Help Me Pick A New Villager!

[Hay]

Hi there!

I’m getting rid of Sherb today and can’t decide on what villager to replace him with. I currently have no peppy or uchi villager so I’m aiming for one of them but have in mind a few others.. I just can’t narrow it down and decide.

Here is my list for who I’m looking at for potential new villagers:
-Tangy (my native fruit is orange after all!)
-Wendy
-Octavian (he is a cranky but he’s very cute imo)
-Diana (very close to saying no to her but I love her design)

What do y’all think? Let me know. Thanks! <3

EDIT: Narrowed my list due to feedback! Thanks guys c:​

 

[Rosewater]

Tangy and Octavian are good choices! If you're looking for an uchi, maybe Phoebe would pique your interest? I think she looks really cool.

 

[Hay]

Tangy and Octavian are good choices! If you're looking for an uchi, maybe Phoebe would pique your interest? I think she looks really cool.

I’ve been looking at her too.. I’m not 100% hooked since I don’t like her color combo but she is definitely an option too! I’ve never met her in any of my AC games so maybe that’s it

 

[hikaricities]

I personally love Wendy because I have a soft spot for the sheep villagers! Also, since you listed two deer villagers, I assume you like them! So, how about going with Deirdre for an uchi villager? I like her design more than Fuchsia tbh because Fuchsia's design IS super cool but I agree that her pink is too... pink lol. Diana and Octavian are nice as well but my vote is for Wendy or Fuchsia/Deirdre! Although honestly, you can't go wrong with any of your choices

 

[Altarium]

Sprinkle is very cute, definitely one of my favorite peppies. I think both her and Wendy would fit your town nicely considering your other villagers!

 

[Hay]

I personally love Wendy because I have a soft spot for the sheep villagers! Also, since you listed two deer villagers, I assume you like them! So, how about going with Deirdre for an uchi villager? I like her design more than Fuchsia tbh because Fuchsia's design IS super cool but I agree that her pink is too... pink lol. Diana and Octavian are nice as well but my vote is for Wendy or Fuchsia/Deirdre! Although honestly, you can't go wrong with any of your choices

Ah I totally forgot about Deirdre! :c thank you! I wish Fushia was like Diana and have more than just a base color with little design, I would like her more.

Post automatically merged: May 9, 2020

Sprinkle is very cute, definitely one of my favorite peppies. I think both her and Wendy would fit your town nicely considering your other villagers!

So far it’s looking like Wendy might be it! Sprinkle is very cute and I’ve never had a penguin villager before so she’s up there! Thanks!

 

[kylie32123]

Ahh Tangy is a great peppy choice! I had her in NL and absolutely loved her. I was thinking on having her as my peppy a while back, but that's before I knew about Audie. I'd still choose her, though! Plus diana is a total sweetheart and I'm a sucker for snootys, but at the moment I currently have 3 of them (including diana) and I'd like to replace her with Whitney maybe (for a friend!) Those 2 are my favs from your list and you can't go wrong with either!

 

[Cnydaquil]

i think tangy!

 

[Hay]

Ahh Tangy is a great peppy choice! I had her in NL and absolutely loved her. I was thinking on having her as my peppy a while back, but that's before I knew about Audie. I'd still choose her, though! Plus diana is a total sweetheart and I'm a sucker for snootys, but at the moment I currently have 3 of them (including diana) and I'd like to replace her with Whitney maybe (for a friend!) Those 2 are my favs from your list and you can't go wrong with either!

Thanks for the input! I’m gonna go hunting soon and I’ve definitely got my eye on her

 

[Vextro]

I think Tangy would be great! She is very unique and you cannot go wrong with peppy villagers! they are so cute

 

[Chachamaru]

Wendy or diana. Wendy is someone im considring to replace gala. 3 normals is way too boring in one town..

 

[Hay]

Wendy or diana. Wendy is someone im considring to replace gala. 3 normals is way too boring in one town..

that’s how I feel with my lazies.. I have 4 rn including Sherb

 

[kojuuro]

I had Tangy on my island and I love her! I think it's cute she'd match your native fruit too. Sprinkle and Diana are both cute too for snooty villagers (and their houses look really amazing)!

 

[Hay]

I had Tangy on my island and I love her! I think it's cute she'd match your native fruit too. Sprinkle and Diana are both cute too for snooty villagers (and their houses look really amazing)!

I’ve never had tangy and everyone seems to like her; I’m excited! Thank you for your input

 

[Xara]

tangy! she was the first villager i ever encountered in wild world and she’s such a cutie! you can’t go wrong with sprinkle, either ;w;

 

[Bcat]

Vote one for Tangy! Orange islands represent!

 

[Hay]

tangy! she was the first villager i ever encountered in wild world and she’s such a cutie! you can’t go wrong with sprinkle, either ;w;

Omg really? How cute! I’m waiting to TT since servers are down ATM, so I’m gonna have to wait to go hunting :c

 

[salem_]

I had Wendy for a bit, she was very sweet! Always watering my flowers, crafting me things and giving me gifts even if i didnt talk too much with her!

 

[Hay]

Vote one for Tangy! Orange islands represent!

I don’t need a peach island, orange clan!

Post automatically merged: May 9, 2020

I had Wendy for a bit, she was very sweet! Always watering my flowers, crafting me things and giving me gifts even if i didnt talk too much with her!

She’s in my top 3 for sure, I love her design she’s so cute

 

[Arithmophobia17]

i adore fuchsia, and for reference i'm not a huge fan of pink either but i love her somewhat edgy vibe