-
Threads in this board should only be bumped once every four or more hours. Animal Crossing trading belongs in Nook's Cranny and other boards located here, even when using TBT Bells.
collectible tier list ★ (now closed)
- Thread starter mogyay
- Start date
- Status
will.
poke it out
will.'s Creature:
i disagree only because it rarely sells and i’m sure someone could get like 4 or 5k from it
Wildtown
Gone With the Wind
Wildtown's Creature:
i bought one for 2500 (the one in your lineup) and glow is selling one for 2750 i think
Jacob
Senior Member
I think it can sometimes get confusing because this list isn't based on how much a collectible sells for, its more of what collectible trades are worthwhile by taking into account how many [buying] threads there are, how long a [selling] thread takes, and how often the collectibles get displayed or talked about. I think the average prices are there to be helpful for people to compare a large amount of collectibles very easily, but for example, T2 can have collectibles that cost more than 10k or less than 6k. We can maybe also think about taking out the prices entirely from the list
I think with the little amount of members compared to the amount of collectibles, it's becoming impossible to assign an average price to collectibles now. There is data so far and few between that the currency rate can completely change between sales of a Pinwheel for instance.
That being said I also think the flower wand maybe could be moved up in the list
omg why do I care so much
I think with the little amount of members compared to the amount of collectibles, it's becoming impossible to assign an average price to collectibles now. There is data so far and few between that the currency rate can completely change between sales of a Pinwheel for instance.
That being said I also think the flower wand maybe could be moved up in the list
omg why do I care so much
Last edited:
will.
poke it out
will.'s Creature:
wait i just realized i put the data on the tier list and not the spreadsheet OOPS ignore that hehe!!
Coach
mr struggle
Coach's Creature:
Bump 
Nougat
Flapping Floaty Thing
I guess it depends on how much the person with the love ball wants a strange doll, and vice versa?
I'd say yes since the doll is rarer, and potentially as wanted, I think.
- - - Post Merge - - -
was selling a hot feather for 1.5k a mistake
Don't stress about it, some of the collectibles aren't on the right spot anymore. For example I think the Pink Feather should not be as high in the list in my opinion since it does not sell that easily (at least the last few trades/sales I've seen on the forum), but then again the Love Ball should shoot up a tier since it's so coveted and people jump on it when it surfaces.
Nougat
Flapping Floaty Thing
The first Weird Doll sold yesterday for a full glow wand set, a glam feather + a nightmare egg.
Estimated 30k+ in value. That finally gives us a first price point to the first tier
Also, I traded my Strange Doll for a Heart Wand. So I think the Strange Doll could start off in Tier 2, or top of Tier 3.
Estimated 30k+ in value. That finally gives us a first price point to the first tier
Also, I traded my Strange Doll for a Heart Wand. So I think the Strange Doll could start off in Tier 2, or top of Tier 3.
Last edited:
skarmoury
½ sugar
skarmoury's Creature:
I second this! Sold mine for 4700 + pink house, so the price should round up to ~6k in value.
Probably a bottom tier 2.
idiotdoomspiral
=__=
The first Weird Doll sold yesterday for a full glow wand set, a glam feather + a nightmare egg.
Estimated 30k+ in value. That finally gives us a first price point to the first tier
adding to this i think the weird doll is worth around 30-60k. its quite a huge gap since i sold mine for about 30k-40k in value but there have been offers for over 60k. if another one got sold it would be easier to put an accurate value since there would be a way to estimate something between the two. it really depends on what people with weird dolls are looking for.
it's also hard to put estimates on these collectibles as well since most of them haven't been sold for a while, or still rarely get sold
heart glow wand - 6-10k
star glow wand - 15-20k
flower glow wand - 6-8k
glam feather - 6-10k
nightmare egg - 3-3.5k
- Status
