Could you guys help me choose between Reneigh and Quinn?

[DaviddivaD]

If you had to choose one which would It be?

Reneigh:

Quinn:

Faith:

 

[N a t]

I honestly love them both so much that if you also loved them both, I'd maybe make the decision based on who else was on your island? Do you have other horses or birds and do you care for variety? Do you have an island theme? If either of those are even applicable.

 

[Moritz]

Quinn is cute
Reneigh is evil

 

[DaviddivaD]

I honestly love them both so much that if you also loved them both, I'd maybe make the decision based on who else was on your island? Do you have other horses or birds and do you care for variety? Do you have an island theme? If either of those are even applicable.

I have no horses but I have Molly on my island who is a duck. However, she's about to be replaced with Sasha next week. I've been wanting Reneigh since this game came out. However with Quinn out that changes things a little bit. My island has no specific theme. My current Uchi villager is Cherry.

I didn't know Faith was Sisterly/Uchi so I added her to the poll. Might consider her too.

 

[Moonfish]

I picked Faith (for the poll and also my own island) because she is new to me. I have Quinn’s card but I just don’t like eagles in this game. Reneigh is probably my favorite uchi overall though!

 

[Venn]

I would pick Quinn. I'm okay with Reneigh but not a fan of Faith f

 

[N a t]

I have no horses but I have Molly on my island who is a duck. However, she's about to be replaced with Sasha next week. I've been wanting Reneigh since this game came out. However with Quinn out that changes things a little bit. My island has no specific theme. My current Uchi villager is Cherry.

I didn't know Faith was Sisterly/Uchi so I added her to the poll. Might consider her too.

I see, tough choice!! I think I'd probably go with Quinn. They're both really good, and I like Reneigh a lot, but Quinn just looks like a bad girl and I adore that about her. I also love purple so partially biased lol. So I'd say Quinn since Molly is leaving!

 

[Edge]

I have Reneigh on my island and love her. She was one of my starting villagers so I might have a bias.

 

[ivorystar]

faith for sure!

 

[EtchaSketch]

I’d say Reneigh or Faith. I don’t understand the appeal for Quinn, she’s super weird looking imo

 

[moon_child]

I’d say Faith. I’ve seen all of them in game and Faith is super cute I would’ve taken her but unfortunately she doesn’t fit my theme. Faith on a tropical island would be so perfect. Reneigh isn’t bad. I’ve had her. She’s cool. Quinn is also nicely designed but I generally don’t like eagle villagers (except for Apollo) because they scare me a bit.

 

[MelodyRivers]

They all have nice designs. I’ve never had any of them but I voted reneigh because I love horses irl

 

[Violet Witch]

I currently have Reneigh (not my choice) and she’s fun to chat to and I’ve had some great DIY’s from her. If I could pick out of the three I’d take Faith in a heartbeat.

 

[azurill]

From those three I would choose Faith. I like the others but can’t wait to invite Faith to my second island.

 

[Foreverfox]

Reneigh! I have her, I love her design and she's the only sisterly I've managed to actually like. I can't imagine her leaving my island, it would feel wrong.

 

[rip]

i think reneigh is so cute! i love her color palette and edgy details lol. quinn isn’t that bad but a bit boring whereas faith is just cursed

it’s completely up to you though haha.

 

[Croconaw]

I’d go with Quinn. I’m not a fan of Reneigh.

 

[Fridaynightcatlady]

I voted Faith! She’s so cute and she’s back from AC GCN!

 

[Flicky]

I love Quinn, so she gets my vote here! Reneigh is the only one of the NH newcomers that I haven't been interested in.

 

[nightglow]

I voted Quinn simply because she is so new. I do see why people like Reneigh even though I haven't met her, I mean... I really like horses. Sisterly villagers are one of those types I wouldn't mind having two of on my island.
I do wonder if people would like Quinn more if her default clothing was different because it would be a different first impression. I think that jacket is normally seen on Apollo right?