Mafia Caxnival Mafia: Game Thread - End Game
- Thread starter Chris
- Start date
So, do you even care that there were two kills? That has serious implications on game strategy at this point
Kit's like 99% clear, as Heyden probably ended up inspecting her N1
EpicGamer12
Senior Member
It just increases the chance that you're scum. In fact, I bet you're going to try to claim SK.
Well, yes, you’re right on the strategy point that SK shouldn’t be lynched (pretty much the only possible one is Evan, who being SK would leave a N1 crossover), but that’s just be stupid if I was mafia because Toads said he blocked me and Tina confirmed SK kills could be blocked. There’s one more thing, if it’s strongarm, we need to get rid of the source of the second kill, or we lose today
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
RIP Toads and Vanessa, Toads better be right about Dolby 
Also lmao Bianca, until I meet forum goers IRL I always think of them as their profile pic
Also lmao Bianca, until I meet forum goers IRL I always think of them as their profile pic
EpicGamer12
Senior Member
RIP Toads and Vanessa, Toads better be right about Dolby
Also lmao Bianca, until I meet forum goers IRL I always think of them as their profile pic
Who do you think is scum?
- - - Post Merge - - -
Trundle
Kit - supposedly inspecting by Heyden
Locket
amazonevan19
Dolby
Kirbystarship
So if Kit actually was inspected by Heyden (which I'm not sure I believe), Dolby, Locket, and amazonevan19 and the last three killing roles. We can't mislynch today, so I suggest we lynch Dolby, who is the most obvious scum I've ever seen.
Biancasbotique
Sweet Feather
My scummates are doing a great job! The remaining town have no idea lol
EpicGamer12
Senior Member
Kirbystarship
Senior Member
This just feels like you're trying to make it look like Dolby is town. I feel more sure Dolby is scum by you saying this.
EpicGamer12
Senior Member
Locket and Kit, please post a reads list with you of the remaining players you think are town or mafia.
- - - Post Merge - - -
The people avoiding this are obviously scum (Dolby hasn't even attempted to post a reads list in a long time because if he did it would be used against him super hard)
- - - Post Merge - - -
The people avoiding this are obviously scum (Dolby hasn't even attempted to post a reads list in a long time because if he did it would be used against him super hard)
We have one of two situations right now. We are at either a 3v2v1, where we have to lynch mafia (and not SK), or a 4v2, where we have to lynch the cause of the second kill specifically, right now, as it stands, this is my reads list
Kit-99% sure that she was inspected by Heyden, if anybody wants my logic I'll give it to them
Kirby-Cast the tie-breaking vote on oath between me, oath, Panda, and Vanessa. Also rode Bianca's ass all through the past two days
Locket
AmazonEvan
Trundle
If we are in a 3v2v1, the breakdown is guarenteed to be this
Kit
Kirby
Dolby
Evan
Trundle
Locket
Evan's pretty much the only possible SK at the moment, as that'd leave only his N1 kill unaccounted for (probably used on Dad if that was the case). N2 went onto Heyden with one from the mafia which is why Ness wasn't able to save him. N3 Toads blocked him, and tonight he killed either Toads or Vanessa. All other players being SK leave the N1 and N3 kills unaccounted for so they are decididly unlikely. Kit is pretty much clear due to Heyden's inspect and Kirby has been extremely town since he replaced in.
If it's 4v2, we have to get the source of the mafia's second kill, and it looks like this
Kit
Kirby
Dolby
Locket
Evan
Trundle
I'm pretty much certain on Kit and Kirby being town (again). Locket and Evan aren't compatible because Evan tried to start a lynch on the former yesterday. This leaves one of them and Trundle as the scum team. I'm more inclined to believe it's Evan, because Locket gave Bianca the majority yesterday and Trundle seems to be pocketing her.
Now, as for Trundle, he has literally never voted for mafia. He even stubbornly clung to me as the Bianca lynch reached and past maj
Kit should be on the same level, if not higher, than Kirby on here. She was 99% inspected by Heyden, and the fact that he doubts that should send red flags to everybody. I see this as him trying to widen his lynch options and spread doubt on someone who should be confirmed
So TL;DR
Tries to drum up suspicion on multiple confirmed town
Has literally only voted for town
Casting suspicion off of oath2order, and hopped around him in the D2 voting
Refused to vote for Bianca
I personally feel that Evan is more likely to be his partner
Kit-99% sure that she was inspected by Heyden, if anybody wants my logic I'll give it to them
Kirby-Cast the tie-breaking vote on oath between me, oath, Panda, and Vanessa. Also rode Bianca's ass all through the past two days
Locket
AmazonEvan
Trundle
If we are in a 3v2v1, the breakdown is guarenteed to be this
Kit
Kirby
Dolby
Evan
Trundle
Locket
Evan's pretty much the only possible SK at the moment, as that'd leave only his N1 kill unaccounted for (probably used on Dad if that was the case). N2 went onto Heyden with one from the mafia which is why Ness wasn't able to save him. N3 Toads blocked him, and tonight he killed either Toads or Vanessa. All other players being SK leave the N1 and N3 kills unaccounted for so they are decididly unlikely. Kit is pretty much clear due to Heyden's inspect and Kirby has been extremely town since he replaced in.
If it's 4v2, we have to get the source of the mafia's second kill, and it looks like this
Kit
Kirby
Dolby
Locket
Evan
Trundle
I'm pretty much certain on Kit and Kirby being town (again). Locket and Evan aren't compatible because Evan tried to start a lynch on the former yesterday. This leaves one of them and Trundle as the scum team. I'm more inclined to believe it's Evan, because Locket gave Bianca the majority yesterday and Trundle seems to be pocketing her.
Now, as for Trundle, he has literally never voted for mafia. He even stubbornly clung to me as the Bianca lynch reached and past maj
D2, he hops his vote around, onto all townies,with a mantra of pretty much "anybody but oath". He literally places his vote on all major lynch candidates (including the horrendous Vanessa wagon, which I still think was majority scum driven) except for oath, and what did oath flip? Mafia godfather. D3 really wasn't eventful as we were all set on Panda. But D4, he stuck to me and refused to vote Bianca even though she scumslipped.
Here we say him defending oath from Cleb. At this point in time, oath was honestly pretty sus, but not to the point where his lynch was guarenteed. This is interesting not so much as him accusing Cleb, but in him calling all of the cases against Oath weak.
Made N2, literally calls out Cleb, despite him being nearly confirmed town due to being hit, for being in oath's townreads. This is scummy beyond all imagination, he's trying to gather dirt against a player who is nearly clear. Which is remarkably similar to what he does in his most recent reads where he calls out the inspected Kit
Kit should be on the same level, if not higher, than Kirby on here. She was 99% inspected by Heyden, and the fact that he doubts that should send red flags to everybody. I see this as him trying to widen his lynch options and spread doubt on someone who should be confirmed
Honestly, this is just icing on the cake at this point. Vanessa was pretty much clear at this point for shooting Farobi, and her existance accounted for the drop in kills.
Hilariously ironic
So TL;DR
Tries to drum up suspicion on multiple confirmed town
Has literally only voted for town
Casting suspicion off of oath2order, and hopped around him in the D2 voting
Refused to vote for Bianca
I personally feel that Evan is more likely to be his partner
Locket
♤
I've already did most of my town but since I only did three:
Kirby - With how hard they pushed the Bianca lynch, I'd be surprised if they are scum.
Kit - Was inspected, so I've heard.
Dolby - Does sorta seem scum, BUT I have not seen Dolby's plays many times before.
Trundle - With how deep he's going for Dolby. I have no idea on him though.
Evan - As Toad once pointed out, Bianca never talked about him. Might be another scum.
I am personally not fully scumming people because I see very good reasons on both sides, and I keep switching town and scum.
If you had to pick 2 from your list to be maf together, who would they be?
Locket
♤
It would either be you/Evan or Trundle/Evan, so basically Evan right now.
Unless you and Trundle are planning this whole thing, though that's unlikely.
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
I just skimmed Dolby's post and checked the voting thread, and see I'm getting sussed alongside Trundle. Tbh Dolby's logic vs. trundle really makes sense, and I can see why process of elimination would dictate I could be his partner. I'm not though, and I feel dolby's just bussing trundle before he goes down and I still think Dolby needs to go today. The only argument I am seeing people give for me being a partner is process of elimination, but the fact people can't put a finger on why I seem scummy to them is rather suspicious itself.
I'll actually read what I've missed here shortly, just posting here with a quick checking in
- - - Post Merge - - -
ok, catching up was less strenuous than expected. Trundle, I frankly think you and Dolby are the last two scum. Locket's kind of redeemed herself the past phase in my view, and Dolby pointed out a lot of your questionable behavior very succinctly, but I think it's because he knows from scumchat the strategies you guys tried to cook up and they've all mostly not worked. Hence, he has insider knowledge to post an excruciatingly detailed Ness-like manifesto against you, because he knows full well your thought processes as a scummate.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Why is it unlikely that Dolby and Trundle planned this? Why are you focused so much on me and not on the other two? Is it because I've sussed you so much?
I'll actually read what I've missed here shortly, just posting here with a quick checking in
- - - Post Merge - - -
ok, catching up was less strenuous than expected. Trundle, I frankly think you and Dolby are the last two scum. Locket's kind of redeemed herself the past phase in my view, and Dolby pointed out a lot of your questionable behavior very succinctly, but I think it's because he knows from scumchat the strategies you guys tried to cook up and they've all mostly not worked. Hence, he has insider knowledge to post an excruciatingly detailed Ness-like manifesto against you, because he knows full well your thought processes as a scummate.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Why is it unlikely that Dolby and Trundle planned this? Why are you focused so much on me and not on the other two? Is it because I've sussed you so much?
EpicGamer12
Senior Member
I mean you realize I was the first person to call oath out this game, right? You also know that I never instantly trust claims regardless of night actions because I've seen some insane night action spreadsheets where things played out the complete opposite of what I thought all game. I have a long history of not trusting blue claims regardless of how plausible they sound. I also mentioned quite a few times early game that I wanted to policy lynch inactives (bianca) which was as early as D2. I wish I had been around more for D1 as well when it was pretty obvious Sensai was a terrible lynch.
My N2 reads were the first time I actually started reading the game and I had no idea that xCleb ever claimed a hit, I never read that.
- - - Post Merge - - -
I'd really like to hear from kirby at this point who is universally read as town.
- - - Post Merge - - -
That's great that you think that but I'm not scum. I have been pushing for a Dolby lynch this entire game and his behavior is incredibly obvious. The minimal contribution except when he's at risk says it all. It's not pro-town play.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Just gonna put this out there too - if we lynch Dolby today then I'm perfectly fine with being lynched tomorrow. Doesn't even matter what he flips. I am willing to let myself die and us lose the game just to prove that I'm town. The fact that he even thinks I'm scum right now is so atypical behavior of him. He always knows my role when he's town just based on posting style. He only went off my reads to make a case about me which shows how hard he is grasping at straws.
My N2 reads were the first time I actually started reading the game and I had no idea that xCleb ever claimed a hit, I never read that.
- - - Post Merge - - -
I'd really like to hear from kirby at this point who is universally read as town.
- - - Post Merge - - -
That's great that you think that but I'm not scum. I have been pushing for a Dolby lynch this entire game and his behavior is incredibly obvious. The minimal contribution except when he's at risk says it all. It's not pro-town play.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Just gonna put this out there too - if we lynch Dolby today then I'm perfectly fine with being lynched tomorrow. Doesn't even matter what he flips. I am willing to let myself die and us lose the game just to prove that I'm town. The fact that he even thinks I'm scum right now is so atypical behavior of him. He always knows my role when he's town just based on posting style. He only went off my reads to make a case about me which shows how hard he is grasping at straws.
EpicGamer12
Senior Member
LOL where does this come from?
- - - Post Merge - - -
Kit has been on me all game for literally no reason
- - - Post Merge - - -
can't tell if bad town or mafia
- - - Post Merge - - -
all I can find is the fact I was suggesting policy lynching inactives (bianca) so Kit thought i was scum because of it? but I was right about bianca
