to try my best to contribute and we should all discuss today's lynch if we lynch a townie then we lose. I'm not going to vote JelloFishXD because he said that he is immortal townie first for me I don't see the problem with Jello. As for Sidover9000 I can feel scummy vibes from him all I can say that he is a distraction looking at his post I don't see anything useful most of them are one liner like:

my side of what?

Now i am confused. i dont get what you mean.

Hi Jeremy

Y U NO SAY HI TO ME?!

I believe it's 3 votes for no lynch and four for MissNiamh

Most of his post are repeat or too obvious like "protect this user because he is smart/strong player" and he does bandwagon. He is only suspicion in my list so therefore I'm going to vote Sid. If there is someone who is more suspicious than Sid then I'm going to change it around 6 AM SGT if somethings new.

##Vote: Sid2125

 

[Jeremy]

Okay, so convince me - If you had to pick three people you guess to be the Mafia team, who would you pick?

I was inclined to believe Jello over you since they stated that they were the Townie role first, but as we've mentioned multiple times they could still potentially be the Godfather. And you have been somewhat back and forth on things. More so than anyone else. It's normal to be a little hesitant since you cannot be certain of almost anything in this game of course. What I found the most odd is how you claimed to be suspicious of the blue roles, so that they likely wouldn't be healed, and then they die the next day. That just doesn't look right to me.

Even if Jello isn't godfather, he or she could still claim townie.

 

[Sataric]

Even if Jello isn't godfather, he or she could still claim townie.

You are right actually. He did know the name of the role which is why I thought it might be a Godfather safeclaim, but logically speaking the Godfather would share the role name in Mafia chat so that the other scum could claim it. Jello did blurt it out super early on day one for no real reason whatsoever.

 

[Sid2125]

Hi Waffles. there does that make you feel better
I was trying to be helpful someone asked me for my side of it. I didn't know what they were talking about. Then they said something else and just made me very confused. I try to act townie but sometimes I just come off as scummy.

 

[Sataric]

Hi Waffles. there does that make you feel better
I was trying to be helpful someone asked me for my side of it. I didn't know what they were talking about. Then they said something else and just made me very confused. I try to act townie but sometimes I just come off as scummy.

... Is that a slip up? How can you ACT townie?

Out of all the people in the game, you seem the most suspicious to me. After hearing your defense, that has not really changed for me. And due to not wanting the pressure of being the last person to vote, and then end up getting chewed out in observer chat if I make the wrong choice, I'm just going to go ahead and vote for you and see how it all plays out. Really really sorry if I'm making a mistake but the evidence against you is simply much stronger than the evidence against anyone else, in my opinion.

##VOTE: Sid2125.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Well, now you're making me second-guess myself. First you seemed really uncertain of wanting to vote at all. Now you seem quite happy to vote for Waffles, even though there is many hours left in the day. What's the rush? There's multiple Mafia left alive and I think we should give everyone a chance to defend themselves before voting at all, surely? How can you be so confident that Waffles is Mafia? You've claimed Townie so you cannot have inspected her, unless you're the Godfather after all and then you'd obviously know who's on your team. I agree that she does seem suspicious of course, but so does Sid - Definitely more suspicious, if you ask me. I feel very uncomfortable with the fact that you're trying to rush this vote when there's more than twelve hours left for us to make up our minds, and I don't know who to trust anymore. Would really like some input from the other players in the game, and I think some of them are still asleep. We must have a Detective in the game - And I think I can guess who it is, perhaps - So maybe we should let them say who they've inspected and cleared. That might narrow the scope down a bit!

I don't believe the DT should reveal just yet if they're in play, last night probably didn't go so hot for them because its likely the person they aimed to inspect got killed or they got roleblocked (Or both!). That said why would you want them to reveal in the first place?

Ryan88- Uhh I don't know what to say. He has almost the same scum and town playstyle (barely different lel). When were scum together in makar mafia he said he's not going to claim at all. He makes this post in defense. I don't know...it seems weak, maybe he's trying to hide his scum play?


Tom- I also don't know what to say since I haven't played many games with him. Mostpeople say he steps up during day 3 or 4, but I don't think we have time for that, honestly I have mixed feelings on him and hope this doesn't turn into Sunleth (shudder shudder)PostCount: 15


ITookYourWaffles- They haven't been posting much so I can't really get a read on her. Idk something about them seems off but, its just a slight gut feeling idk.PostCount: 22



Jeremy- I don't know he's usually quiet in games but again like Waffles, I just don't know what to say about him, Out of all the people I've mentioned so far, I think he has the highest chance of being scum. PostCount: 11


Marii- They've been mostly quiet the whole game but again like most people idk. A few off their posts make me feel a bit off I don't know her and Jer scum team? PostCount: 9

Feloreena-I'm getting mostly town reads from them as they've been posting how they usually do when they're town. PostCount: 8

Sid2125- Again he has in implied he has the same townie role as jello but he hasn't really said it. They've been quiet the whole game like many of the people I have on my list.PostCount: 9

JellofishXD- Day 1 you claimed the townie role. You said it was too "save your skin" How can you say that when there wasnt a single vote on you and there was still atleast 20 hours left in the game. I'm thinking possible godfather for her. I'm sorry but blues are more important. If you get lynched it is for the benefit of town and the blues to do their job. Maybe you are the godfather and didnt want to get lynched so quickly. PostCount: 15


Sataric-Like other's said they are pretty pro town, but I'm watching you, I'm always weary of pro town players tho. PostCount: 12


VillageDweller- I'm getting town reads from them. Post Count: 8

Bringing this back up, something I thought you would do Sataric. When ahead and tossed in some color and crossed out the dead. There are some players that appear to be quieter than most this game to be honest. Where's Feloreena?

 

[Sid2125]

Try to act like town if that makes better sense. well i hope you like losing.

 

[Sataric]

~@ Tom - Your recent post speaks volumes about why every single person on TBT likes you. *Smiles!* Made me giggle!

 

[Trent the Paladin]

~@ Tom - Your recent post speaks volumes about why every single person on TBT likes you. *Smiles!* Made me giggle!

Huh. What relevance does that have to the game?

 

[Feloreena]

Sorry for not posting something earlier on, had issues with sleeping last night and been busy looking after my dog while my parents are away. I have been trying to keep up-to-date with the thread on my phone meanwhile - really good job to Jeremy with the vigilante shot, the risk has definitely paid off!

So we find ourselves in another critical situation for today's lynch. I'll try and give an overview of my thoughts right now. I'll need to look back at Crystal's posts in more detail again to see her behaviour towards certain players, but the post that Tom has brought up is a good start.

Tom - I'm a bit uncertain on Tom, his play style is really consistent from what I have seen in the games I have played or watched that he has been in. I would like him to explain his reasoning for Marii being shot by the vigilante like he said he would earlier because it was a weird conclusion to make. Crystal said she had mixed feelings about Tom, so she never cleared him but never really gave a proper opinion on him.

ITookYourWaffles - Has been inactive a fair bit and put it down to busy with school things. I think I have only played one game with them before, and I am finding the play style a bit similar, and I found it to be quite scummy before. Crystal says she had a bad gut feeling about Waffles - kind of vague and doesn't give us much information really. I am kind of 50/50 with Waffles right now as I wanted to lynch them in the previous game I played with them for similar behaviour and they were actually town.

Jeremy - Vigilante and confirmed as town to me due to no counterclaims, therefore not a lynch candidate.

Sid2125 - I have felt uneasy about Sid since day one, and a lot of her behaviour doesn't seem very town-like despite her being adamant that she is a townie. The townie claim doesn't mean a lot to me as she was not the first one to reveal the true townie name and it was mentioned more in passing, so I can't help but feel that she might be on the mafia side trying to clear herself. The defense I have seen from her earlier today has not been very encouraging either. Interestingly Crystal never really commented on the alignment they felt Sid was, but just stating the fact that she had been quite quiet and claimed townie (which everyone can read for themselves). So that also makes me feel a bit uneasy about them as well.

JellofishXD - We all know about the townie claim business so I won't go over that and possible Godfather stuff. I am a bit concerned that Jellofish voted no lynch for Day one, then didn't vote for Day two, and now is the first to vote for today. It seems a weird switch in play style, so perhaps he has been encouraged to get the ball rolling by scum team mates, I'm not sure. Crystal was also the 'harshest' on Jellofish in her post and said if he was lynched it would be for the benefit of town. That could also be trying to throw us off.

Sataric - His behaviour has been pro-town and helpful, and like Tom his play style is generally consistent in every game. It's harder for me to know his true intentions in a non-PM game (yes I have played a non-PM game with him in the partner mafia, but I believed him to be town quite early because of his plan with VillageDweller), as he seems to try and PM a lot of players as scum that perhaps he wouldn't usually speak to or work with. As we come closer to the end game it is harder to know what to think, but putting him up for lynch feels too risky for me when I have stronger suspicions on other players. Crystal again just observed his pro-town behaviour and that she was weary and keeping an eye out, fairly vague comments that I believe other players had mentioned earlier.

Overall Crystal's comments on players have been fairly safe or obvious in that post, but the Jellofish comment seems to be the most 'aggressive' which may tell us something. At the moment I really think that there is at least one or two mafia players in Jello, Sid, and Waffles. I'll be thinking about who to vote for as I don't want to do it just yet.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

I equated vig shooting Marii instead of scum because I listed Marii's name with Jeremy and somebody else (on phone, tabs r hard).

And you know what, whatever I'm Aphrodite the Detective. I was blocked last night but was going to inspect VD so it wouldn't have mattered anyways. Night one I inspected Sataric and they flipped town, but there's always the possibility he's godfather (Hades).

 

[Feloreena]

I equated vig shooting Marii instead of scum because I listed Marii's name with Jeremy and somebody else (on phone, tabs r hard).

And you know what, whatever I'm Aphrodite the Detective. I was blocked last night but was going to inspect VD so it wouldn't have mattered anyways. Night one I inspected Sataric and they flipped town, but there's always the possibility he's godfather (Hades).

But Marii was Aphrodite?

 

[Trent the Paladin]

But Marii was Aphrodite?

****, too many A named goddesses. Sorry, Artemis. Whichever one is stupid hunter.

 

[Jeremy]

Well if we don't lynch mafia now, the game is probably over. So we have to be careful. Who do you guys think is the most likely to be mafia?

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Well if we don't lynch mafia now, the game is probably over. So we have to be careful. Who do you guys think is the most likely to be mafia?

Well I think we have two options here, we take a risk on the unconfirmed stronger players or we go out on a limb and lynch Waffles/Sid. Because with nobody counterclaiming our two blue roles, there should only be two townies left. Preferably we should aim for the Mafia Roleblocker, but then I'm just going to killed off regardless. Who do you think we ought to go for Jer?

(Also what's your god/goddess?)

 

[Jeremy]

I'm Athena. I'd rather vote for Sid than Waffles I think. But why not Jello?