First villager that comes to mind

[Goldi Locks]

Judy I bet. Unless she felt she relate' to the main character somehow. Then she'd cry.

A villager who would steal a package from your doorstep and not even feel bad about it.

 

[coffeeplant]

Hamphrey, for some reason.

A villager who knits hats and scarves for all of their neighbours.

 

[. Rarity .]

Well its the first who comes to mind so, Sasha. At least he'd try

A villager who would likily go looking for you if you were missing

 

[Hunter_Gr33n]

Moe
A villager who would write a lot of fanfiction as a secret hobby.

 

[-Blue-]

Buck, but it would be about some buff dude exercising on his quest all the time. And he'd also explain that it's to train his finger muscles with pencil grip and writing. And also brain muscles cause writing fancy words is hard.

A villager who wastes a lot of time watching stupid internet videos and scrolling endlessly.

 

[coffeeplant]

Tabby, 100%.

A villager that'd move in with you if they could.

 

[Hunter_Gr33n]

O'Hare.
A villager who would probably read this very forum.

 

[Goldi Locks]

Megan. Probably whilst at work.
A villager with a deep internal struggle?

 

[coffeeplant]

Frett.

A villager who loves science fiction?

 

[Zerous]

Cephalobot

A villager who plays the drums

 

[. Rarity .]

Chief

A villager who would ptotect you

 

[Zerous]

Walt

A villager who would be into mmos

 

[QueenCobra]

Mira? (Idk why though)

A villager who practices witchcraft.

 

[coffeeplant]

Muffy.

A villager who's secretly rich?

 

[QueenCobra]

Gala (she looks like a piggy bank)

A villager who loves board games?

 

[Hunter_Gr33n]

Mitzi somehow comes to mind.
A villager who would worry excessively about minor details.

 

[coffeeplant]

Raymond.

A villager who gives the worst fashion advice?

 

[ZeldaCrossing64]

Ruby.

A villager who enjoys heavy metal music.

 

[CozyVillager]

Cherry!

A villager that collects books?

 

[coffeeplant]

Melba.

A villager who always cries while watching The Lion King?