collectible tier list ★ (now closed)

[Lancelot]

Arguably the gold egg is only for first place people in the egg hunt atm no? Hasn’t it only been bought by whoever found all the eggs first atm

Post automatically merged: Nov 8, 2020

Also to keep on thread trend,

traded my flick egg for a cobweb egg+ eerie potion

 

[mogyay]

ya i'm thinking dreamy and nightmare are moving up (if seliph agrees). this is about rarity as well and they're definitely just as rare now as the bottom ones in the tier above

 

[Alienfish]

Also, yeah just wanted to say I did indeed buy a star glow wand for 39k, but since they are hardly sold anyway I don't think it matters tier-wise too much.

Post automatically merged: Nov 8, 2020

Arguably the gold egg is only for first place people in the egg hunt atm no? Hasn’t it only been bought by whoever found all the eggs first atm

Yeah, it was gift-able at one point but since removed.

 

[skarmoury]

I forgot to mention but some trades I had the past weeks:
- traded my moonlight egg for a hot feather + 1k tbt
- got a zen egg for a kirby egg + 5k tbt

thanks mog & seliph as always for this list, you guys are the best

 

[seliph]

nightmare and dreamy eggs can definitely move up, they've gotten quite popular. there also seems to be a general consensus on the values of the halloween collectibles so stay tuuuuuned

also just a reminder we do not take outlier transactions into account, thank you

 

[Cosmic-chan]

Cobweb egg is sold for 3.5k

 

[biibii]

dreamy egg is around 6-10k at this point I think ?? ;-;

 

[Cosmic-chan]

Bruh I was hopping to maybe trade my cobweb egg for a dreamy egg or buy one but my 2.2k bells aren't worth anything it seems. :')

 

[biibii]

Bruh I was hopping to maybe trade my cobweb egg for a dreamy egg or buy one but my 2.2k bells aren't worth anything it seems. :')

don't give up! both 2.2k and the cobweb egg together could get you somewhere!!

 

[Cosmic-chan]

don't give up! both 2.2k and the cobweb egg together could get you somewhere!!

Maybe

 

[Cosmic-chan]

So how much does one think I'll spend on a blue fragment?

 

[mogyay]

hello! me and seliph made some changes! you can see it on the thread and the spreadsheet! (spreadsheet is always updated first so always best to check in there first if poss)

dreamy egg & nightmare egg have moved up to the bottom of tier 2
sheep plush up to the top of tier 3
flick egg in the middle of tier 3
cobweb egg low in tier 3
moonlight and zombie egg at the top of tier 5
candycorn egg at the top of tier 6

potion is still undecided

 

[Cosmic-chan]

Hi ! What do you think is the highest price I can sell my Cobweb egg without it being too high ?

 

[Sharksheep]

Bought a spring sakura for 200tbt

 

[oak]

I bought a Ruby & Coco collectable for 500 TBT each!

 

[Variety.Gamer 4438]

friday the 13th candy bout to be tier 1 fo sure. Just you wait!

 

[seliph]

friday the 13th candy bout to be tier 1 fo sure. Just you wait!

it won't.

 

[Plainbluetees]

it won't.

It’s honestly gonna be middle of the road. I’d be surprised if it even got to uncommonly sold.

 

[seliph]

It’s honestly gonna be middle of the road. I’d be surprised if it even got to uncommonly sold.

there's been trades for pierrot candy so if anything i predict it'll be around there at most, but who knows. def not gonna make t1-t2 though lol

 

[LambdaDelta]

my thoughts are the candy value will drop and settle once the hype factor wears off (esp as 332 is actually quite a lot. only orange, pierrot, and wix candies beat it out in total around. probably purple too, if we count by active users with them)

so kaleidoclover 2.0, in a sense