When I first voted on this poll I picked Rhonda. Not sure what 2018 me found so appealing about her (not that I dislike her or anything). Today I've taken a liking to Hornsby. I almost invited him onto my island but decided against it in favor of Alfonso.
Merengue was one of my first New Leaf villagers so she's really nostalgic! She was such a sweetheart and I still miss her. I don't really like any of the other rhino villagers ngl.
Renee is likely my favourite. I had her as a starter (I think) in NH but gave her up for Merengue and I regret it so much I thought her personality would be more fun than it is, even for a normal