Have you ever had a town that was made up of one personality? how was it?

[mizzsnow]

was just thinking about how all my favorites end up being peppy villagers and I was wondering how feasible it would be to have my ACNH town be a single personality type

 

[axaniao]

was just thinking about how all my favorites end up being peppy villagers and I was wondering how feasible it would be to have my ACNH town be a single personality type

I've never done that before but let me just say that would probably get annoying reaaaaaal quick.

 

[Mairmalade]

I've never done that before but let me just say that would probably get annoying reaaaaaal quick.

Agreed. Never done it because I like having more than one set of unique interactions, Adds more life to the game.

I have had all the same species though.

 

[Nami]

I would never consider that, but I know that a lot of my favorites are normal and peppy types. That said, I really try to keep my town balanced on personalities. It's the only reason I havent made a cat only town, because there isnt an uchi cat and only one jock cat. Plus there are other villagers I really like, so yeah...

 

[axaniao]

I would never consider that, but I know that a lot of my favorites are normal and peppy types. That said, I really try to keep my town balanced on personalities. It's the only reason I havent made a cat only town, because there isnt an uchi cat and only one jock cat. Plus there are other villagers I really like, so yeah...

There's 3 jock cats and a uchi cat actually

 

[Clock]

I feel like if my town was filled with one personality, dialogue would be super repetitive and you will get annoyed easily. Which is why it’s nicer to have balance, at least 1-2 with the same personality for me is fine.

 

[Seastar]

The closest I've gotten is a town with 4 normal villagers. I cannot imagine being able to stand having 10... Talking to them every morning just to learn if anyone is trying to move is already annoying enough!

 

[Nami]

There's 3 jock cats and a uchi cat actually

Wait, really? I'll have to look that up! Good chance I may not be a fan of one or more, but thanks for the tip!