collectible tier list ★ (now closed)

[nightxshift]

So I can sell my vesta for 10k?! Huh!? How is that?? She's not even a rare collectible. Whhere do the plushies and star fragments fall?

Plushies would fall in tier 3 and fragments in 5 if I’m not wrong. Vesta is gonna be pretty rare since it’s only gonna be available in the shop for a couple of days now, but I’m not 100% sure heh

 

[SinnerTheCat]

Vesta at the top of the collectible tier list?

 

[skarmoury]

So I can sell my vesta for 10k?! Huh!? How is that?? She's not even a rare collectible. Whhere do the plushies and star fragments fall?

LOL vesta isn't really 10k+ TBT but we can dream!!! She'll probably fall in tier 5-6.
Yeah I agree w nightxshift, I'm seeing Mom's & Sheep plushies and Pink & Purple frags go for roughly 4k+ tbt, and common fragments around 1.2-1.5k tbt. As for Celeste & White frag they're probably tier 2 (they're going for 7k+ tbt I think?)

 

[Karmahri]

I'm going to guess vesta will probably be around tier 6 or 7 actually, since thats where most of the villager/npc collectibles fall under
(or put vesta in her own category xD)

 

[Cosmic-chan]

LOL vesta isn't really 10k+ TBT but we can dream!!! She'll probably fall in tier 5-6.
Yeah I agree w nightxshift, I'm seeing Mom's & Sheep plushies and Pink & Purple frags go for roughly 4k+ tbt, and common fragments around 1.2-1.5k tbt. As for Celeste & White frag they're probably tier 2 (they're going for 7k+ tbt I think?)

I have seen the pink n purple ones sold for 4.5k and the rest for 1.2k -1.5k. Except the white. (Maybe yeah 7k?) Ughhhh I need those plushies aahh!!

 

[Damniel]

bought a swirl for 700!

 

[seliph]

vesta is actually worth more than weird doll this is science

 

[IonicKarma]

My prediction for fair collectibles are as follows:
Celeste Chick: Tier 2 -> Tier 1 over time (7k->10k+)
White Star Fragment: Tier 2 -> Tier 1 over time (Potential for this to be the next white feather but who knows, 7k->10k)
Pink Star Fragment: Tier 3 -> Maybe Tier 2 a year from now (4.5k->6-7k)
Purple Star Fragment: Tier 3 (4k->5-6k)
Sheep Plushie: Tier 3 (4k)
Unlimited Star Frags: Tier 5 (1.2-1.4k)
Vesta: Tier 6 (200-400)

 

[lana.]

Goddess Tier
Priceless

Vesta​

 

[seliph]

spreadsheet update!

- pink/purple fragments and mom's/sheep plush have been added to the middle of tier 3
- white fragment and celeste chick plush have been added to the bottom of tier 2

 

[Lavamaize]

I feel like a black feather might need to be moved up considering it was traded for collectibles worth like 14k.

 

[seliph]

I feel like a black feather might need to be moved up considering it was traded for collectibles worth like 14k.

crash is one person who was willing to overpay and lord knows they could afford to. we will not be moving anything based on single instances.

 

[xTech]

I think Goomba could be moved up into at least the next tier, since I've seen a couple sold for at least 4k, and i'm pretty sure some others also traded them 1:1 for the smaller plushies. While he's not as pricey as Invader and Pinky, I definitely feel he shouldn't be left at the bottom of tier 4.

 

[Bcat]

Bought a final boss feather from the wonderful @michealsmells for 10k

 

[Sharksheep]

3 sheep plush for 4k each
1 sheep for 4.5k

 

[Cosmic-chan]

3 sheep plush for 4k
1 sheep for 4.5k

Huh?? That math doesn't even add up

 

[Chere.]

Huh?? That math doesn't even add up

I believe they mean they bought/sold three sheep for 4k tbt each, and bought/sold one sheep for 4.5k tbt

 

[Lavamaize]

crash is one person who was willing to overpay and lord knows they could afford to. we will not be moving anything based on single instances.

There's also a thing called supply and demand though in economics. Because there are so few black feathers, and people want them, the price of it is likely to increase. In addition, because the black feather is sold so infrequently, one time does make a difference so even if you were to take the average of about three past sales (8k, 8.5k, 14k), the value would be a little over 10k.

 

[Cosmic-chan]

I believe they mean they bought/sold three sheep for 4k tbt each, and bought/sold one sheep for 4.5k tbt

How one sheep worth more than three?

 

[Chere.]

How one sheep worth more than three?

I mean it just depends on who's buying/selling. Collectibles are never sold at the same price. For example, I've seen the dreamy popper recently range from 2k-2.5k tbt recently. Again, it's up to the seller how much they want to charge, and how much the buyer is willing to pay, so there will always be a range in value.