Do you remember your starting five villagers?

[Bloodflowers]

Yep! My original two were Shari and Sly and they were soon joined by Tabby, Poppy and Benedict. Everyone has moved on though I may invite Tabby back at one point.

 

[xlisapisa]

My starting jock was Axel and my starting sisterly was Agnes. I liked both of them but I didn’t end up keeping either of them after I received their photos. My normal, lazy, and peppy villagers were Rhonda, Zucker, and Anabelle. I really miss Zucker, I will probably invite him back to my island one day if we ever cross paths again. The other two I didn’t care too much for, easily replaceable.

 

[Zerous]

My two starters were Agnes and Poncho; I still have Agnes but gave Poncho to a friend to make room for someone else took me ages to force myself to let him go tho. Then my first three islander villagers I found were Piper and Punchy, who I still have and adore, and Skye, who I got rid of when I got to the point of having 3 normal villagers lol.

 

[inazuma]

Two starters are muffy and lyman, three plots were Zucker, Marina, and Pango! Only Pango are gone now xD

 

[niko@kamogawa]

I still remember them all clearly as if they were in my island yesterday.

I regretted hitting Rex with a net. That was really cruel of me to force him into moving out. He ended up in the void.
Someone adopted Muffy here! She's in good hands.
No one wanted Celia and Penelope!
It's hard to move Antonio! He's the reason why I began to dislike jock villagers. He also ended up in the void.

 

[Bugs]

My starters were Mac and Renée, then the first three moving in were Tia, Stitches and Bangle

 

[HappyTails]

My starters were Lyman and Cherry. I got Simon, Bangle, and Carrie from the Mystery Island. Those were my first five villagers, Cherry and Simon have since moved away though.

Helped that 4 of their names rhymed: Cherry and Carrie, Lyman and Simon. XD

 

[tiffanistarr]

Coach and Reneigh were my two starters, then I got Zucker, Marina, and Ruby I think.

Coach and Ruby have stuck around.

 

[EerieCreatures]

My starters were Renée and Genji, and I know two of my first three were Piper and Beau, and I want to say the last one was Ava, but I'm honestly not sure. I know I had her pretty early though.

 

[Slothicans]

.

 

[jvgsjeff]

My starters were Louie and Shari. My first three plots went to Marcel, Midge, and Agent S. Of those five, I still have Louie, Midge, and Agent S. But I am going to let Midge move out the next time she asks.

 

[TheMagicIf]

Two out of five of my starting villagers are still on my island! Flip and Katt were my starters, and I found Flora, Bertha, and Egbert on Mystery Island Tours.

I'll most likely let Flora move out when she next asks, as I'd like to invite sisterly villager since Katt has been my only one. I don't know if I could ever part with Katt though. There's just so few sisterly villagers at it is, and I would hate to give her the boot only to not be able to connect with any of the other sisterlies.

 

[Serabee]

-Tammy and Sheldon were my first two (neither are favorites of mine, Tammy is cute but there are so many ursine sisterlies I prefer)
-Merry (had her for MONTHS and did a big photoshoot when she left, I just downloaded Pocket Camp and she's now my... manager thing in that, she is just utterly delightful)
-Erik (also kept him for months, such a cutie, and I actually preferred his starter house over his "real" one when I saw it online)
-Megan (didn't realize she was new, but found her rather boring compared to the tons of incredibly precious normals out there)

I remember them all well, though most didn't last long. Except Merry and Erik ☺
(controversial opinion: Merry is the best peppy cat and kicks Rosie's tail)

EDIT: OH! And my first forced camper was Graham. I was super excited because I had him for awhile in ACNL and I just think he's such a cute smug. My BFF, though, upon seeing I had him was like "I'm so sorry" and I was so confused I guess there's a solid amount of online hate for him? But I love him and kept him for quite awhile!

 

[moonchu]

ahh let's see . . . think my first five in order were genji, agnes, filbert, victoria, and skye.
genji, filbert, and skye are all still in my town!

 

[StarlitGlitch]

I kept a daily journal for a year so I know everyone who went in and out of my island during that time!

I'm too lazy to write them all down but out of the first five Flurry is the only one still on my island.

 

[Hsn97]

I had Mira and Biff as my first two and then Twiggy, Marina and Big Top as my three move ins. Out of those five, I still have Mira and Twiggy.

 

[Lulucrossing]

I had to go and look through pictures because it was so long ago but my starters were Pashmina, which I remembered and Iggly(completely forgot about him and I feel bad). First 3 move in were Stitches, Chrissy and Gayle!

 

[BigBadButterfree]

I certainly remember them well, it took a lot of convincing myself to let them leave well, I still have the very first two, Billy and Plucky. The other three were Carrie, Tucker, and Wendy! I'd gladly let any of them back onto the island in the future!

 

[your local goomy]

I've had three islands throughout my time on ACNH, and remember my starters for all of them!

For my first island, my starters were Dom and Flo, and the 3 who moved in were Drago, Winnie, and Merengue. Unfortunately I reset that island pretty early on, right when I was really growing attached to Winnie and Dom.

My second island, my starters were Shari and Antonio, and the ones who moved in were Audie, Sherb, and Megan...and tbh, I really regret resetting that island because I love all 5 of them, though Shari did move and was replaced by Reneigh.

For my latest island, my starters are Phoebe and Hamlet, and I don't know who's moving in yet, though I did invite Bangle. Not sure about the lazy or normal yet.

 

[Darth Savage]

Lets see Started of with
Snake - Rabbit
Agnes - Pig

Next 3 were
Deva - Frog
Lucky - Dog
Tammy - Cub

And this is why I keep a spreadsheet LOL