Favorite Horse Villager

[Sweetley]

I'm curious and would like to know which horse villager is your favorite and why.

I was at first not such a big fan of the horse villagers, mainly because I didn't find any one of them so appealing. After I while however, I started to like Roscoe more and later also Colton. Cleo is also kinda cute, but I never had the chance to invite her into my town when I stilled played New Leaf back then. And although Filly seems to be one of the "superhero" villagers, I must say I don't find her not as cool as the others, mainly because IMO her design doesn't match so good along with those of Kid Cat, Agent S, Big Top and Rocket.

[Something went wrong while posting the thread, hence why the poll here doesn't have all horses listed, sorry.]

 

[MapleCake]

Papi and Julian!
They're the cutest of all the horses in my opinion.

 

[LadyDestani]

I'm going to go with Roscoe because he's the only horse villager I've ever had in my town and he's really cool. I already liked his look before he ever moved in.

I also like the look of Papi and Savannah and wouldn't mind getting to know them.

 

[BluebearL]

Papi is soooooo cute! I have never had Papi before but I have always loved the look of him. Roscoe is pretty cool to but I'd say Papi for the win

 

[Halloqueen]

My favorite Horse villager would probably have to be Julian. Since I'm a fan of designs with unique aspects, you don't really get much more unique than Julian being a unicorn. Plus, he has the Smug personality, my favorite male personality type. I had him living in one town for years, then decided that he would fit better in my hybrid circus/magic show-themed town, leaning more on the magical aspect rather than the circus one, and moved him into that town instead. Love having him around. Unfortunately it's not the exact same Julian since both towns involved in this scenario are on the same 3DS, so direct adoption would've been impossible and shuffling him across my other towns would've been a hassle. Had initially wanted to keep that original one because he had a unique personality trait, seeming to collect very small things, like seahorses. Regardless, he's great.

Second favorite is Savannah, due to her zebra design.

Third favorite is Victoria, due to her mask and name. While she's likely supposed to be more of a reference to racehorses, I prefer to imagine her as a luchador/masked wrestler, like Lucha the Smug Bird villager.

Honorable mentions go to Annalise, Cleo, Colton, and Roscoe. Annalise has a cute design and it's unfortunate that she doesn't fit any of the themes my towns are based around, since she'd be nice to have. Cleo has been living in my GameCube town since the early days and I have memories of her thanks to that, so she slides by on nostalgia. I had Colton in one of my towns for a while and replaced him since he didn't fit the theme, but he was enjoyable while he was there. Finally, I've never had him in a town, but I like Roscoe's Cranky personality, his overall design including the red eyes, and the interior design of his house looks pretty great.

 

[Snowesque]

Elmer! I have had him in my town before and he was an enjoyable villager. I would of liked for him to stay, but there just is not enough room unfortunately!

 

[rhinoo]

Papi he has such a cool name.

 

[duckykate]

papi!! he's so adorable

 

[Alyx]

Annalise & Savannah. Annalise because she's interesting and cute, Savannah because she looks like a zebra and I love zebras.

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

I like Julian the best, even though he's not technically a horse by design. Unicorns for the win!

 

[AlyssaAC]

Cleo, Colton, Filly, Julian, Papi, Peaches, and Winnie are my favorites. I really love horses in real life and my favorite kind of horse color I like it white, so Colton would be my top pick if I was going for a town with certain animal villagers in it. Other than Colton, I really love Julian and he would be my top pick for a smug villager in my town. Cleo and Peaches I really like based off of color and think both of them are really adorable.

 

[seliph]

no poll for this one huh

i think it's safe to say my favourite horse overall is colton. i'm a sucker for regal aesthetics and he looks like a royal palace horse with that blue ringmaster coat on, i love his little blushed cheeks too and his pink nose, and the nice blue accents. i just kind of wish he wasn't a smug villager, i understand it makes sense with the whole being royal and elegant thing but i'd rather he have been lazy.

 

[cornimer]

Elmer is my boy <3 he gives me homey and nostalgic vibes.

 

[DubiousDelphine]

colton, papi (then i accidently deleted that town, rip papi)
I just met epona, she wasnt so bad

Cleo in my Gamecube animal crossing game thought my mail to her was mean although all i wrote was
like "Hi, welcome to this town" or something like that lol
i dont mind her in my town lol

 

[Stalfos]

Meh, we don't need a poll to know that Savannah is number 1!

Just like with Gaston, Savannah is a villager that has always been with me since the first game.

 

[gobby]

Oh, dude, Julian for sure

 

[Emolga59]

Annalise is my favorite horse villager (I don't know why.)

 

[carackobama]

Julian is my favourite male villager period so definitely him <3

 

[Mayor Monday]

Roscoe and Peaches. Strangely enough, lol. Horses like Julian or Colten are a bit too flashy, just in my opinion.

 

[Nunnafinga]

Yeah,Colton might look flashy but after he's been in your town for a while,you realize that he's just as dorky as the other smugs.His original top is the blue ringmaster shirt which I like but I think it's a bit too ornate and he looks better in more casual clothes.