Have you ever betrayed your favourite villager?

[Moritz]

My favourite villager is Tybalt
I think

The update brought tiansheng
And I adore him
Hes perfect in every way
Even his fitness hobby I hate on everyone else is so adorable on him. I thought it would make me dislike him. Makes me love him more.

So right now, I'm not even sure I really want tybalt back on my new island. Because I had him for a year, and now there is a new man in town.

Have you ever found a new favourite and then ignored the old?

 

[N a t]

Yes. Cleo. I kicked her out of my island simply because her house didn't fit the island theme even though I love Cleo, I just felt like I'd lose my mind if the houses didn't match... and then someone discovered that we were able to change villager exteriors now and posted it online. I'm bringing Cleo back to my island, but I still feel like the worst virtual friend ever. Even if she can't remember lol.

 

[Fey]

100% when I initially deleted/reset my Island. Katt, Antonio, Lolly, Beau…I ghosted them all for months only to then destroy their home. Gosh I’m the worst.

(this may be one of the reasons I’m not planning on having any of them in my new game. Too much guilt)

 

[EmmaFrost]

Rosie is my fave cat besides Tangy and I betrayed her by kicking her out and letting my partner adopt her. I have her amiibo card, he doesn’t.

 

[Croconaw]

Mac is my favorite villager. I love my jock dog. I won’t ever betray him.

 

[Flicky]

Worst I've done to any of my long-term/favourite villagers was agree to send a gift and then, after opening it, deciding not to give it to the other villager. No, Claude, I do not want to see Phoebe walking around in a Hot Dog costume.

 

[Rosch]

Does this count?

Rolf is one of my all-time faves but I kicked him out with an amiibo to have Static, whom I later replaced with Marlo. But I can call him back again with amiibo though.

 

[Moritz]

Does this count?

Rolf is one of my all-time faves but I kicked him out with an amiibo to have Static, whom I later replaced with Marlo. But I can call him back again with amiibo though.

Yeah totally!
I have tybalts amiibo
I make my own amiibos
But I bought his legit card as I love him so much

I got a custom made plush of tybalt as I love him so much

I could amiibo him on to my new island
I just don't know I want to

 

[xSuperMario64x]

I had Leopold in my original NH island and he obv disappeared with it. I just found him in the campsite on my new island a few days ago but I didn't invite him. I kinda feel bad cause he's my favorite but I also have him in the gamecube AC as well as in NL.

 

[Jassiii]

Yes. Cleo. I kicked her out of my island simply because her house didn't fit the island theme even though I love Cleo, I just felt like I'd lose my mind if the houses didn't match... and then someone discovered that we were able to change villager exteriors now and posted it online. I'm bringing Cleo back to my island, but I still feel like the worst virtual friend ever. Even if she can't remember lol.

THIS! Vesta is my all time favorite villager and booted her from my island because of her house + the interior...and then 2.0/dlc made it possible to customize both...

Getting her back as soon as I'm able.

 

[Millysaurusrexjr]

I love all my villagers but I'm probably going to replace 90% of them. After a year even the dreamies can get old. So why not freshen things up with some new peeps?!

That said, it will be hard replacing Punchy but I really want to go for a new villager theme on my island.

 

[Snek]

He's not my favourite, but I really liked Julian. He was on my island for almost a whole year. In my pursuit to kick out a certain void villager, I sacrificed him in order to get my ultimate dreamie. It certainly was a betrayal, because there were many other villagers I could have kicked out, but I decided that I was ok to let Julian go. I still feel bad about it, so if I ever encounter Julian again while island hopping I may just invite him back.

 

[Moonlight.]

i wanted to fill my island with villagers i had a lot of nostalgia for, which meant kicking out a decent amount of my current favorites. one of which was bianca, my actual favorite villager. yeah, the whole idea was thrown out the window pretty fast because it felt so odd not seeing her walking around my island (same with not seeing freya around). even the idea of swapping out villagers once i get their photo would be weird for me, i've grown too attached to some of them lol

 

[Marshmallows]

So despite being one of my top favorites, and the best in NL, I kicked Coco out of my town in the first months of the game. I had too many normals, and for some reason just wasn't clicking with her like I did in NL.... maybe because she seemed so cold compared to my NL town, maybe because her ears didn't move like the other bunnies, maybe it was the silly glasses (though I kind of find that funny now.) I don't know, but I could have done more to befriend her.

I'm thinking of bringing her back. Fill her house with gyroids and maybe she'll liven up a bit. But I already have 2 normals that I love (Marina and Fauna.)
I have her in Pocket Camp, at least.

 

[inazuma]

I really really adore Marshal even before i have animal crossing lol. HE IS THE CUTEST and THE FLUFFIEST of em all. but then i saw this orange cub online and like, who are you? It was Pudge. HE IS THE CUTEST and THE FLUFFIEST of em all. sorry Marshal. youre still here but Pudge is now my son.


did i ever told you i also really love Chief? yes. At the first time, Marshal is the most quirky and cool of em all, but, IM SO SORRY. Chief just took that badge. He is now my husband. Sorry Marshal, youre in the third place now. (i just really really LOVE chief)


Once i get Ace to move in, youre no longer in the stage, Marshal! Gahahah. Just kidding. No, im serious.

Spoiler: MORE pics

(also he's so overrated but i still love him)

 

[sn0wxyuki]

I guiltily admit I had Raymond betrayed. I once TT hardcore to find him in my campsite only to decide I would let him go for NMT as well as new face. The only one and only I wouldn't even let go is Barold. Judy for now remaining but not sure when I would change my heart towards her. I love how 16 cycles being removed so I have no miss towards any of them after they give me that photo aka visa to leave. Also with the HHP i invite all of them to my island so at least I can still visit and see them there, no one is permanent now except my Barold.

 

[Bilaz]

I replaced Lolly with Tabby in my City Folk town because LOLLY ABANDONED ME lol but then Tabby abandoned me too, so I made up with Lolly and she’s on my island now

Post automatically merged: Nov 19, 2021

I replaced Lolly with Tabby in my City Folk town because LOLLY ABANDONED ME lol but then Tabby abandoned me too, so I made up with Lolly and she’s on my island now

 

[Sarah3]

Definitely not! Once I finally have a villager I really love, they're stuck with me forever! Want to move? Nope! Try again.

 

[geo-mew]

I'm about to betray Punchy lol. I invited his best friend Bob to our island (and grew to love him). However. Sasha stole my heart and will be replacing Bob as I can't stand having 3 lazies.

My friend had Bob and reluctantly let him go, so I think he will be happy on her island <3

 

[. Rarity .]

I had Genji leave, so I could move in Sasha, i was so sad when he did leave. I had lots of fond memories with him.