This should be a poll
And alright, I'll say it: Zucker
I know he's popular but it's cute how he's the most unlucky octopus ever ^^
Octopus would make more sense in "Favorite octopus villager"
Octopi/Octopuses/Octopodes would make more sense if the title were "Favorite octopi villagers"
For me, Zucker, for resembling a food that has octopus in it, and for having a house that's a conveyor belt sushi bar. That sort of humor reminds me of Lucky and Boots.